Libya: Is a breakdown in order forcing NGOs out?

Medecins Sans Frontieres staff treating a man in Misrata Medecins Sans Frontieres staff treating a man in Misrata

The decision by the French group Medecins Sans Frontieres (MSF) to withdraw its fieldworkers from prisons in the Libyan city of Misrata is an important and disturbing indicator of the situation in that country.

While some NGOs are guilty of trying to apply western 'best practice' in unrealistic ways, or to put the safety of their own teams ahead of project work, MSF's reputation, built over decades of operations in the most inhospitable parts of the world, suggests they should be listened to carefully both by the interim government in Libya and the western countries that assisted it to overthrow Muammar al Gaddafi's regime.

According to the NGO, in a few months its field workers have treated 115 people in the city's jail for wounds arising from torture.

"Patients were brought to us in the middle of interrogation for medical care, in order to make them fit for further interrogation", says MSF director Christopher Stokes, "this is unacceptable".

When one considers that this is just one city, it is not unreasonable to suppose that hundreds or even thousands of detainees have been abused in this way.


Apparently those subjected to this treatment have been removed from Misrata's prisons, taken to 'interrogation centres' run by various militias or state agencies before being returned with bad bruises, broken bones, and other signs of beating. Some are suspected of loyalty to the Gaddafi regime, others of criminality, and with some it is completely unclear.

Has Libya overthrown an oppressive, centralised, regime that relied upon torture, with one that also uses brutal methods but is so diffuse and divided along regional or tribal lines that it cannot run the country?

It is too early to write off the interim government, the revolution still has huge support, and it is natural that it should take time to establish a new democracy after 42 years of dictatorship.

However, the torture in Misrata and other places suggests that a great deal of score-settling is going on - much of it along tribal or local lines - and that it is not petering out in a way that many might have hoped.

Arbitrary detention and abuse now seem to be fuelling a new insurgency among former regime supporters in places like Sirte, Abu Salim (a neighbourhood of Tripoli), and Bani Walid, as well as feuds between tribes.

There have already been warnings to the Libyan government from the Foreign Office and State Department about the mistreatment of people in prison.

It does not appear that these have produced any effective action from the authorities.

Rather the arbitrary nature of the arrests, who is being beaten by whom, and the signs of new violence from former regime members and tribal enemies all suggest a situation in which authority is fragmenting.

Mark Urban, Diplomatic and defence editor, Newsnight Article written by Mark Urban Mark Urban Diplomatic and defence editor, BBC Newsnight

What else happened in Middle East as Gaza burned?

The Middle East is going through such turmoil that much has been happened during the month that Gaza has dominated the headlines. Here are five of the key events.

Read full article


Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 1.

    So we destroy their infrastructure, kill off some civilians, succeed in getting Gadaffi killed, and wait, oh that's right, noone is at all surprised that nothing good has come of the war. The governments knew that nothing would change, so you have to ask why the insistence that the war had to be fought? It wasn't about suffering, it was about profiteering.

  • rate this

    Comment number 2.

    I don't know why anyone's surprised at this outcome. The BBC was pretty disgraceful in its optimistic and ill-informed support for 'the rebels' during the war. We'll now be told a lot more about the divisions and hostility existing between Libyan tribes and factions as the country disintegrates and slips into further turmoil.

  • rate this

    Comment number 3.

    MSF is facing a difficult dilemma, however saving life, restoring health should be the only priority. It is similar to saving a life of a soldier who is sent back to the battlefield to be killed the next day. Even in a peaceful situation patients are routinely saved just to be subjected further (pathological) pain and suffering. Part of being a doctor; making lot's of ethical decisions.

  • rate this

    Comment number 4.

    Even before Gaddafi was 'overthrown' - I prefer murdered, but there you go - there were horrendous reports of rebel atrocities; yet 'our' 'leaders' continued to spout their hegemony of 'human rights' and 'democracy' - this war was nothing to do with either. It was about revenge and profit and to blazers with the consequences for the real men AND women of Libya - absolutely disgusting...

  • rate this

    Comment number 5.

    Kinda nasty when folk don't behave per the script conjured up for them in the minds of those elsewhere. Especially the bunch who like to tell others how to think, vs. report on what is going on so they can for themselves.

    Blowing the chances adding this, but wondering if, at 5, we might beat the record of 8 before a blog closes. Out of 24M licence fee payers.


Comments 5 of 16


This entry is now closed for comments


BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.