Scottish independence: Trident relocation 'very difficult but not impossible'

test firing of Trident missile Nuclear weapons would be removed from an independent Scotland by 2020 under the Scottish government's proposed timetable

Moving Trident nuclear submarines out of an independent Scotland would be very difficult but "not impossible", according to a study.

The report by the Royal United Services Institute (Rusi) also said relocating the submarines would be far cheaper than previously assumed.

But it could take a decade to build a base for the submarines elsewhere in the UK, it said.

The SNP wants to remove nuclear weapons within four years of independence.

The submarines carrying the UK's nuclear deterrent currently operate from the Faslane naval base on the Clyde.

There have been concerns over how they could be relocated in the event of a "Yes" vote in September's independence referendum.

Milford Haven in Wales and "the most obvious replacement", Devonport base in Plymouth, have been suggested as potential new homes for the submarines.

Falmouth in Cornwall is named as a possible munitions site.

Start Quote

The UK government has choices on what it decides to do with its nuclear weapons following their removal from an independent Scotland”

End Quote Scottish government

Former cabinet minister Lord Forsyth has previously warned that the potential difficulties of moving the submarines would mean that the UK could be forced to give up its nuclear deterrent if Scotland votes in favour of independence.

But in their paper, Rusi research analyst Hugh Chalmers and research director Malcolm Chalmers said relocating Trident would be both financially and technically feasible.

They suggested that recreating the required nuclear facilities outside Scotland would add between £2.5-3.5bn to the cost of maintaining a nuclear-armed fleet, plus the cost of acquiring and clearing land.

This would be far less than a previously-predicted £20-25bn, they said.

Hugh Chalmers said the research by the military think tank contrasted with an "unlikely consensus" between supporters and opponents of Scottish independence that it would be impossible to relocate the nuclear weapons elsewhere.

If the question mark over Trident's future could be answered, it would help untangle a difficult issue surrounding Scottish independence, he added.

line
Analysis: Jonathan Beale, BBC defence correspondent

Britain's nuclear deterrent doesn't come cheap. It'll cost around £20bn to replace the current fleet of four Trident submarines, sometime during the next decade.

Not everyone's convinced - either in Parliament or the MOD - that the UK can afford or really needs a like for like replacement.

This study, by the distinguished defence think tank Rusi, highlights the additional costs if Scotland votes for independence.

It concludes that moving the deterrent from the Clyde and the secure storage facilities for the warheads at Coulport is financially and technically feasible but wouldn't be cheap - between an additional £2.5bn to £3.5bn.

It'll also cost a lot of political capital - persuading people of Plymouth and Falmouth that it's in their interests to have the deterrent and warheads based in their backyard instead.

The Ministry of Defence has already had to cut its cloth to the tougher economic climate. It would rather not contemplate an even bigger dent to its finances as a result of a "Yes" vote.

line

Mr Chalmers said: "When people start considering options for relocations it's only natural to assume that it would be quite expensive and very difficult and that is certainly the case. But importantly it is not impossible.

"We estimate that essentially the net costs of relocating could actually be £2.5-3.5bn at 2012 prices, rather than the tens of billions or even £20bn that has been put forward so far."

Start Quote

It is difficult to estimate the total costs, or how long it would take, to replicate the facilities at Faslane, but it would likely cost taxpayers billions of pounds and take many years”

End Quote Ministry of Defence

But he said it would take a long time, and was unlikely to be completed by the SNP's target date of 2020.

Mr Chalmers said: "It may be possible to deactivate Trident by that point and have it out of Scotland but it's unlikely we would have been able to have it up and running in a new location by that point.

"The Scottish government has acknowledged that if they were to become independent there would be a period of time where the UK would be basing its nuclear forces in an independent country. The UK would be the first country to ever do this."

A more "natural timeframe" would be linked to the entry of a new generation of nuclear-armed submarines, currently anticipated to start in 2028, he argued.

Mr Chalmers said the Rusi paper showed the possibility of a "space for a friendly and amicable settlement" over Trident in the event of independence.

He added: "Effectively this is a key aspect of any negotiations that will emerge after a Yes vote.

"This will be a very, very important issue. If both Scotland and the UK can show that they can come to some sort of amicable arrangement then that untangles a very knotty issue.

"We are trying to essentially dispel the myth that relocating Trident out of Scotland is impossible and in doing so create some space allowing an amicable settlement to be reached in the event of a Yes vote."

'Speedy withdrawal'

A spokeswoman for the Scottish government said: "As Rusi's paper shows, the UK government has choices on what it decides to do with its nuclear weapons following their removal from an independent Scotland, including of course the potential to reconsider the possession and planned renewal of Trident.

"The Scottish government will work responsibly with the government in Westminster in securing the speediest safe withdrawal of Trident from an independent Scotland.

"We look forward to the opportunity to discuss these arrangements with the UK government following a vote for independence."

A Ministry of Defence spokeswoman said: "There are no plans to move Trident from Her Majesty's Naval Base Clyde and unilateral disarmament is not an option.

"We are not planning for Scottish independence and as such it is difficult to estimate the total costs, or how long it would take, to replicate the facilities at Faslane, but it would likely cost taxpayers billions of pounds and take many years."

trident infographic

More on This Story

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More Scotland politics stories

RSS

Scotland Live

  1.  
    @BBCKheredine Murray watch Kheredine Idessane BBC Scotland

    A fan's eye view of @andy_murray as he rewards those on Margaret Court who watched his practice with some autographs.

    Andy Murray at the Australian Open
     
  2.  
    09:06: Job creation drive

    The Scottish Labour Party will today publish a bill at Westminster calling for the immediate transfer to Holyrood of job creation powers.

    Shadow Business Minister Ian Murray's bill would devolve responsibility for the work programme ahead of the general election.

    Labour says it may force a Commons vote on the issue next month.

    The UK government says Labour's proposal is flawed and insists the powers will be devolved as part of further devolution legislation by whoever is in power after May's general election.

     
  3.  
    Email: newsonlinescotland@bbc.co.uk Your pictures - Get involved

    Gill Williamson took this picture at the Up Helly Aa festival while on a break with friends in Shetland.

    up helly aa

    Email us your pictures from around the country for our photo gallery and we'll use the best.

     
  4.  
    08:44: Oil and gas taskforce

    A taskforce which aims to support jobs across the energy sector will meet for the first time in Aberdeen.

    oil rig

    The new Energy Jobs Taskforce, which was established by Scotland's First Minister Nicola Sturgeon, will focus initially on the oil and gas industry.

    It includes figures from the oil and gas sector, enterprise bodies, local and central government and unions.

    The taskforce will be chaired by Scottish Enterprise chief executive Lena Wilson.

    It will report to the Scottish Energy Advisory Board.

     
  5.  
    @BBCKheredine Tennis defeat Kheredine Idessane BBC Scotland

    Disappointment for Scotland's @GordonReid91 - knocked out of the Australian Open singles 6-2, 6-4 by his doubles partner here, Gustavo Fernandez, Arg.

     
  6.  
    08:37: 'Cut whisky tax'

    The Scotch Whisky Association has backed research which shows our national drink is worth £5bn to the UK economy and urged Chancellor George Osborne to do more to help producers.

    Chief executive David Frost told BBC Scotland's Good Morning Scotland programme: "I think the government took a great decision last year in abolishing the duty escalator and freezing duty on spirits and Scotch whisky.

    "We would like them to follow the logic of that decision this year, to stop taxing a sector that is so successful. Follow the logic and cut duty by 2% this year at the Budget."

     
  7.  
    @bbcweather Cold snap BBC Weather Latest

    Today gets colder, and for a few...snowier! Weather warnings: http://bbc.in/1yMuS9C Here's you day in pictures

    Weather map
     
  8.  
    Text 80295 Vouchers for pregnant smokers - Your views

    John Ross, Edinburgh: Research in other areas has shown that such financial incentives will only lead to an increase in smoking among pregnant women so that more women can claim reward for apparently stopping smoking later.

    Stephen Mather: Shame that some are more interested in health of their purse than health of their child.

     
  9.  
    08:17: Vouchers for pregnant smokers

    One of the lead authors, Professor David Tappin, hopes the scheme will be rolled out across the UK.

    "It (the voucher) was £400 split into four points during pregnancy," he told BBC Radio's Good Morning Scotland. "The first point was if they engaged with the pregnancy cessation services, and set a quit date, they got £50.

    Smoking

    "Then, if they were quit four weeks later they got a second £50 voucher and if they had still quit after 12 weeks then they got a £100 voucher.

    "And, if they had quit towards the end of their pregnancy, they got a final £200 voucher.

    "When women are young, and the time they're having babies, if you stop them smoking at that point, their probably going to get the same life expectancy and health outcomes as a non-smoker.

    "This study has only been done in Glasgow and needs to be done in other places around the UK with different rates of smoking.

    "If that future study shows that it is cost effective, then I think National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (Nice) would recommend it."

     
  10.  
    @trafficscotland Here we snow again

    Traffic Scotland tweets: #Snow now showing on the #A82 at Altnafeadh (East of Glencoe)-Take extra care, visibility will be reduced. #StaySafe

    snow on A82
     
  11.  
    @bbcscotlandnews Vouchers for pregnant smokers - Your views

    Iain Dick tweets: I guess having a healthy full term baby isn't enough incentive!

    Louise Agnew: You would think their health and the health of their unborn baby would be incentive enough.

    Culag Park: Bonkers. Surely the incentive is to have a healthy baby? Why not give £400 vouchers to those who don't smoke as a thank you?

     
  12.  
    @BBCTravelScot Snow on the way... BBC Scotland Travel Latest

    Snow in the air - across the #M80- can't see it lying but be aware in case it affects visibility.

     
  13.  
    07:55: Monte Carlo Rally starts in Paisley

    Thousands of people are expected to gather in Paisley later for the UK start of the Monte Carlo Classic Rally.

    Monte Carlo Classic Rally

    About 70 classic cars - including Porsches, Mini Coopers and Linwood-built Hillman Imps - will set off from Paisley Abbey at about 18:45.

    They will join competing cars from the other start cities of Barcelona, Turin, Copenhagen and Reims on the 1,670-mile (2,688km) route to the French Riviera.

    The rally is expected to generate more than £1m for the Renfrewshire economy.

     
  14.  
    Text 80295 Vouchers for pregnant smokers - Your views

    M: If a woman can't stop smoking for the health of her child then I don't think a financial incentive will do it. If that's what'll do it, then I think it's a sad state of affairs for their unborn child!

     
  15.  
    07:42: What the papers say

    The Scottish Daily Mail claims an exclusive with a report that defence officials are secretly drawing up plans to move Britain's nuclear-armed submarines from Scotland to Wales.

    Scotland's newspapers

    The Scotsman leads with figures showing that almost half of all pupils taking Highers will sit the old exam rather than the new qualification.

    The Times focuses on the review of the spiralling costs of the new V&A project in Dundee.

    Read our full review of today's papers here.

     
  16.  
    @BBCJamesCook Intelligence gathering... James Cook Scotland Correspondent, BBC News

    What do Scotland's councils and GCHQ have in common? bbc.in/1z1wxIO by @marceellison #BigBrother

    Surveillance
     
  17.  
    07:34: Councils' spying missions Marc Ellison Data journalist, BBC Scotland

    Scottish councils used covert surveillance on hundreds of occasions over the last three years, according to data obtained by BBC Scotland.

    camera

    Local authorities authorised 460 clandestine investigations into issues ranging from drugs and prostitution to dog fouling and underage sunbed use.

    The figures show an overall decline in the use of the powers.

    But campaigners said they were being used to investigate "less serious" crimes than originally planned.

     
  18.  
    07:27: 'Shark attack' on killer whale

    A shark has been suspected of biting a chunk out of the tail fluke of a killer whale well-known to whale and dolphin watchers in Scotland.

    Tail of orca called John Coe
    Killer whale John Coe

    Nicknamed John Coe, the male orca can be identified by a notch on its dorsal fin.

    The injury to its tail was spotted during a survey by the Hebridean Whale and Dolphin Trust (HWDT).

    The trust said consultations with experts suggested that it was "almost certainly" caused by a shark.

    John Coe is one of a small community of orcas regularly seen off Scotland's west coast.

     
  19.  
    Text 80295 Fracking - Your views

    Peter: You do know there was a vote at Westminster this week regarding fracking? And guess what? Scottish Labour MPs abstained and Jim Murphy couldn't be bothered to even turn up.

    Lynn, Forfar: I hope you will point out that Jim Murphy didn't even attend Westminster for the fracking vote while he was telling us up here that is against fracking.

     
  20.  
    07:20: Whisky jobs galore

    Scotch whisky contributes almost £5bn to the UK economy and supports more than 40,000 jobs, according to research commissioned by the industry.

    scotch whisky

    The Scotch Whisky Association (SWA) said the sector now accounted for 25% of total UK food and drink exports.

    Its report also suggests that the industry's direct economic impact had grown by 21% since 2008, to £3.3bn.

    It found it added more value to the economy than shipbuilding, iron and steel, textiles or computing.

     
  21.  
    07:15: Call for fracking ban

    Labour has urged Scottish ministers to take further steps to thwart the prospect of fracking for shale gas in Scotland.

    fracking

    Energy Minister Fergus Ewing will make a statement on the issue at Holyrood today.

    Labour says he should use the opportunity to place a series of obstacles in the path of unconventional gas extraction.

    However, the Tories are warning that banning fracking could jeopardise Scottish jobs.

     
  22.  
    @bbcscotlandnews Vouchers for pregnant smokers - Your views

    Fiona Shields tweets: Shopping vouchers for pregnant women who give up smoking?? What about those of us who didn't smoke? Where's my £400?

     
  23.  
    @BBCGaryR Coming up... Gary Robertson BBC Radio Scotland

    Scottish space industry doubles its turnover in three years & employs over 5000 people. @macdonke looks at its prospects #bbcgms 0720

    Good Morning Scotland

    Listen live to the programme here.

     
  24.  
    Text 80295 Vouchers for pregnant smokers - Your views

    John, Edinburgh: Unfortunately, research in other areas has shown that such financial incentives will only lead to an increase in smoking among pregnant women so that more women can claim reward for apparently stopping smoking later.

    Anon: Paying pregnant women to stop smoking: outrageous, ridiculous and an embarrassing waste of taxpayers' money, seeing as there was still an 80% failure rate. Surely if smoking in public places is banned due to the harm it causes people, then smoking whilst pregnant should be banned due to the harm it causes the poor unborn children?!

     
  25.  
    07:06: Vouchers 'help pregnant smokers quit'

    Offering shopping vouchers worth £400 to pregnant smokers makes them more likely to quit the habit, say researchers.

    pregnant smoker

    They have published the results of a trial involving 600 women from Glasgow in the British Medical Journal.

    More than 20% of the women offered vouchers stopped smoking, compared with 9% given normal NHS support alone.

    The Royal College of Midwives said incentivising healthy behaviours using money was "not ideal" - and expensive.

     
  26.  
    @BBCScotWeather Wintry weather warning BBC Scotland Weather Latest

    Met Office issues yellow 'be aware' warning for snow showers across Scotland. Valid from 8am today & lasting all day Thurs.

    Snow warning
     
  27.  
    07:01: Snow on the way...

    Yellow "be aware" warnings have been issued by the Met Office for frequent snow showers across Scotland.

    The warnings are in place across the entire country from 08:00 on Wednesday to 23:55 on Thursday.

    About 5-10cm (1-3in) is expected at lower levels with 10cm (5in) over higher ground.

    Weather map

    BBC Weather's Chris Blanchett said: "By [this] morning, there will be snow across the northwest Highlands.

    "During the day that snow level will come down, and we'll see snow showers across central and southern Scotland as well."

     
  28.  
    07:00: Rise and shine Thomas McGuigan BBC Scotland News

    Good morning and a wintry welcome form the Scotland Live team. Any snow where you are yet?

    Stay with us until 19:00 as we bring you news, sport, travel and weather from across the country.

     

Features

Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.