Scotland's Justice Secretary alleges lack of consultation on surveillance powers

Kenny MacAskill Kenny MacAskill said the emergency legislation "potentially impinges" on Scots law

Related Stories

Scottish Justice Secretary Kenny MacAskill has accused the UK government of a "lack of prior consultation" over surveillance powers.

Emergency powers to enable police and security services to continue to access phone and internet records are being rushed through the UK Parliament.

The move has the backing of the three main Westminster parties.

Mr MacAskill said the legislation could affect Scots law and matters devolved to the Scottish government.

Prime Minister David Cameron defended the move in a joint news conference with Deputy Prime Minister Nick Clegg, saying it was about maintaining existing capabilities - not introducing new snooping laws.

An EU directive requiring phone and internet companies to retain communications data - when and who their customers called, texted and emailed but not what was said - for a 12-month period was ruled unlawful in April by the European Court.

Mr Cameron claimed the emergency legislation, which would mean firms can retain data for 12 months, was needed to prevent companies fearing legal challenges destroying the information within weeks, meaning police and the security services would not be able to access it.

MacAskill said: "We are disappointed at the lack of prior consultation and discussion from UK government on today's announcement given how much this legislation potentially impinges on areas of Scots law that are clearly devolved and under the jurisdiction of the Scottish government or our law enforcement agencies, including the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service.

David Cameron and Nick Clegg David Cameron and Nick Clegg held a joint news conference on the emergency legislation

"While the retention of communications data is currently a reserved matter, the Scottish government takes the safety and security of our communities extremely seriously.

"In an independent Scotland, this government will set out clear arrangements for investigatory powers, updating existing legislation where necessary.

"This will ensure that law enforcement agencies have the powers that they need to do their job and keep Scotland safe, while also clarifying the limit of those powers and the extent of the controls over them."

Mr Cameron said: "We face real and credible threats to our security from serious and organised crime, from the activity of paedophiles, from the collapse of Syria, the growth of Isis in Iraq and al Shabab in East Africa.

"I am simply not prepared to be a prime minister who has to address the people after a terrorist incident and explain that I could have done more to prevent it."

He stressed that the measures were about "plugging holes" in the legislation but were not about any "new obligations for phone and internet companies, nor any new intrusions on civil liberties".

The UK government claimed the planned legislation would contain safeguards, including the creation of a new oversight board and a "sunset clause" ensuring the powers end in 2016, enabling a longer and wider debate about what would replace them.

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More Scotland politics stories



  • Dandie DinmontJust Dandie

    How a painting revealed the story of a rare terrier breed

  • A sign reading Calais (Alcatraz)Fortress Calais

    Why people who once had good jobs are living in despair

  • MilkHard bargain

    Do dairy farmers really make a loss on milk?

  • Maud GonneGonne's tragedy

    Why Ireland's heroine had sex in her baby son's tomb

  • Baby smiling10 things

    Who smiles more - Dutch babies or US babies?

Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.