Concern over 'forced' uni merger in south east Wales

Newport University's new city campus The University of Wales, Newport, would merge with the University of Glamorgan and Cardiff Metropolitan

Related Stories

The National Union of Students said it is concerned by suggestions a merger of universities could be "forced" to create a new "super" institution in south east Wales.

Education Minister Leighton Andrews has proposed merging the University of Glamorgan, Cardiff Metropolitan and Newport University.

But Cardiff Metropolitan previously said it was against the plan.

The NUS said students must be priority as universities "thrash out" details.

Mr Andrews gave details of the blueprint for the future of higher education in Wales on Tuesday, saying he wanted to create "strong, successful and sustainable" universities.

Among his proposals was the plan to replace the University of Glamorgan, Cardiff Metropolitan University and University of Wales, Newport with a "super" university, with campuses across the region.

They will now be consulted on the plans.

Analysis

Ciaran Jenkins, BBC Wales education correspondent

Four out of 10 of Wales' universities are in a little cluster around south east Wales and the Welsh government has thought for a long time that that's a bit bonkers.

But what it couldn't do was actually persuade them to come together and create one big super university that could really compete on the UK and international stage.

Now it's saying there will be a new university. It will require the merger of Glamorgan University, Newport and also Cardiff Metropolitan.

And the inference is that this will happen whether they like it or not.

Cardiff Metropolitan University certainly are fundamentally opposed to the idea so it will be interesting to see what happens next.

Cardiff Metropolitan are supposed to be autonomous, as universities are, and they said they don't want to merge with anyone.

Yet the government policy is that they should have to merge with other universities and because they're not protected by a royal charter like some of the older universities, the education minister Leighton Andrews does have the power to dissolve the university whether they like it or not.

And that could be what happens some way down the road.

The Welsh government though are saying they want this to happen by consent and there will now be a period of consultation to make it happen.

Cardiff Metropolitan, which previously went by the name University of Wales Institute, Cardiff (Uwic), had previously said it did not want to be part of a merged south east Wales university.

After the education minister's proposals were announced it said its board of governors would consider them at their next meeting.

However, BBC Wales education correspondent Ciaran Jenkins said the minister has the power to force through the merger because the three universities do not have a royal charter, like older institutions do.

'Stand off'

The NUS warned such a move "would not be helpful".

"While the details are being thrashed out between institutions, we warn against losing sight of what is fundamentality important - the individual students that will be affected by these proposals," said NUS Wales President Luke Young.

"I am concerned by the suggestion of forced mergers and dissolution of universities.

"It will not be helpful to higher education in Wales to create a stand off between university vice chancellors and the government.

"What we need is sensible, clear and well-evidenced proposals that ensure that the provision currently available is protected and that the student experience is enhanced.

"Students need to be full partners in this process."

Mr Andrews unveiled his proposals after the Higher Education Funding Council for Wales (Hefcw) provided advice on the structure of higher education in Wales earlier this year.

The Welsh Government also received over 400 responses from interested parties following its recommendations.

After considering the issues raised, Mr Andrews said he accepted Hefcw's recommendations that:

Start Quote

We have made a commitment to a smaller number of stronger universities”

End Quote Leighton Andrews Education minister
  • The University of Glamorgan, Cardiff Metropolitan University and University of Wales, Newport, should merge
  • Cardiff and Swansea Universities should continue to develop their considerable research and collaborative potential.
  • Aberystwyth and Bangor should continue to strengthen their strategic alliance, although they will not be expected to formally merge at this time.
  • The University of Wales Trinity Saint David and Swansea Metropolitan University should merge as already planned, and also pursue their merger with the University of Wales.

However, the minister rejected the recommendation that Glyndwr University should move into a group structure managed by Bangor and Aberystwyth Universities.

Instead, he proposed to commission a review of higher education provision in north east Wales.

Mr Andrews said: "We have made a commitment to a smaller number of stronger universities, which are more sustainable and better equipped to meet the needs of learners and the Welsh economy."

Wrexham MP Ian Lucas said he was "pleased" with the decision to stop Glyndwr University forming a group with Bangor and Aberystwyth.

"I am pleased that the minister has listened to the united voice of the region," he said.

"We should now work to improve further upon Glyndwr's relations with business to strengthen the regional economy at this difficult time."

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More Wales stories

RSS

Features

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.