'Clarity' call on organ donation

Donor Card Full responses to the Welsh government's organ donation plans have now been published

Related Stories

The Law Society has called on the Welsh government for more clarity on the role of family members if a new organ donation law is to be introduced.

Currently, people wishing to donate their organs must carry donor cards or express their wishes to family.

Ministers want a soft opt-out system so everyone's organs are available for donation when they die unless they have said otherwise.

But the Law Society warns "the extent of the family's role is not certain".

Health minister Lesley Griffiths has said she could not imagine organs being removed if a family objected.

The response from the Law Society, which represents solicitors in Wales and England, was one of more than 1,000 submissions to the public consultation process which ended in January.

The Welsh government wants to introduce a 'soft opt-out' donation system, whereby people will have to object if they want to avoid being automatically placed on the organ donation register.

Start Quote

It's a difficult time and we shouldn't have doctors removing organs without the consultation of the family”

End Quote Roy Thomas Kidney Wales

Full details of the responses to the consultation were published on Wednesday, along with findings of qualitative research commissioned by the government.

On the issue of family involvement, the government's White Paper setting out its proposals states: "The Welsh government recognises the importance of the role of the family in a soft opt-out system.

"The wishes of the deceased will be respected and in order to safeguard these wishes family involvement is essential."

'Veto' confusion

But the Law Society claims that other comments in the proposals appear to confuse the issue of whether a family member may have a veto over organ donation.


  • A bill is set to be introduced later this year and passed in 2013, paving the way for what would be the first system of its kind in the UK.
  • The new system would start in 2015 after allowing time for a public information campaign.
  • Despite a record 83 people donating organs in 2010, the Welsh government said a shortage of organs continued to cause deaths and the system will improve donations
  • Opponents have said changing the law may not make a difference and could be counter-productive

The society said in its response: "The 'soft' element of the proposed system is the inclusion of a role for the family.

"However, the role of the family in the proposal seems to safeguard the wishes of the deceased alone.

"By referring to a role for the family without stating clearly that the family cannot refuse permission for the removal of organs and tissue, the paper is misleading."

The Law Society goes on to state that "the extent of of the family's role is not certain even in the minds of Welsh ministers and clarification is vital".

The health minister, Lesley Griffiths, went on the record in March on the issue of a potential family 'veto', as the initial responses to the consultation were published.

She said she "cannot envisage a time when a doctor would remove those organs if the family specifically didn't want that to happen".

The minister said she also hoped that the suggested donor system would mean that relatives were aware of a patient's wishes, and whether they had decided to register as not being a donor.

Roy Thomas, the chairman of Kidney Wales Foundation, which has vocally backed the opt-out presumed consent plans, said he believed families should be able to have the last say on organ donation.

"We believe they should - it is as simple as that," he told BBC Wales.

"It's a difficult time and we shouldn't have doctors removing organs without the consultation of the family."

However, the confusion over a family's role is also highlighted in research commissioned by the Welsh government as part of the consultation process.

The authors of the qualitative study, carried out by Beaufort Research, stated in their conclusions: "The most pressing concern from participants' perspective was the lack of clarity over the influence of (and role played by) family members at the point of organ donation, and the realisation that family members could effectively 'overturn' the wishes of the deceased.

"The need for family involvement was not widely understood."

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More Wales stories



Try our new site and tell us what you think. Learn more
Take me there

Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.