Scottish independence: Conservative MSP calls for a federal UK

Murdo Fraser Murdo Fraser will argue that federalism could "unite both unionists and many nationalists"

Conservative MSP Murdo Fraser is expected to call for a federal UK in a speech at Glasgow University.

Mr Fraser will say that a federal option could create "common ground" between supporters and opponents of Scottish independence.

His proposals include a written constitution and replacing the House of Lords with a senate to represent the federated areas of the UK.

SNP MSP Stuart McMillan called the proposals "pie in the sky".

Analysis

Murdo Fraser has a reputation for radical thinking in the Conservative party.

He lost out on the Tory leadership in 2011 having argued for the Scottish party to breakaway from the UK Conservatives.

The MSP is now turning his attention to redesigning the UK if there's a "No" vote in the independence referendum.

He believes a federal UK could be an "alternative" to independence that would unite many nationalists and unionists.

Mr Fraser acknowledges that England has shown little appetite for regional government but argues this may change as Holyrood gains new powers.

The SNP said his proposals were "pie in the sky" because they do not represent official Conservative party policy.

The Yes Scotland campaign said only independence would guarantee the powers it believes Holyrood needs.

He said the changes Mr Fraser was advocating were "simply not on the table" and the "No" campaign parties had "completely failed to reach any common position on more powers for Scotland".

Mr Fraser, the Scottish Conservatives' spokesman on enterprise, energy and tourism and a former deputy leader of the party, will give a lecture organised by the think tank Reform Scotland.

'Common ground'

He is expected to say: "A referendum with a binary Yes/No question was always bound to polarise opinion.

"But is there really no common ground between these two different stances? Is there no alternative around which a substantial majority of the Scottish people could coalesce?

"I would suggest that federalism within the UK, if it were workable and could be achieved, is a solution which could unite both unionists, and many nationalists, and provide a secure framework for the future."

Mr Fraser will argue that federalism for Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland would be "comparatively straightforward" as the three nations have devolved administrations.

He will call for devolution to English regions, giving the example of the creation of the London Assembly and an elected mayor for the city.

Ruth Davidson and Lord Strathclyde Conservative leader Ruth Davidson outlined her party's devolution proposals earlier this month

Mr Fraser's comments go further than his party's devolution proposals, which would give the Scottish Parliament additional responsibility over VAT, income tax and welfare if voters reject independence in the referendum in September.

The option of federalism or further devolution will not be put to referendum voters, who will be asked the Yes/No question: "Should Scotland be an independent country?"

'Full powers'

Mr McMillan, from the SNP, said: "The 'No' campaign parties accepting that Scotland needs more powers is galvanising the 'Yes' vote.

"Scotland needs the full economic and welfare powers of independence, which only a 'Yes' vote can deliver, and barely a third of people trust Westminster to deliver anything. That is why a 'Yes' vote is so important."

He added: "In an independent Scotland we will get the government we vote for every time, instead of Tory governments we reject - as well as saving taxpayers some £50m per year by getting rid of the Westminster tier in Scotland."

More on This Story

More Scotland politics stories

RSS

Scotland Live

  1.  
    Highlights from Day Two 10:17:

    Watch BBC Scotland's Andy Burke's round up of Day Two at the Commonwealth Games for Scotland.

    Daniel Wallace at Glasgow 2014
     
  2.  
    Park and ride delays 10:07:

    Reports of long delays on the park and ride at Eurocentral, with thousands of rugby fans trying to get to Ibrox.

    Ibrox is hosting the rugby sevens at Glasgow 2014

    One disgruntled passenger has texted in to say: "Now on a bus to Ibrox 75 minutes after getting to park and ride at Eurocentral, but massive queues still! Buses now seem to be arriving but those still at Eurocentral will probably miss the start of the 7's."

     
  3.  
    Today's papers 09:55:

    Most of the Scottish papers lead with three-year-old Mikaeel Kular's mother admitting to killing him.

    The Scotsman says an independent review into the death of Mikaeel is to take place after his mother admitted killing the toddler.

    Scotsman front page July 26 2014

    The Daily Record, meanwhile, reports that his mother beat him to death because he was sick after eating ice cream.

    Read the Paper Review and see the front pages.

     
  4.  
    Barbados rugby stars 09:39: Graham Fraser BBC Scotland

    At around 18:00 tonight, Scotland will play Barbados in the rugby sevens.

    The Barbados team will play in front of thousands of fans at Ibrox Stadium after a late call up to the Games.

    One of their players is car mechanic Sean Ward.

    Barbados rugby sevens team

    Some of the team are based in the UK, while the Barbados-based players train on the beach or in Sean's back garden using tyres.

     
  5.  
    Lawn bowls fightback 09:34:

    Watch Scotland pair Paul Foster and Alex Marshall bowl their way to an "impossible" comeback after going 15-7 against South Africa's Jason Evans and Jerry Baker in the lawn bowls yesterday.

    lawn bowls

    The Scots managed to score 3-1-5 in the final three ends and, with the last ball, South Africa could not reply, meaning a 16-15 win for Foster and Marshall.

    You can watch all the latest in the lawn bowls on the BBC Sport website.

     
  6.  
    Latest travel 09:27:

    A very busy day at the Commonwealth Games means delays and disruption is likely. So if you're heading to or past the SECC, Ibrox, Scotstoun, Glasgow Green, Tollcross or at the Barry Buddon shooting centre in Carnoustie, be prepared for delays and leave extra time for your journey.

    SECC

    In East Renfrewshire, the A727 East Kilbride Road in Clarkston is closed because of an accident. Police are directing traffic.

    And trains through Motherwell are returning to normal after an earlier signalling fault.

     
  7.  
    Latest weather 09:15:

    Dry with some bright or sunny spells for most but rain will reach the west coast by around lunchtime, and extend north-eastwards across the Highlands this afternoon.

    Some of this rain will turn heavy with thunder. Across the south and east it should remain largely dry but with the risk of a shower around Glasgow. Another very warm day with highs peaking at 26C in sheltered parts of the northeast.

     
  8.  
    Flotilla excitement 09:06: Laura Bicker Scotland Correspondent, BBC News

    The boats are piped out James Watt Dock Marina. The logistics of getting the fleet of 250 boats safely out of the harbour is proving challenging. The Clyde looks calm and serene this morning.

    Commonwealth flotilla

    People on board are excitedly chattering on the radio and to each other. The plan is to muster out just outside the harbour before sailing down the Clyde. All the boats are decked out with flags and banners gently waving in the breeze.

    It should be a spectacular sight for those along the route.

     
  9.  
    This evening's highlights 08:54: Andrew Southwick BBC Scotland

    18:00 - Judo: An intriguing side story with Scot Euan Burton and wife Gemma Gibbons both competing, but under different flags. Burton represents the host nation in the 100kg men's category, while Gibbons will compete for England in the 78kg women's category.

    Ross Murdoch in tears after winning Commonwealth gold

    18:40 - Boxing: Scotland's Josh Taylor - Commonwealth silver medallist (at lightweight) in 2010 - faces Botswana's Kagiso Bagwasi at 64kg.

    20:50 - Swimming: He won the nation's hearts with his tears on the opening day, and Scotland will be hoping for more when Ross Murdoch goes for another medal in the 100m Breaststroke final.

     
  10.  
    Rangers appoint Nash 08:41:

    If you missed it last night, Rangers have appointed financial consultant Philip Nash to their board of directors.

    The former Arsenal and Liverpool executive will assume the position immediately, having been a consultant at Ibrox since January 2014.

    Ibrox

    An accountant and former banker, Nash was brought to the club by chief executive Graham Wallace.

    Read Richard Wilson's report.

     
  11.  
    Karen Gillan transformed 08:30:

    Scots actress Karen Gillan is to appear in her biggest movie role yet in Marvel's sci-fi action adventure Guardians of the Galaxy.

    Inverness-born Gillan's big break came when she was cast as Doctor Who companion Amy Pond.

    Karen Gillan in Guardians of the Galaxy

    While Pond was part of a force for good, Gillan's character in Guardians of the Galaxy has a villainous dark side. It certainly looks like it.

     
  12.  
    This morning's highlights 08:16: Andrew Southwick BBC Scotland

    08:45 - Lawn bowls: Scotland are confident of medals at Kelvingrove. In the men's triples sectional the top two of Scotland and Wales go head-to-head, and in the women's sectional group stage world champion Caroline Brown carries the home nation's hopes against Australia's Kelsey Cottrell.

    Scotland are also in action in the men's pairs and women's fours.

    Hannah Miley with her 400m individual medley gold medal

    10:30 - Rugby sevens: Ibrox makes it's Glasgow 2014 debut today. It does not get much tougher for Scotland in their opening match, with four-time champions New Zealand squaring up to them in pool A. The All-Blacks have never lost a game at the Commonwealth Games.

    Scotland also face Canada and Barbados in the evening.

    10:40 - Swimming: The 400m individual medley gold medal winner Hannah Miley is back in the pool in the women's 200m Breaststroke heats.

    Scotland are also aiming for a place in the women's 4x200m Freestyle final.

    You can watch all the latest Commonwealth Games events on the BBC Sport website.

     
  13.  
    Pool Party 08:08:

    It was Scotland's pool party, but where was the poster boy? BBC Sport's Aimee Lewis reflects on Scotland's success in the pool and the disappointments for Michael Jamieson.

    Michael J
     
  14.  
    07:50: Via Twitter Huw Williams BBC Scotland reporter

    tweets: Crew of the Lerwick registered Swan taking part in @Flotilla2014 and live on @BBCRadioScot Out of Doors.

    Commonwealth flotilla crew

    Listen live to Radio Scotland.

     
  15.  
    Last night at the Games 07:33:

    It was another great night in the pool for Scotland last night as Daniel Wallace won gold in the 400m Individual Medley.

    Daniel Wallace

    Meanwhile, Neil Fachie and Craig Maclean won Scotland's first Commonwealth Games cycling gold with victory in the Para-cycling 1000m tandem time trial for blind and visually impaired athletes.

    However, it was disappointment again for Michael Jamieson after he finished fifth in the 100m breaststroke semi-final meaning he will miss the final.

     
  16.  
    Sir Jackie's car up for sale 07:13:

    Racing legend Sir Jackie Stewart's first ever race car is set to go under the hammer.

    The 1960 Marcos GT Xylon is being offered for sale this weekend by Silverstone Auctions.

    Sir Jackie Stewart's car

    Only nine Xylons were built by Marcos, which was founded in 1959 by racer Jem Marsh and engineer Frank Costin.

    The auction estimate is between £35,000 and £50,000.

     
  17.  
    Commonwealth flotilla 07:07:

    The largest flotilla ever seen on the River Clyde will sail from Greenock to Glasgow later as part of the city's Commonwealth Games celebrations.

    Commonwealth flotilla

    About 250 boats are due to leave from Greenock at 10:00 and arrive at Pacific Quay, home of BBC Scotland, at 13:00.

    Small ships, leisure yachts and clipper and working boats will be taking part.

     
  18.  
  19.  
    Good morning 06:58: Graham Fraser BBC Scotland

    Good morning and welcome to BBC Scotland Live. We'll be here until 23:00 bringing you all the latest news, sport, weather and travel from across the country, including all the action and atmosphere from the Glasgow 2014 Commonwealth Games.

    Keep in touch and send us your comments and pics via Twitter using #ScotlandLive, by email or by text on 80295.

     

Features

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.