Scottish independence: Nato members 'would welcome' Scotland

Nato soldier The SNP ended its 30-year opposition to Nato membership in 2012

Nato would welcome an independent Scotland even if the country removed Trident, the former UK ambassador to the military alliance has said.

Dame Mariot Leslie was responding to a warning by Sir Richard Shirreff, a former Nato deputy supreme commander.

She revealed she will be voting "Yes" in the independence referendum.

The Better Together campaign said expelling the UK's nuclear deterrent would be seen as a "block" to Scotland's membership of Nato.

Sir Richard described the SNP's defence policy as "dangerous" and "amateurish" at the weekend, and said Scotland's future in Nato is "uncertain" if it leaves the UK and expels nuclear weapons from the Clyde.

But Dame Mariot, who was born in Edinburgh and retired as the UK's permanent representative to Nato earlier this year, said she drew "a different conclusion" from Sir Richard.

Start Quote

No ally would wish to interrupt the integrated Nato defence arrangements in the North Sea and North Atlantic - least of all at a time of heightened tension with Russia”

End Quote Dame Mariot Leslie Former ambassador to Nato

In a letter to the Scotsman newspaper, she wrote: "I am sure that it would be in Scotland's interest to join Nato and to continue to anchor our own defence in a wider alliance of Western democracies.

"But I am also in no doubt that the other 28 Nato allies would see it in their interests to welcome an independent Scotland into Nato.

"No ally would wish to interrupt the integrated Nato defence arrangements in the North Sea and North Atlantic - least of all at a time of heightened tension with Russia.

"A democratic, non-nuclear Scotland with strong military and technological traditions would fit naturally alongside similar Nato members in Northern Europe, and would be likely to join them - and the UK - in looking for multinational solutions to the pressures on their defence budgets."

'Security agencies'

Dame Mariot, who also formerly served as director-general for defence and intelligence at the Foreign Office. said any comparisons between Scotland and countries such as Ukraine and Georgia, who also wish to join Nato, were "out of place".

She added: "There is no 'queuing order' for membership of Nato. Each candidature, and its timing, is considered separately on its own merits by the Nato council."

Outlining her reasons for voting in favour of independence on 18 September, she said: "I am a democrat, and believe that the geography, economy, demography and politics of our country are so distinctive that they are best served by our own sovereign government.

"I nonetheless have affection for the UK, am proud to have been a British diplomat for more than three decades, and have enjoyed working with our highly professional armed forces and security agencies.

"Of course the closest and most important defence and security relationship for an independent Scotland would be with the United Kingdom.

Start Quote

Expelling the UK deterrent - especially when President Putin is reminding the world about his - would be seen as a serious block to Scottish membership”

End Quote George Robertson Former Nato secretary general

"It's clear that as Scotland made the transition to independence there would be some tough negotiations over defence, nuclear and wider security questions, because there is a lot at stake on both sides. We are already witnessing some staking out of positions.

"But nothing in my long experience of British or international security make me think that either country need emerge as a less safe place when those negotiations were concluded."

Her comments were welcomed by Deputy First Minister Nicola Sturgeon, who said: "Dame Mariot is an enormously experienced diplomat who worked at the highest levels, and she speaks with authority on Scotland's potential and opportunities as an independent country.

"I am confident that having experts of her calibre publicly backing Yes will encourage many more undecided and No voters to decide in favour of Yes."

But speaking on behalf of the Better Together campaign, former Nato secretary-general George Robertson said: "Ms Leslie is entitled to her opinion but even she will see how difficult it would be to get 28 countries to agree to admitting a country determined to disarm another Nato state.

"The SNP is not just non-nuclear, it is anti-nuclear and no other Nato country takes that position. Expelling the UK deterrent - especially when President Putin is reminding the world about his - would be seen as a serious block to Scottish membership."

More on This Story

More Scotland politics stories


Smith Commission Live

    08:23: Who is Lord Smith?

    His name may be familiar to you after the Commonwealth Games in Glasgow, as he served as chairman of the organising committee.

    Lord Smith of Kelvin

    Lord Smith of Kelvin was then appointed to oversee the process of devolving more powers to Scotland.

    Find out more about him.

    08:18: Who was on the Commission?

    Ten people - two representatives each from the SNP, Labour, the Conservatives, the Liberal Democrats and the Greens - made up the Smith Commission.

    Lord Smith commission panel

    Find out who they were.

    08:14: What is the commission?

    The recommendations of the Smith commission, chaired by Lord Smith of Kelvin, are to form the basis of UK government legislation on more Scottish powers although they would not be delivered until after the Westminster election in May 2015.

    08:08: Analysis - What powers will Holyrood get? Glenn Campbell BBC Scotland news

    The Smith commission on further devolution has concluded its talks with the five political parties represented in the Scottish Parliament. They have reached agreement on a package of additional powers, which is to be announced in Edinburgh on Thursday.

    The commission's recommendations are expected to include:

    • the full devolution of income tax rates and bands, with the personal allowance (the threshold above which tax is paid) continuing to be set by the UK government
    • assigning a proportion of the VAT revenues raised in Scotland to the Scottish budget
    • giving Holyrood control of air passenger duty and - eventually - the aggregates tax
    • devolving welfare measures including attendance allowance, carers' allowance and some cold weather payments
    • retaining UK control of all the benefits being merged into universal credit, while introducing some devolved flexibility over aspects such as the frequency of payments
    • devolving the work programme
    • putting Holyrood in charge of its own elections, which could allow MSPs to give 16 and 17 year olds a vote in the 2016 Scottish Parliament election
    08:04: Smith Commission

    The BBC understands the commission on devolving powers to the Scottish Parliament is to recommend it has full control over income tax rates and bands.

    Scottish Parliament

    The report is not expected to call for personal allowances - the threshold at which tax is paid - to be devolved.

    The Smith Commission, which was set up after the "No" vote in the independence referendum, reached an agreement at its final meeting in Edinburgh and its full report will be published on Thursday morning.

    08:01: Good morning Graham Fraser BBC Scotland

    Good morning, and welcome to our live coverage of the Smith Commission.



  • Finance casino

    A deal on new Scottish powers does not mean it will actually happen

  • Patient zero

    Tracking first Ebola victim and and how virus spread

  • Barbie's battle

    Can the doll make it in China at the second attempt?

  • Lost in the desert

    How I drank urine and bat blood to survive in the Sahara

  • Blacklisted

    The Afghan interpreters left by the US to the mercy of the Taliban

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.