Scottish independence: Academics back higher North Sea oil estimate

oil instillation Future North Sea oil and gas income is one of the main battlegrounds in the referendum debate

A projection by industry body Oil and Gas UK that 24bn barrels of oil can be extracted from the North Sea is "plausible", two academics have said.

The projection has been used by the Scottish government as part of its campaign for independence.

Last week industry figure Sir Ian Wood claimed the figure was too high.

Professors Alex Russell and Peter Strachan of Robert Gordon University said there was a "potential" for the higher projection to be met.

Sir Ian claimed there were about 15bn to 16.5bn barrels of recoverable oil left and that the figure from Oil and Gas UK, used in the Scottish government's White Paper was between 45% and 60% too high.

He predicted that oil and gas revenues would run down with "a big impact on our economy, jobs and balance of payments".

Following Sir Ian's prediction, Melfort Campbell, chairman of a Scottish government commission into the future of North Sea oil said the industry would be "hard-pushed" to extract 15bn barrels.

Sir Ian Wood Sir Ian Wood recently headed a major oil industry review
'Extremely wealthy'

However, Oil and Gas UK has stood by its projection, which was endorsed by Prof Russell, who is professor of petroleum accounting at Aberdeen Business School, and Prof Strachan, both from Robert Gordon University in Aberdeen.

They said: "The healthy 16bn barrels or so of oil equivalent figures now widely accepted by all campaigners in the referendum debate (apart from the ludicrously pessimistic forecasts from the Office for Budgetary Responsibility) as being economically exploitable from existing discoveries is surely an understatement of the future potential of North Sea production.

"Prof Alex Kemp and [learning support assistant] Linda Stephen have modelled future production based on oil prices at $90 per barrel and arrived at future production figures up to 2050 of between 15 and 16.5bn barrels of oil equivalent.

"Since current oil prices are higher than $90 and likely to rise and as improvement in technology continue then the ultimate potential of 24bn barrels of oil equivalent foreseen by Oil and Gas UK appears plausible."

They added: "There is no question that had Scotland been an independent country in 1975, say, that Scotland would be extremely wealthy now and there would be no national debt."

In July the the Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR), cut its estimate of tax income from the North Sea between 2020 and 2041 by a quarter, to £40bn.

This led Chief Secretary to the Treasury Danny Alexander to accuse First Minister Alex Salmond of offering voters a "fantastical" future based on unrealistic oil forecasts.

Alex Salmond Alex Salmond clashed with opposition leaders over oil in the final first minister's questions before the referendum

Mr Salmond dismissed the OBR's assessment as "stuff and nonsense". He has also continued to back a higher estimate of remaining oil reserves.

Responding to Sir Ian's claims during the final first minister's questions before the 18 September referendum, Mr Salmond said that the equivalent of 15bn to 16.5bn barrels could be taken out up to 2050, with this rising to a total of 24bn in the years after that.

'Substantial cuts'

SNP Treasury spokesman Stewart Hosie said the latest academic intervention should "put to bed some of the nonsense which is being peddled by the No campaign on Scotland's oil wealth".

He added: "Westminster politicians have been claiming for decades that oil is a curse for Scotland and a blessing for every other country, but people are now seeing through that, and on September 18 have the opportunity of a lifetime to put Scotland's wealth in Scotland's hands."

But Mr Alexander backed Sir Ian's oil estimates.

"It undermines the case that the SNP has made, which is built on fantastical over-optimistic oil predictions in order to pretend that somehow in an independent Scotland various policies could be afforded," he said.

"An independent Scotland from day one would have no choice but to make substantial cuts to public services or substantial increases to income tax for people in Scotland."

More on This Story

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More Scotland politics stories

RSS

Scotland Live

  1.  
    09:21: Graphic Burns

    Robert Burns is portrayed as a flintlock-wielding witch hunter in a new graphic novel.

    Robbie Burns: Witch Hunter

    The Bards' tale Tam o' Shanter influenced the writing and artwork for the book, which will be officially unveiled in his birthplace today.

     
  2.  
    09:19: Douglas Fraser Business and economy editor, Scotland

    Petrofac share price down 24% in early trading, on profit warning. RBS holding up despite recent embarrassing admissions.

     
  3.  
    09:14: Scots ice-cool under pressure

    Scotland's women bounced back from a losing start to earn two wins on the second day of the European Curling Championships.

    Scotland skip Eve Muirhead

    Eve Muirhead's rink beat Latvia 10-5, then overcame the Czech Republic 9-4, having lost to Denmark on Saturday.

    The Scots face hosts and holders Switzerland before locking horns with Russia today.

     
  4.  
    09:11: UK fighters 'not mercenaries'

    A British man fighting with Kurdish troops against Islamic State militants in Syria says he is not a mercenary.

    Jamie Read (left) and James Hughes (right) are said to have joined American Jordan Matson in the YPG Jamie Read (left) and James Hughes (right) are said to have joined American Jordan Matson in the YPG

    Jamie Read, from North Lanarkshire, and James Hughes, a former British soldier, are reported to be among 15 Westerners with the YPG militia group.

    Mr Read said they were helping the Kurdish people in their efforts against the jihadists and were not being paid.

     
  5.  
    09:06: Unsolved murder

    Police are expected to make a fresh appeal for information on the murder of Nairn banker Alistair Wilson ten years ago.

    Alistair Watson

    The 30-year-old was shot dead on the doorstep of his home on 28 November, 2004.

    A massive police investigation was launched but the murder of the father-of-two remains unsolved.

     
  6.  
    08:58: Coming up on Morning Call BBC Radio Scotland

    On Morning Call with @LWhiteMedia: Does gender matter in politics? We are hearing from @MikeBuchanan11 and @talatyaqoob. 0500 92 95 00.

     
  7.  
    08:48: On the back pages

    Which Manchester United star nearly signed for Rangers? And which Celtic player thinks playing against Messi is "easy"?

    Lionel Messi

    It can only be today's sports gossip.

     
  8.  
    08:45: Cabinet's first meeting

    Nicola Sturgeon will convene the first meeting of her new Scottish cabinet today.

    Nicola Sturgeon's first cabinet

    Ms Sturgeon revealed her top ministerial team, which has a 50-50 gender split, on Friday after becoming Scotland's first female first minister.

    She is expected to announce her first legislative programme to the Scottish Parliament on Wednesday.

     
  9.  
    08:40: Read all about it...

    The first ever issue of The National, Scotland's only daily pro-independence newspaper, goes on sale today. The paper leads with the news that 60 charities are urging the Smith Commission to recommend devolving welfare powers to Scotland.

    Scotland's newspapers

    The Scotsman reports that, under the Anti-Terrorism and Security Bill, police are to be given new powers to force internet firms to record details which could identify suspected terrorists and paedophiles.

    Read the rest of our newspaper round-up here.

     
  10.  
    08:34: RBS 'sorry'

    The Royal Bank of Scotland has apologised for giving incorrect evidence to a parliamentary hearing.

    RBS sign

    Bank directors appeared before the Treasury Committee in June to answer claims that RBS's Global Restructuring Group (GRG) had deliberately killed off viable firms.

    Newly released letters show that RBS chairman Sir Philip Hampton later said some of the evidence "lacked clarity".

     
  11.  
    08:27: Katie Morag awards

    A nine-year-old actress who plays the title role in CBeebies show Katie Morag has become the youngest-ever winner at the Bafta Children's awards.

    Katie Morag acress Cherry Campbell

    Cherry Campbell was named best performer at the awards.

    The show, about a feisty and independent girl who lives on a Scottish island with her family, also won the award for best drama.

     
  12.  
    08:21: Body found in burn

    Police in Dumfries and Galloway are investigating the death of a man after a body was found in Dalbeattie.

    Colliston Park

    The 67-year-old was found in a burn at the town's Colliston Park at 18:45 on Sunday.

    Police Scotland said the death was being treated as unexplained.

     
  13.  
    08:15: Tributes to boy killed by van

    Relatives of an 11-year-old boy who died after being hit by a van in Aberdeenshire have paid tribute to their "amazing boy".

    Bobby Douglas

    Bobby Douglas, from Newtonhill, was struck by the vehicle near the Newtonhill flyover on the A90 at 18:20 on Friday.

    He died after being taken to the Aberdeen Sick Children's Hospital.

     
  14.  
    08:11: Travel update BBC Scotland Travel Latest

    Traffic is heavier than normal on #A720 Edinburgh City By-Pass Eastbound between M8 J1 (Hermiston Gait) and B701 (Baberton Junction).

     
  15.  
    08:09: C. diff report due Eleanor Bradford BBC Scotland Health Correspondent

    A five-year inquiry into Scotland's worst outbreak of Clostridium difficile (C. diff) will be published later.

    The probe, led by Lord MacLean, looked at the treatment of 63 patients at Vale of Leven Hospital in Dunbartonshire between December 2007 and June 2008.

    Of the 31 patients who died, C. diff was a contributory factor in 28 cases.

    The Vale of Leven Hospital report is due

    The independent inquiry was ordered in 2009 and completed at a cost of about £10m. Publication of the report had previously been delayed five times.

    C. diff is a bacteria which lives harmlessly in the gut of 10% to 15% of adults but causes diarrhoea when the delicate balance of gut flora is disturbed, often following a course of antibiotics.

     
  16.  
    08:06: Coming up... Gary Robertson BBC Radio Scotland

    Five-year inquiry into Scotland's worst outbreak of Clostridium difficile published at lunchtime. More #bbcgms 0815

    Good Morning Scotland

    You can listen live to BBC Radio's Good Morning Scotland here.

     
  17.  
    08:03: Weather update BBC Scotland Weather Latest

    Morning! Gillian here. 5-7C to start for most. Largely dry, best of the sunshine in the east of the country. Cloudier in the west with rain on the west coast later. This evening: cloud and patchy rain will pass across the country, then skies will clear, winds ease, allowing a widespread frost and mist/fog.

     
  18.  
    08:02: Book Week

    The director of the Scottish Book Trust has said every child in Scotland should be automatically enrolled in their local library.

    Scottish Book Week

    Marc Lambert made the call at the start of Book Week Scotland.

    He said the move would not only benefit children but would also secure the future of libraries.

     
  19.  
    08:00: Welcome Thomas McGuigan BBC Scotland News

    Good morning and a warm welcome to Monday's edition of Scotland Live as we offer a comprehensive round up of the biggest news and sports news until 18:00.

     

Features

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.