School music lessons in Wales cut by £500k since report

School brass band There are wide variations in music lessons from county to county

Related Stories

At least £500,000 has been cut from school music lessons in Wales since a report called for a better service.

While extra-curricular music lessons are still free in some counties, others charge or are considering doing so.

It is claimed the number of children reaching youth orchestra standard is "declining at an alarming rate".

The Welsh Assembly Government said it was funding new initiatives, but delivery of lessons was down to individual schools and councils.

In 2006, a host of music stars including Bryn Terfel, Katherine Jenkins and rock band Super Furry Animals, wrote to former First Minister Rhodri Morgan, urging an end to the "postcode lottery" for provision of young people's music lessons outside the curriculum.

To coincide with BBC Radio Wales' Music Day, BBC Wales has asked each council about the services on offer.

Start Quote

The number of children reaching youth orchestra standard is declining at an alarming rate”

End Quote Helen Wilding Smith Powys council music director

The results show wide variations from county to county.

Flintshire council is cutting £177,000 from its budget for instrumental music teaching, which means it will no longer support the county youth brass band or a singing project for 2,500 primary school children.

Carmarthenshire council is reducing its budget by £120,000.

Powys is the only county that offers no council-funded music lessons at all.

The authority's music director Helen Wilding Smith said: "Provision for learning certain instruments is patchy or non-existent.

"As a result, the number of children reaching youth orchestra standard is declining at an alarming rate."

In Powys, many parents must pay the full cost of lessons, which varies from £10 to £26 per hour.

While instrumental lessons are still free in Conwy and Bridgend, Carmarthenshire and Pembrokeshire are considering introducing charges in the near future.

Meanwhile, parents in Cardiff and the Vale of Glamorgan face a 7% increase in the cost of instrumental lessons this year.

"Less inclusive"

Emyr Wynne Jones, who is in charge of school music services in Carmarthen, chaired the assembly government's review which was published last year.

It found music service provision across Wales varied greatly in terms of range, take-up and affordability.

He said the cuts would mean "massive implications for schools".

"The danger with these things is that to keep the provision going we're going to have to begin increasing charges which by default is going to make events such as this more elitist and less inclusive," he said.

Start Quote

Unfortunately having a rich musical heritage doesn't necessarily guarantee a bright musical future”

End Quote Emyr Wynne Jones Review chairman

"The review identified an awful lot of good practice across Wales but it also identified circumstances that were deteriorating.

"The situation has deteriorated further and continues to deteriorate year on year.

"County councils and music services and friends and parents' associations are doing all they can to make sure the rich musical heritage we have here in Wales continues for many years to come.

"But unfortunately having a rich musical heritage doesn't necessarily guarantee a bright musical future."

The assembly government accepted most of the recommendations of the music services review.

A spokesperson said the development of musical skills was "firmly embedded in the foundation phase and all pupils from the age of seven to 14 years have opportunities to compose and perform music".

They added: "Delivery of the curriculum and extra curricular activities are very much a matter for schools working with partners and, in particular, the local authority-funded music services."

They said the assembly government was committed to raising the profile of music in schools and one example was its "can sing" initiative, promoting singing in primary schools backed up by £476,000 over three years.


Area Drop in spending

Information as provided to BBC Wales


£18,000 (efficiency savings)

Cardiff and the Vale of Glamorgan

£65,000 - 17% of budget




No change




£39,705 - 16.2% of budget


£177,000 - 33% of budget



Merthyr Tydfil

£3,500 - 5% of budget

Neath Port Talbot

No change


2% cut in funding


No budget

Rhondda Cynon Taf

No change


Reduction last year and further reduction likely


£35,000 (18 months ago)

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More Wales stories



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.