One in five adoptions in Wales break down, says charity

Young girl generic Adoption UK said care professionals need to learn from adoption failures

Related Stories

Up to a fifth of child adoptions in Wales break down due to poor and inconsistent services for youngsters and families, claims a report.

The charity Adoption UK said care professionals were not learning from the "unacceptable" level of breakdowns because no overall record was kept.

The charity said families did not always know what help they could have.

The assembly government said it was to consult on measures to "emphasise the importance of permanency" in care.

Adoption UK said its report comes as the number of adoptions in Wales rose from 212 in 2008 to 256 in 2009.

The charity said some local authority services are failing to respond to the emotional and developmental needs of adopted children.

It said there were significant numbers of adoptive families in Wales who are struggling to cope with the demands of "re-parenting a child who has suffered early trauma and loss."

Schools could also be dismissive of the parents' concerns over their child's needs, even though adopted children have a higher than average rate of special education needs, it said.

Wales manager Ann Bell, who is both an adoptee and an adoptive parent, said the number of adoptive family break-ups could be as high as one-in-three but statistics kept by Wales' 22 councils were not collated by the assembly government.

She said: "We feel that the assembly government needs to be pulling that data together and really learning from that data.

"One-in-five is a really unacceptable level of breakdown.

Case study

  • Diane, not her real name, and her husband adopted their son, now 16, when he was three. He is back in care.

"He did not cry when the foster parents dropped him off. He'd been there two years. He had a stealing problem as well, which he had not learnt from us. But we could manage and he fitted in well at school until he was about 13, then he started stealing in the community.

The police were ringing all the time and he was permanently excluded from school. No-one recognised the problems we were having with this boy, which were way and above normal teenage troubles.

They did not relate to his adoption, the fact he had been with a neglectful person in the first year of his life."

"It is really heart-rending when children have to go back in to the care system when they thought they were going to get a home for life.

"The parents are also really heartbroken when they thought they had a family.

"Adoptive parents do not have enough support to help them through those difficulties."

The charity said fewer than half of adoptive parents know of their entitlement to a statutory assessment, while local authorities have varying levels of expertise in adoption when dealing with traumatised children.

It said it had found that 90% of parents thougth a booklet for school staff outlining the needed of adopted children would have been helpful.

The charity's report makes 12 recommendations including training about children suffering early trauma and neglect for all health and social services professionals.

A Welsh Assembly Government spokesperson said: "We've received a copy of the report and will consider its findings and recommendations.

"We are committed to ensuring the safety and permanence of children who are looked after.

"This autumn, we will consult on a package of measures to strengthen assessment, placement and care planning arrangements for children in care. This will emphasise the importance of permanency.

"Adoption UK is represented on our Adoption and Fostering Advisory Group and we value their contribution to improve permanence for children in Wales."

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More Wales stories



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.