Lord Chief Justice calls for Welsh courts reprieve

Lord Chancellor, Kenneth Clarke Lord Chancellor, Kenneth Clarke is expected to make a decision on court closure later this year

Related Stories

The Lord Chief Justice says a number of proposals to axe magistrates' and county courts in Wales cannot be supported.

The Ministry of Justice announced plans in July to consult on closing 15 courts.

But responding to the proposals, the senior presiding judge, Lord Judge said five should remain open and a further six should be reviewed.

A final decision is expected by the Lord Chancellor later this year.

The original courts earmarked for closure stretch from Flint Magistrates' Court in north-east Wales, down to Chepstow Magistrates' Court in the south.

Start Quote

Lord Chief Justice, Lord Judge

A bus or train fare for some will mean genuine hardship”

End Quote Lord Judge Lord Chief Justice

The proposals also covered Rhyl and Pontypool County Courts.

But in his response, the Lord Chief Justice warns that if the plans proceed, there will be "little, if any, slack left" in the Welsh justice system.

"There is high unemployment and considerable social deprivation in parts of the country, while other parts are large, sparsely populated, rural areas," noted the senior presiding judge in the report published on Thursday.

"A bus or train fare for some will mean genuine hardship.

"In some cases I am of the view that poor facilities and low utilisation do not outweigh the genuine difficulty which court users will experience when travelling to court.

Lord Judge also expressed concerns over access to family justice services.

"There is nothing to suggest that family work has been a factor in the consultation and would urge consideration of this before any plans to close family centres are implemented," he added.

'Real difficulties'

The report, which is being presented to the Lord Chancellor, Kenneth Clarke, states that five proposals to close courts cannot be supported.

These are Aberdare County and Magistrates' Court, Abergavenny Magistrates' Court, Cardigan Magistrates' Court, Llangefni Magistrates' Court and Pwllheli Magistrates' Court.

In the case of the Cardigan court, the review warns that those without a car could face a two hour bus journey to reach the proposed replacement services at Aberystwyth.

"A large part of the country would be a considerable distance from a court were Cardigan to close," states the report.

"This court, perhaps more than most, demonstrates the real difficulty between access to justice and modern-day appropriate facilities.

"On balance, I think retention is justified."

A similar case is made for Llangefni Magistrates' Court, as users would face travelling to Holyhead, which the Lord Chief Justice notes would mean "substantial and difficult journeys" for those in outlying areas.

The document also makes the case for reviewing whether closure is necessary at a further five magistrates' courts at Ammanford, Barry, Chepstow, Denbigh and also Pontypool County Court.

The Lord Chief Justice said that of the 15 proposals, only four did not face objections: Abertillery, Flint, and Llandovery Magistrates' Courts, and Rhyl County Court.

'Administering justice'

"It is obvious that a number of courts in different parts of England and Wales no longer fulfil any sufficiently valuable public purpose," added Lord Judge in his foreword to the report.

"The current national financial crisis has provided us with a useful opportunity to examine the court estate, and I supported this public consultation which provided an opportunity not only to examine the locations where our courts are situated, but also whether they were sufficiently meeting their purpose in the administration of justice throughout the country."

Responding to the views of the Lord Chief Justice, a spokesperson for Her Majesty's Court Service said: "The responses to each document will now be studied in detail, including consideration of alternative proposals from respondents, and the impact of each proposed closure analysed fully.

"Recommendations will then be made to the Lord Chancellor who will decide, in each case, whether or not to close the courts and whether to merge any Local Justice Areas.

"We anticipate that he will make his decisions later this year."

Provision of court services in Wales: Lord Chief Justice's view

Support Closure: Why?

Abertillery Magistrates' Court

Poor facilities, with only a 32% utilisation rate.

Flint Magistrates'' Court

Only sites one day a week, 24% utilisation rate, Mold court only five miles away.

Llandovery Magistrates' Court

Not used since 2000.

Rhyl County Court

Well used, sitting every day, but Prestatyn courts only three miles away.

Oppose Closure:

Aberdare County and Magistrates' Court

Magistrates sit four days a week, with 57% utilisation rate. Concerns on whether business case "may not stand up to scrutiny". HCMS review also concludes that family services should not be moved to Merthyr.

Abergavenny Magistrates' Court

Recently reopened and refurbished in July, and the only court serving the north Gwent areas. Concern that facilities at the replacement, Newport are "lamentable".

Cardigan Magistrates Court

Low but consistent use, with limited running costs. The alternative is using Aberystwyth, with two hour journey times on public transport.

Llangefni Magistrates' and County Court

Frequent court sittings while journey times to Holyhead courts would be difficult, especially for outlying areas.

Pwllheli Magistrates' Court

Low use, but travel distance to Caernarfon lengthy. It should be retained on "access to justice" grounds.

Review:

Ammanford Magistrates Court

Any assessment should take account of travel times from outlying areas of northern Carmarthenshire.

Barry Magistrates' Court

Unclear whether Cardiff Magistrates Court would be able to absorb the workload of this busy court.

Chepstow Magistrates' Court and County Court

Rarely used, but with very low running costs.

Denbigh Magistrates' Court

Public transport users face lengthy journeys to Prestatyn.

Llwynypia Magistrates' Court

Concerns over whether Pontypridd can absorb the workload of this busy court.

Pontypool County Court

A deprived area where public travel costs to Blackwood are expensive, at £7, and also concerns over whether Blackwood can absorb the additional workload.

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More Wales stories

RSS

Features

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.