Love or nothing: The real Greek parallel with Weimar

Athenians sitting in front of anti-government graffiti

Of all the operas written during Germany's Weimar Republic (1919-33), probably the most haunting is the last.

Kurt Weill's The Silver Lake, written with playwright Georg Kaiser, tells the story of two losers - a good-hearted provincial cop and the thief he has shot and wounded - as they make their way through a society ruined by unemployment, corruption and vice.

After spending a week again in Greece - amid riots, hunger and far right violence - I finally understood it.

The opera was meant to be Weill's path back into the mainstream. It was his first break from collaborating with Bertolt Brecht, and was scheduled to open simultaneously in three German cities on 18 February 1933.

But on 30 January Adolf Hitler was appointed Germany's chancellor.

The first performances of The Silver Lake were disrupted by Nazi activists in the audience and on 4 March 1933 it was banned. The score was torched, together with its set designs, in the infamous book-burning ceremony outside the opera house in Berlin.

It is easy to see why the Nazis didn't like The Silver Lake. Weill was Jewish; the Nazi theatre critics found the music "ugly and sick". Moreover the plot contains an allegory of the political situation on the eve of the Nazis' rise to power.

But there has always been something else about The Silver Lake that goes beyond politics. Something hard to fathom.

Spending time in Greece, as the far right Golden Dawn party breaks up theatre performances with impunity, and street violence is common, I finally know what that something is.

The Silver Lake is ultimately about how people feel when they switch from resistance to hopelessness. And about how strangely liberating hopelessness can be.

Greece right now is a place with a lot of hopelessness. Its own prime minister, Antonis Samaras, has compared its atmosphere to that of the Weimar Republic.

"Greek democracy stands before what is perhaps its greatest challenge," Mr Samaras told the German newspaper Handelsblatt. He said social cohesion is "endangered by rising unemployment, just as it was toward the end of the Weimar Republic in Germany".

The comparison seems plausible: there are far right gangs meting out violence on the streets - a report last week identified more than half of all officially recorded racial attacks as perpetrated by people in paramilitary uniforms. Every demonstration ends with tear gas and baton charges.

There is mass unemployment. There is the collapse of mainstream parties. The press and broadcast media are struggling to remain independent, indeed solvent.

Yet the comparison with the "end of Weimar" only holds if you know nothing about the Weimar Republic itself.

Sadly this condition is common. School students are rightly taught lots about Nazi Germany - but not very much about the detail of how it came into being.

Here's a short summary. In the elections of 1928 the Nazis, who had - like Golden Dawn in Greece - been reduced to a splinter group in the years of economic recovery, got just 2.7%.

But in March 1930, as the Wall Street Crash cratered the German economy, a cross-party coalition government of the centre left and right collapsed. It was replaced by the first of three "appointed" governments - designed to avoid either the communists or the now-growing Nazis gaining power.

It was led by Heinrich Bruning. Faced with a recession, Bruning followed a policy of austerity, while keeping Germany's currency pegged to the Gold Standard (much as Greece as follows a policy of austerity dictated by euro membership). This made the recession worse.

As unemployment rocketed, so did the Nazi vote: in a shock breakthrough they came second in the elections of September 1930, with 18%. But Bruning was determined to crack down on both the right and left: he banned the Nazi paramilitary organisation, the sturmabteilung, along with the rival communist uniformed militia.

As recession worsened, the Nazis grew massively: they won the election in 1932, gaining 14 million votes (37%). The socialists and communists combined polled higher. And the parties of the centre collapsed. Yet the presidential system of appointing governments now allowed these very centrist parties to go on ruling Germany - now under a new Chancellor, the aristocrat Franz Von Papen.

Von Papen unbanned the Nazi stormtroopers in June 1932 and, as historian Ian Kershaw puts it in his definitive biography of Hitler: "The latent civil war… was threatening to become an actual civil war."

By the end of 1932, with the communists now also growing rapidly, the political establishment made one last final attempt to keep Hitler out of power. Right wing general Kurt Von Schleicher was appointed chancellor, and tried to form a government with everybody from the left wing of the Nazis to the socialist trade unions. But this too fell, opening the door to Hitler.

Kershaw wrote: "Only crass errors by the country's rulers could open up a path [for Hitler]. And only a blatant disregard by Germany's power elites for safeguarding democracy - in fact, the hope that economic crisis could be used as a vehicle to bring about democracy's demise and replace it by a form of authoritarianism - could induce such errors. Precisely this is what happened." (Hitler: Hubris)

These names - Bruning, von Papen, Schleicher - troublesome though they are to remember, should be as famous as the words Stalingrad, Arnhem and Dunkirk.

These were the men who tried and failed to use a mixture of austerity, tough policing and what we might now call "technocratic" rule to save German democracy. They failed.

And herein lies the parallel with Greece: a country committed to austerity, whose centrist parties are clustered into a coalition which represents the forces of conservatism and social democracy. The coalition sees itself as the last bulwark against a government of the far left and is trying to crack down on extremism using a police force which has itself been criticised for extremist leanings.

But despite these parallels, Greece is not on the brink of a Weimar-style collapse.

Nor is it "in civil war" as claimed by a leader of the far right Golden Dawn movement on Newsnight last week. If anything, Greece has levels of instability and political radicalisation close to the levels seen in Germany in early 1930, not late 1933.

The problem is: Greece is approaching 1933 levels of economic collapse.

Unemployment was 30% in Germany when Hitler took power; it is 25.1% and rising in Greece. GDP collapsed by about 7% in both 1931 and 1932 in Germany. Its current rate of collapse in Greece is roughly the same: 7% per year. Germany's banks had gone bust in 1931. Greek banks are effectively part nationalised already.

You can see the physical impact of this on Stadiou Street in Athens. I have reported from there numerous times in the past two and a half years, but this last time it looked desolate.

There was an arcade where, just over a year ago, I remember blogging about how small specialist businesses in Greece were doomed: the pen shop, the stamp collecting shop, the stationary store. They're all gone now.

So is much of the street itself. The Art Nouveau cinema burned out last year; the Marfin Bank, next door, torched with the deaths of three workers during a riot in 2010.

On the walls somebody has spray-canned "Love or Nothing". Right now there is a heck of a lot of nothing: shops closed, stripped, barred, graffitied, the fascias chipped off as ammunition in riots, burned out, gone.

And nowhere is the human impact of this weird situation, clearer than when you talk to young people.

I met Yiannis and Maria in a bare flat in Exarchia, the bohemian district of Athens. Despite their bruises and bandages they took some persuading to go on camera - anonymously and in their hoodies - to put on record their allegations of brutality in police custody.

What struck me, beyond their allegations (which are denied by the police, but partially corroborated by a coroner's report), was their detachment from regular life.

They expected the police to be brutal, and to be fascists. They were outraged that they'd had to listen (they allege) to Golden Dawn propaganda in the police cells. But they were reluctant to bring a complaint within the system.

For tens of thousands of young people life is already lived in a semi-underground way: squatting instead of renting; cadging food and roll-ups from their friends. Drifting back to their grandparents villages, sofa surfing. Yiannis is a sporadically employed technician in a cultural industry; Maria a highly qualified professional who waits table.

The British author Laurie Penny has captured the situation in a recent memoir of a trip to Athens: "We came here expecting riots. Instead we found ourselves looking at what happens when riots die away and horrified inertia sets in." (Penny L and Crabapple M, Discordia, Random House 2012)

Horrified inertia is now seeping from the world of the semi-outlawed young activists into the lives of ordinary people.

What people do - whether it is the black-hoodied anarchists in Athens or the young farmers in Thessaly on their third of fourth bottle of beer by lunchtime - is retreat into the personal.

It's no longer "the personal is political" - but the personal instead of the political. True, demonstrators still turn out in large numbers, as in last week's General Strike. But they go through the motions - of demonstrating, of rioting even.

"It's just for show on both sides, the cops and the anarchists," I was told by my Greek fixer as we legged it through stampeding people and tear gas.

A year ago the buzzword was "anomie" - the fear of anomic breakdown, in which small groups and communities just give up on law and order and make their own. I reported on it then:

Watch Paul's report on anomic breakdown from September 2011

There is not even much anomic activism anymore; the movement that defied road tolls and disrupted the sale of repossessed homes - which was large in the Spring - is tiny now.

If anything captures the buzzword of late 2012 in Greece it is the person who sprayed the slogan "Love or Nothing". It's less about anomie, more about depression.

What has depressed much of Greek society - from the liberal centre right to the liberal left - is the rapid rise of Golden Dawn.

In the two elections of May/June 2012 it scored between 6-7%. Nothing like a 1930-style breakthrough.

But it has begun to do DIY law enforcement against migrants with no intervention from the police. At street markets in Messolonghi and Rafina its uniformed activists checked the permits of migrant stallholders, demonstratively destroying those who did not have permits.

With electoral data showing - on one count - 45% police personnel voting for Golden Dawn, there is rising concern that support for the far right is beginning to skew the operational priorities of the police at local level.

When I challenged Golden Dawn's second in command, Ilias Panagiotaros, he claimed support within the police at "60% or more". And he gave a chilling explanation of how Golden Dawn's extra-judicial actions were affecting the rule of law. Referring to the market stall attacks he said:

"With one incident, which was on camera, the problem was solved - in every open market all over Greece illegal immigrants disappeared. There was some pushing and some fighting - nothing extraordinary, nothing special - only with one phone call saying Golden Dawn is going to pass by the police is going there meaning the brand name [of Golden Dawn] is very effective…"

Greece, in truth, has a massive and apparent problem with illegal migration. The centres of many cities are - or were until this summer - full of young, male migrants from Afghanistan, Somalia, Sudan and increasingly Syria.

Many Greeks do fear them, and they perceive them as a threat to social order and a traditional lifestyle - in a country that never had any colonies and therefore did not experience high ethnic diversity until recently.

The new policy - known as "Hospitable Zeus" is to round migrants up and put them in camps: police in plain clothes or uniforms visibly stopping every person of colour on the street, checking their papers, and if the papers are not in order processing them ultimately to a migrant detention camp.

Even as human rights groups protest this, and demand access to the camps, Golden Dawn has protested outside them on the grounds that conditions are too good there, and that deportations are not fast enough (about six thousand have been detained, with maybe three thousand deported). And even as the police round up the migrants, Golden Dawn's policy is to terrorise them off the streets, and mount a legal campaign against companies who employ them.

The Greek media, meanwhile, has taken its cue to reinforce the association of migrants with crime. For those seeking an alternative view there are only the newspapers of the far left: the main liberal newspaper - Eleftheropia, an equivalent to the Guardian - went bust and has closed.

Economically, the Greek coalition is getting ready to impose the latest and last round of austerity: 13.5bn euro a year cuts and tax rises, in order to release 31bn euro worth of bailout money.

The moment it puts this to parliament we can expect a big and unruly protest. After that the Coalition just has to hold on and hope that its own electoral support does not go the way the German centrist parties went after 1932.

Unfortunately for them, however, electoral support is slipping. While New Democracy has maintained its poll rating at 27% (compared to 29% in the election), Pasok - the former governing socialist party - is down to 5.5%, neck and neck with coalition partner Democratic Left. The combined poll rating of the pro-austerity parties is now 38%.

Golden Dawn polled 14% last week, while the left wing Syriza party is leading the polls at 30% (taking many votes from the Communists, who are now down to 5%).

However, these poll ratings are unlikely to be tested in an election anytime soon. The EU is working overtime to keep the current coalition together, and as Pasok's support dwindles to rock bottom, it has no incentive to risk an election now.

So for the majority of people who want the austerity to stop, and who do not want to be gassed, truncheoned, menaced or even to go on strike, there is only the "love or nothing" strategy.

Anecdotally the use of anti-depressants is rising. Penny's book tells numerous tales of former political activists simply stunned by drink and drugs.

Which brings us back to The Silver Lake.

The "love interest" in Kurt Weill's opera doesn't start until the second half, with the arrival of Fennimore, a young woman trapped in a castle with the two losers and a scheming, reactionary aristocrat who has duped them out of their money.

Once Fennimore appears, the music becomes mesmerised and lyrical; it focuses on the combined hopelessness of the two men and the girl.

And in the final sequence - a dream-like 15 minutes during which the men set out to cross the castle's lake, certain they will drown - there is a mixture of ecstasy and despair.

"You escape from the horror," Fennimore sings; "that may destroy all we know. Yet the germ of creation will struggle to grow."

"All this can be a beginning

"And though time turns our day back to night

"Yet the hours of dark will lead onwards

To the dawning of glorious light."

I have always struggled to understand this ending: why, in the last days of Weimar, did Kurt Weill not pen some anthem of defiance against Nazism rather than a work which, ultimately, expresses resignation?

On the streets of Athens there is already the answer. You can feel what it is like when the political system - and even the rule of law - becomes paralysed and atrophies.

The "hopeless inertia" begins to grip even the middle classes, as the evidence of organised racist violence encroaches into their lives.

Faced with an economic situation dictated by the European Central Bank and the International Monetary Fund, and a street atmosphere resembling Isherwood's Berlin, the natural human urge is not fight but flight.

Flight away from danger - flight into the cocoon of drugs, relationships, alternative lifestyles, one's iPod.

After the first-night disruption of The Silver Lake in Leipzig this is how its director, Douglas Sirk, described the scene at the theatre:

"The sturmabteilung filled a fairly large part of the theatre and there was a vast crowd of Nazi Party people outside with banners and god knows what, yelling and all the rest of it. But the majority of the public loved the play… And so I thought at first, well, things are going to be tough but perhaps it isn't impossible to overcome…[But] no play, no song, could stop this gruesome trend towards inhumanity." (quoted in Kurt Weill On Stage, by Foster Hirsch)

And this is how the director of Corpus Christi, Laertis Vasiliou, whose play was once again disrupted by far right demonstrators in Athens on Thursday night, described it in a message to me just now:

"We went ahead with the performance, which started with two hours of delay because of the fight outside the theatre between the police against the Christian fundamentalists and the Nazis. It was like hell. The noise from outside was clear inside the theatre during the performance. People were beaten up by Nazis and Christian fanatics."

The differences with the final days Weimar, then, are clear. Under international pressure, the Greek state is still capable of upholding the rule of law; centrist parties, though atrophied, still hold the allegiance of more than one third of voters; there has been no decisive electoral breakthrough by the far right.

Crucially, no major business or media groups, and no significant portion of the elite, have swung behind the far right as happened in Germany.

But this flight to inertia, depression, to personal life may also be more pronounced than in Weimar. Weimar Germany was after all a society of intense political engagement; of hierarchical politics, lifelong commitment to social movements, trade unions, military veterans' groups.

So while the crisis may be on a scale weaker than the one that collapsed democracy in Greece, the forces holding democracy together may also be weaker.

When I interviewed Golden Dawn MP, Ilias Panagiotaros, two weeks ago, he was clear as to the party's project: if Syriza wins the election, "we will win the one after that".

"Revolution will take place after two elections by giving first place to Golden Dawn; now we are third, and maybe we will get second place - so it's not a dream that in one, two or three years we will be the first political party."

The leaders of the international community, busy negotiating the last-ditch austerity package that is supposed to precede a strategic rescue of the country know what the stakes are.

If they fail, a whole generation of Greek young people will be left, like Weill's protagonists in The Silver Lake, with a choice between love or nothing.

Paul Mason Article written by Paul Mason Paul Mason Former economics editor, Newsnight

End of an era

After 12 years on Newsnight, Economics editor Paul Mason has moved on to pastures new and this blog is now closed.

Read full article


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 71.

    But Greece is just a small country and very easily manageable. What with the other heavily debted countries in the southern Europe? Spain, Italy, Portugal? What's the real face of the EU and Germany? Are we really living the fourth, economical 'Reich' ? Should the over-debted countries of Europe be working only for Germany's benefit? Is this a modern form of enslaving other countries? I wonder...

  • rate this

    Comment number 70.

    So, if the opposition comes to power, then G.D. has no reason for existence, as an ( pseudo - ) anti - referendum acting party of Greece, and its real identity will be exposed to the public.
    Then, on the other hand, the risk of having daily violent riots between G.D. and leftists would be high. If so, then the worst scenario for Greece would be a military coup, as a transition government, as usual

  • rate this

    Comment number 69.

    So, the only, one-way solution - and salvation at the same time - for Greece is to get out of the eurozone and EU at every cost. The sooner the better. For its own people sake.
    If the current ( coalition ) government doesn't retreat from the EU and eurozone, it will step down very soon. Personally, far the best option for Greece. If that happens and the opposition comes to the power, G.D. is...

  • rate this

    Comment number 68.

    No state can or should protect savers ot investors because it is un-natural, subverts justice, is proven recpice for disaster, lets smug ah so's get away with sophisticated thefts and simply is ridiculous. Financial theft must carry penalty. The death penalty.

  • rate this

    Comment number 67.

    #60 It may be thay 2.75 m jobs were created. They have not estimated how many are lost :-) .... funny old world.

    Europe is descended into financial chaos with its constituents pray financially upon one another in a contracting market. It is nothing new and will sorely test the resolve of €uropeans. I mean, which army should they join? National or pan-national, or..... bi-polar.

  • rate this

    Comment number 66.

    Since then Mr Samaras was renowned for his ( pseudo - ) nationalistic ideology. All his efforts now to show a different face - allegedly against the neo-fashism - are fake. Sometimes he gives the impression that he acts as a modern 'Gauleiter' of Greece. Thus, Mr Samaras as PM and Golden Dawn are a very dangerous combination for Greece. He should have realized the EU's ineffectiveness and failure.

  • rate this

    Comment number 65.

    Additionally, it's a common secret in Greece that in the ranks of the conservative party ( ND ) and in the police force there are very fanatical fans of nazism and racism. Many incidents have been recorded in newspapers in the past. As for Mr Samaras,simply have a look at when he was the leader of the POL.AN., the small, insignificant party he had founded in the '90s. An unsuccessful effortof his.

  • rate this

    Comment number 64.

    History tells us that Greece was invaded by Italy in WW2 and then occupied by Germany with over 400,000 Greek lives lost. They were OUR allies during that time and it is a sad irony that it is a punitive Germany that may now bring them once more to their knees

  • rate this

    Comment number 63.

    We all know that this shameful group G.D. was there before the crisis as a small, insignificant 'political' party. It grew up through the current financial conditions in Greece. And it will keep on if we - government and citizens - still watch without doing nothing.
    On the other hand, this group comforts the current government and troika (especially Germany). It serves as a destructive instrument.

  • rate this

    Comment number 62.

    Considering the situation the current Greek authorities have been well to keep a lid on things thus far, but without the German recognising that their trade surplus has come at the expense of the Greek economy (& genuinely bail them out, not simply pile on the loans) then the Greek state could all too easily collapse entirerly.....which would devestate most of Europe, the UK included....

  • rate this

    Comment number 61.

    @48 purple "The problem in Greece 'was' corruption. It still is."

    YES, but it is the corruption inherent in (INTERNATIONAL) FINANCE / BANKING, to which you MUST add MANIPULATION. It is this corruption and manipulation which allows the RULING CLASSES to SUBJUGATE/ EXPLOIT the populations, and so REMAIN in POWER in an obviously blatant shame of meritocracy and democracy.

    POOR Greeks do pay taxes.

  • rate this

    Comment number 60.

    This appears to be, at the moment, the only place on the Europe pages where one can comment.

    The BBC carries a report of pro-"EU" propaganda claptrap fromn the so-called parliament of the so-called "EU" but there is no place there to comment.

  • rate this

    Comment number 59.

    For those that don't get it, everything is being revalued, again, Yes it happened recently before and we are in the middle of its ongoing chaos.

    Everything was devalued. You really don't want to know the measure of that last re-valuation but our Central Banks balance it every day.

    It is the Skilling effect.

  • rate this

    Comment number 58.

    Thank you a lot for verbalizing this scenario like you do!
    This is about living humans, friends, loved ones. About one of the most beautiful and amazing cities in Europe turning into a war zone whilst smiles, love, creativity is extinguished into resignation in so many. With the rest of Europe as silent spectators to this tragic replay.
    The Weill comparison is so spot on.

  • rate this

    Comment number 57.

    Danaos –You seem to believe that XA is not a real organisation, and was started by the founder of Pasok, but why? To ridicule Nazis ideas? Stupid idea as XA now has a following in ordinary people, the police and probably the military, who are encouraged believe that it is alright to hate and persecute foreign scapegoats. It is now a true Nazis party irrespective of its origins.

  • rate this

    Comment number 56.

    The concept and practice in accounting standards is now insane.

    Consider paragraph one, here -

    I am not mad, those dreaming up the rukes are.

  • rate this

    Comment number 55.

    Greek problems have a genesis founded >30 years ago. Then, political leaders took the path of least resistance.

    Now those chickens are coming home to roost, and extremism will run its bloody and cathartic course.

    The worry is that similar problems (rampant, unassimable immigration) in the UK will also propel the far-right to ascendancy.

    A Nazi Britain in 50 years? Possible!

    Oh, the irony!

  • rate this

    Comment number 54.

    We've had the Tour de France.

    Get ready for the Tour de Force.

    No drugs allowed, pepsi only.

  • rate this

    Comment number 53.

    Debt based wealth leverages the borrowers potential. Pulling the rug from under the borrower is a criminal act that will reap devastating consequences.

    In debt based finance, 1+1 most definately does not = 2. The morons getting wealthy, do not understand that or their part in the process. They must be sacked :-)

  • rate this

    Comment number 52.

    Golden Dawn Parliamentary Deputy Ilias Panagiotaros insulting audience members & actors with vile taunts. Thugs hurl stones. Policemen who are present stand by. Ministry for Homeland Security does nothing.
    Golden Dawn is a fascist organisation using Nazi symbols. It demands the deportation of all with an immigrant background. Support 6.9% (May elections) now 14%.
    Where are we going?


Page 3 of 6



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.