Lib Dems call for review of ambulance trust chair's pay

Ambulance Welsh ambulance response times to the most serious 999 calls dropped in the autumn

Related Stories

The Welsh Liberal Democrat leader, Kirsty Williams, has called for a review of the salary paid to the chairman of the Welsh Ambulance Trust.

She says Stuart Fletcher is among the highest paid ambulance service chairs in the UK, in a £40-45,000 pay band.

That was despite the Welsh trust missing a target of getting to 65% of serious 999 calls within eight minutes.

A Welsh government source said ambulance staff should be praised for their hard work, not attacked.

"These figures paint a very telling picture of how the Welsh Labour government runs our NHS and, indeed, how it spends Welsh taxpayers' money," said the Brecon and Radnorshire assembly member.

Start Quote

I find it outrageous that we are financially rewarding failure and poor performance”

End Quote Kisrty Williams AM Welsh Lib Dem leader

"We are not getting the best value for money. The chair of the Welsh Ambulance Trust is paid the highest salary despite the trust having the lowest response rates, by a significant margin, when compared with the other 12 ambulance trusts in England and Scotland."

According to the Welsh trusts' own figures in its annual report for 2011-12, its ambulances made it to 68.4% of the most serious emergencies within the eight minute time, describing it as "the best performance by the Trust since its formation in 1998".

But the latest figures released at the end of the year, show that in November, the category A call times had dropped by a full 10 percentage points.

"I find it outrageous that we are financially rewarding failure and poor performance," added Ms Williams.

"Paramedics and staff at the Welsh Ambulance Trust provide a very important service under difficult circumstances.

"They must find it hard to stomach the amount paid to their chair when they see that his counterparts across Britain are performing better and paid less."

UK AMBULANCE SERVICE STATISTICS - 2011/12

AMBULANCE SERVICE POPULATION (MILLIONS) EMPLOYEES % 8 MINUTE RESPONSE TO CAT A CHAIR SALARY BANDS

Source: Welsh Liberal Democrats

South East Coast Ambulance Service

4

3,200

78

£20-25,000

Yorkshire Ambulance Service

5

4,300

77.3

£20-25,000

Great Western Ambulance Service

2.4

1,700

76.7

£15-20,000

North West Ambulance Service

7

5,200

76.6

£20-25,000

North East Ambulance Service

2.6

2,000

75.9

£10-15,000

West Midlands Ambulance Service

5.4

4,000

75.9

£20-25,000

South Western Ambulance Service

2.9

2,200

75.9

£40-45,000

East of England Ambulance Service

5.8

4,000

75

£20-25,000

South Central Ambulance Service

4

2,250

74.7

£15-20,000

East Midlands Ambulance Service

4.8

2,700

74.7

£25-30,000

Scottish Ambulance Service

5

4,027

74.1

£25-30,000

London Ambulance Service

7.5

4,500

73.2

£20-25,000

Welsh Ambulance Service

2.9

2,576

64.2

£40-45,000

According to the Lib-Dem figures, only one other ambulance service chair is in a £40-45,000 pay band, at the South Western Ambulance Service. It made it to 75.9% of category A 999 calls within eight minutes.

Start Quote

If they want to make comparisons between the Welsh and English NHS, then they're skating on very thin ice indeed”

End Quote Welsh government source

The mid-point for salaries paid to ambulance service chairs is the £20-25,000 band.

Outside of Wales, the lowest percentage for responding to the 999 calls was for the London Ambulance Service, at 73.2% arriving at serious cases within eight minutes.

But a source in the Welsh government dismissed the attacks from Liberal Democrats.

"The Welsh Ambulance Service is working extremely hard in difficult weather conditions, and we should be thanking ambulance staff, not attacking their performance," said the source.

"It's testament to the hard work and dedication of staff that emergency response services have been delivered throughout the bad weather, despite dangerous driving conditions."

A review of the Welsh Ambulance Service is currently underway, and is due to end in March.

The government said it would deliver recommendations to "enable high quality, sustainable ambulance services for the future".

The government source added: "In making this attack, the Welsh Liberal Democrats are nothing but hypocrites - pure and simple. If they want to make comparisons between the Welsh and English NHS, then they're skating on very thin ice indeed.

"They cannot on the one hand prop-up a Tory Government that is causing utter mayhem to the NHS in England and then attack the health service in Wales. It's two-faced to say the least."

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More Wales stories

RSS

Features

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.