Metal theft 'soft target' warning for councils

Scrapyard generic Police say metal thefts generally are falling but there is concern councils are being targeted at a time when their finances are stretched

Related Stories

Councils are being warned they are seen as soft targets by metal thieves as new figures reveal the cost to them.

Metal thefts cost councils in Wales at least £820,000 in 2011/12, according to figures obtained by BBC Wales.

Police say metal thefts generally are falling but there is concern council property is being targeted at a time when their finances are stretched.

Councils say efforts to combat the problem are starting to take effect.

A BBC Wales freedom of information request suggests the cost of metal thefts to councils in Wales has increased by around £144,000 compared to 2010/11 and by over £530,000 on the year before that.

Start Quote

These people are recklessly stealing metal that has the potential to kill people”

End Quote Det Insp Mark Cleland British Transport Police

Most councils were able to provide figures for the last year, and some for the past five years.

Two councils in the Gwent Police force area are thought to have been worst hit in the past year: Torfaen (£247,176) and Caerphilly (£132,431).

Sgt Simon Clark of Gwent Police, who works full time tackling metal theft, said he was surprised by the rise in the cost to councils when overall figures were coming down.

"Across Wales, metal theft has been reduced by 22% in the last year and in Gwent it's been reduced by 45%," he said.

"I think councils are seen as a bit of a soft target."

Metal thefts have cost Welsh councils over £2.5m in the past five years, according to the figures.

Torfaen council has been particularly hard hit recently. Incidents have included a school badly damaged by rain after lead was stolen from the roof (costing £11,000), and the theft of a water tank, boiler and copper pipe at a football club changing rooms (£18,000).

Metal is tested for the DNA dye Councils are using SmartWater, which can be seen under UV light, to catch thieves

Anthony Hunt, Torfaen's executive member for resources, said every penny spent on damage was a penny lost from frontline services.

"With the rise in the scrap metal value, it suddenly became a problem," he said.

"But because we've worked closely with the police and metal collectors, hopefully that will lead to a big improvement in this."

He said the council had taken action, with one of its main weapons being SmartWater, which is used to mark items with a special liquid that is invisible to the naked eye but can be seen under UV light.

The SmartWater is applied to everything from computers to manhole covers and cannot be washed off.

Last year, it helped bring about the jailing of a man for the theft of lead in Pontypool.

"Anyone who thinks Torfaen is a soft target has certainly got the wrong idea and the full force of the law will be brought against them," added Mr Hunt.

Start Quote

Councils in Wales are also beginning to adapt their operational practices”

End Quote Welsh Local Government Association

Other local authorities in Wales have also been hit hard.

The cost to Rhondda Cynon Taf (RCT) last year was £110,000 and, over the past five years, the council has been hit with a bill for £400,000 because of metal thefts.

A total of 16 schools in RCT were affected, including Tonypandy Primary School which was targeted twice by lead thieves over the summer leaving holes in the roof which caused rain damage.

Many other councils elsewhere also reported lead thefts from schools including Flintshire, Powys, Anglesey, Denbighshire and Vale of Glamorgan.

Metal thefts present a major problem for the police, accounting for around 10% of all crimes.

Officers say they take it very seriously and a number of operations have been taking place to combat it.

Sgt Clark is working on Operation Tornado, a scheme being introduced in the whole of the UK where scrap operators insist on seeing a seller's photographic ID and a utility bill before buying metal.

But even then there can be problems.

"The scrapyards have to keep a book - who has come in, name and address, what vehicle has brought it in, and time and date," he said.

Metal seized

"What happens is they don't check those details are valid. We've had Elvis Presley taking scrap in, Joe Bloggs, we've had all sorts."

Examples of incidents in 2011/12

  • Rhondda Cynon Taf: Plaque from mines memorial stolen; lead from crematorium; goal posts; 16 schools targeted
  • Denbighshire: 20 manhole covers stolen in single incident
  • Caerphilly: Live electricity cables stolen
  • Bridgend: 21 gulley covers stolen from a single highway
  • Flintshire: 8 incidents of lead theft from schools
  • Monmouthshire: Substantial damage to main roof and dome of Chepstow Museum

SOURCE: BBC Wales FoI

He said Gwent Police were taking action to ensure scrapyards were complying with the record keeping.

In another operation, 20 people were arrested and thousands of pounds worth of material recovered during a three-week crackdown in Caerphilly county.

British Transport Police and Gwent Police carried out checks on so called "itinerant collectors", stopping and searching 44 vehicles with 15 loads of scrap metal seized.

Det Insp Mark Cleland, of British Transport Police, said officers were looking to expand the operation into other areas in the Gwent Police force area and further afield.

"It's saving lives at the end of the day. These people are recklessly stealing metal that has the potential to kill people," he said.

"It's not about what they steal it's the consequences.

"If you steal signalling cable, then signals don't work; if you steal a manhole cover, there's a hole in the road."

Det Insp Cleland is part of a pan-Wales group - which includes police, local authorities and various companies - which meets every three months to share information to try to prevent thefts.

Ministers in Westminster are also trying to clean up the industry and make it easier to trace the source of scrap metal by banning cash transactions at scrapyards.

flooded classroom Classrooms at Tref-y-Rhyg, Tonyrefail, were damaged when thieves stole lead from the roof

And an MP's Private Member's Bill aims to introduce a more robust licensing regime.

The body representing councils in Wales, the Welsh Local Government Association, said the seriousness of the crime had been recognised by government at all levels.

"Councils in Wales are also beginning to adapt their operational practices," said a spokesperson.

"Many use SmartWater... and items such as metal bins are increasingly being replaced by plastic or other composite materials.

"In some areas this has already resulted in as much as a 50% reduction in metal theft."

The spokesperson said that thefts added "an extra financial burden on local government finances that have already been stretched by the severe economic climate".

COST OF METAL THEFTS TO COUNCILS

LOCAL AUTHORITY 2008/09 2009/10 2010/11 2011/12

SOURCE: Local authorities via BBC Wales Freedom of Information request - 2008/09 to 2010/11 were from a previous BBC Wales FoI

*1 Items stolen but value unknown

*2 Other items were stolen in addition to this

*3 Manhole covers only

*4 2010/11 was street light cable only

*5 Street light cable only

*6 Excludes £115,000 needed to replace lights on other roads/footpaths

*7 Items stolen but no records kept of their value

Anglesey

No info held

No info held

£5,633

£9,500

Blaenau Gwent

£30,000

Not costed

Not costed

No figures supplied

Bridgend

£7,750

£12,900

£19,866

£39,600

Caerphilly *1

See *1

£30,993

£129,766

£132,431

Cardiff

£51,876

£23,360

£68,711

No figures supplied

Carmarthenshire *2

£14,293

£50,181

£4,795

£6,224

Ceredigion

£0

£0

£900

£0

Conwy *3

£5,700

£1,050

Figure not supplied

£2,000

Denbighshire *4

Info not held

Info not held

£5,000

£50,000

Flintshire

Not responded

Not responded

Not responded

£29,325

Gwynedd *1

See *1

See *1

£900

£2,350

Merthyr Tydfil

Not provided

Not provided

£37,500

£10,100

Monmouthshire

£0

£0

£0

Incidents but no costings

Neath Port Talbot

£0

£0

£0

£42,444

Newport *5

£18,000

£4,000

£5,000

No figures supplied

Pembrokeshire

£0

£180

£300

£0

Powys *1

£5,300

£0

£6,750

Up to £22,000

RCT *6

£94,833

£37,454

£107,094

£110,000

Swansea *3

£96,030

£96,690

£50,160

£68,188

Torfaen

£23,845

£23,554

£106,760

£247,176

Vale of Glamorgan

£17,817

£9,050

£128,415

£50,518

Wrexham *7

No figs available

No figs available

No figs available

No costings

Total

£365,444

£289,412

£677,550

£821,856

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More Wales stories

RSS

Features

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.