Freebies: the 'cynical trick'?


Update: Wednesday 11am

A great deal of response to Johann Lamont's speech - this is one take from the Spectator blog:

"Lamont's speech was, in effect, a repudiation of fifteen years of Labour thinking. The devolution years have been an exercise in fantasy politics in which everything has a value but nothing comes at a price. There will be cake for everyone. Labour built this political culture. Now it falls to Labour to try to change it".

You will, all being well, hear a Welsh Labour voice on this from the party's Manchester conference on Sunday Politics.


Who said this?

"What is progressive about a chief executive on more than 100,000 a year not paying for his prescriptions, while a pensioner needing care has their care help cut?

"What is progressive about judges and lawyers earning more than 100,000 a year, not paying tuition fees for their child to follow in their footsteps at university, while one in four unemployed young people can't get a job or a place at college?"

I'll give you a clue. It's not Andrew RT Davies. It's a Labour leader and surprise, surprise, it's not Carwyn Jones.

Need to read more?

"I believe our resources must go to those in greatest need.

"But if the devil's greatest trick was to convince the world he didn't exist, Mr X's most cynical trick was to make people believe that more was free, when the poorest are paying for the tax breaks for the rich."

The answer is Johann Lamont, leader of Scottish Labour, in full flow in Holyrood today. Who is the Mr X and his 'cynical trick' of giving freebies that protect the affluent as much as the poor? That, of course, is Alex Salmond.

Free school breakfasts Free school breakfasts are here to stay.

Now I wasn't in Holyrood but my colleague, Brian Taylor, was. He lives there, I think. For his reading of what Ms Lamont was out to achieve, click here. If you're pushed for time, here's a bullet point precis:

  • The Scottish Labour leader is out to paint the SNP leader and First Minister as shifty.
  • She's doing it by attacking him for offering goodies when it's not clear they're affordable.
  • Why? Labour hope their leader will be seen as upfront and honest, that voters are fed up of politicians promising stuff when it's not clear where the money is coming from.
  • The SNP think she's just given them a freebie - her head on a plate. After all, these policies are popular and seen as positive.

"We are not going to touch free prescriptions. If you look at what people have found most beneficial to them they will talk about free bus passes, they will talk about free school breakfasts, they will talk about free prescriptions. Those are the areas that I think members of the public will expect us to protect."

A quote from Alex Salmond? Actually no. That'll be Carwyn Jones , leader of Labour in this neck of the woods, where the Labour line is that universal, rather than means-tested services, are a key part of progressive politics (and that cutting universal benefits brings you relatively little cash but a whole lot of political pain).

That's devolution for you, they may argue, Scottish and Welsh Labour coming to their own conclusions based on what is best for Scotland and for Wales (and who is in government, who in opposition, perhaps.) You may however argue in return that you'd expect basic points of political principle to remain pretty much the same - in the same hymn book at least, if not on the exact same hymn sheet.

Are the two leaders sharing a stage at Labour's conference in Manchester later this month? Now wouldn't that be a whole lot of fun - and free for all.

Betsan Powys, Political editor, Wales Article written by Betsan Powys Betsan Powys Former political editor, Wales

A big day for health in Wales

A day of big health stories in Wales is capped with a potentially very significant announcement.

Read full article


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 79.

    Johann could have saved a lot of time by posting a short comment: The Scottish Labour Party has given up on social values, aspirations are now officially off the agenda, we will keep Trident and consume ourselves with hatred for the SNP.
    After her catastrophic TV interviews on Tuesday, we now know why she was all but absent from radio and TV for months. No vision for Scotland.
    YES is the only way.

  • rate this

    Comment number 78.

    ... make the wealthy pay more says Dingus, an interesting notion, perhaps a little more information might be in the offing, some meat on Salmond's bones.

    ... Dingus might define wealthy !

    ... Dingus might define "pay more" !

    I'm sorry Dingus, but I'm guessing more hot air from "north of the border" !

    The reality is, almost everyone will pay more, but only Salmond would know ....... how much !

  • rate this

    Comment number 77.

    74: We afford them just now, and if independent we'll be better off. But there's something you all seem so brainwashed as to miss: we can raise taxes.

    Simples? Make the wealthy pay more. I know, I know, that's not on the agenda down Sarth...but it WILL be in an Indie Scotland! :-)

  • rate this

    Comment number 76.

    ... you cannot have the second question, a question that would impose Scotland's will upon the remaining peoples of the UK, Salmond is presumptuous in the extreme, it might be a skill learned amongst Bankers .... and his not very good friend Trump.

  • rate this

    Comment number 75.

    There was NEVER any intention on behalf of Salmond to have a third question. It was a ploy played out a year in advance to do two things:
    1. Allow the SNP to accuse Labour (who's hatred of the SNP puts them into opposition towards and SNP policy) of being undemocratic and
    2. To use as a negotiating card to get Salmond's date, question, and votes for 16 and 17 year olds.

    We WANT 2 questions


Comments 5 of 79



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.