Scottish independence: Prof Patrick Dunleavy makes £200m start-up claim

Professor Patrick Dunleavy

An independent Scotland would face £200m of immediate start-up costs, it has been claimed.

Prof Patrick Dunleavy gave the figure in a report commissioned by The Sunday Post.

A spokesman for the First Minister said the UK Treasury's previous £2.7bn figure had been "blown out the water".

A UK Treasury spokesperson said the Scottish government was "refusing to come clean" on the cost of independence.

Prof Dunleavy, from the London School of Economics, said an independent Scotland could have to spend between £150m to £200m on new administrative structures to replace existing UK bodies.

Although an independent Scotland could share UK bodies during the transition to independence, it would have to build its own systems by 2021 to the cost of hundreds of millions of pounds, he claimed.

However, he added that a hostile approach from the UK government in post-Yes negotiations could "greatly add" to the cost.

The key points from the paper include:

  • Immediate set up costs of up to £200m to create new versions of existing UK bodies
  • The total would increase if UK ministers take a "hostile stance" in post-Yes negotiations
  • The costs could be offset due to Scotland having a "smaller government machine", spending less on areas such as defence
  • The initial expenditure should be seen as an investment which will save on future running costs
  • The long-run viability of an independent Scotland is "generally high"

Prof Dunleavy's latest work comes after he dismissed the UK Treasury's use of his research to calculate £2.7bn of start-up costs as "ludicrous".

'Utterly demolished'

A spokesperson for the First Minister said Prof Dunleavy's findings "totally vindicate" the Scottish government's position.

He said: "Their figure of £2.7bn has been blown out of the water by Prof Dunleavy.

"The Treasury estimate has been exposed as a total and utter fabrication, and we now demand an immediate retraction.

"The No campaign's arguments have been totally and utterly demolished, and we now need a retraction both from the Treasury and the No side."

He added: "The set-up costs, which Prof Dunleavy estimates at £200m, would be offset against the scope that he has pointed out for efficiencies from better delivery of services."

'Come clean'

However, a Treasury spokesperson said the Scottish government was "refusing to come clean" on the cost of independence.

The spokesperson said: "Prof Dunleavy accepts there may be over a billion pounds in additional costs to Scotland at a time when the economy and our national finances are recovering.

"In addition, independent estimates show that setting up a new tax system is costing £750 million in New Zealand, and research from the Department of Work and Pensions says that a new welfare and pensions IT system alone would cost between £300 million and £400 million.

The spokesperson added: "The Scottish Government has refused to come clean with its own number on the cost of independence and only the UK Government is providing the facts."

More on This Story

More Scotland politics stories


Scotland Live

    BBC Scotland Travel Latest

    #FortAugustus #A82 RTC between Canal Side (Fort Augustus) and A887 (Invermoriston).

    Bout 1 1/2 miles N of Fort Augustus.

    08:06: BBC Scotland Weather Latest

    A cold, icy start in places with frost away from the coast. A chilly day ahead with a good amount of dry and sunny weather for the Central Lowlands, east coast and south.

    For the Highlands, Northern Grampian and the Isles, frequent showers through the day. These are of rain or sleet to low levels, and of snow on high ground and high road routes. Winds remains strong in the north from a northerly direction.

    Highs this afternoon around 5 or 6 C - colder where there is snow on the ground.

    07:59: Continental market suspended

    A continental market's licence to trade in Stranraer has been suspended.


    The decision was made after a number of the market's traders set up in the town last July without booking in advance.

    Their position in Castle Square meant an event organised by Stranraer Music Town had to be cancelled.

    07:53: End of poll tax debts approved in principle

    Plans to end the collection of poll tax debts in Scotland have been approved in principle by the Scottish Parliament.

    Poll tax

    The community charge debt bill was passed by 96 votes to 14, although it still faces two further stages of scrutiny before becoming law. Some councils are opposed to the legislation.

    07:41: Scotland's papers

    Andy Murray's fiancée Kim Sears features on many of the front pages as he secured his place in the Australian Open final. What the papers say.

    07:34: More snow falls overnight

    Eddie Ross, BEAR Scotland's North West Operating Company Representative, says: ''The North West and North East Trunk Roads have experienced intermittent snow showers throughout the night on most routes.

    A835 at Altguish near Garve in Highlands

    "Our winter teams have worked throughout the night and the Trunk Roads in North West and North East are clear and currently have no issues.

    ''We will continue to monitor weather conditions and patrol and treat routes as necessary throughout this period of winter weather. We encourage motorists to check travel updates before setting out, prepare for their journeys and drive with care as these wintery conditions are set to continue into next week."

  7. 07:27: Your Pictures

    Neil Cameron sent this image of a sunset on Loch Linnhe taken from Camusnagaul ferry.

    Sunset on Loch Linnhe

    Email your pictures to

    You can also tell us what you think of the week's pictures on the BBC Scotland News facebook page.

    07:18: BBC Scotland Travel Latest

    Roads: A77 Girvan road is described as "just passable" because of snow between Girvan and Stranraer; the road was closed from 9 last night till just after midnight.

    A risk of ice wherever there's been a bit of thaw, especially on side roads.

    Trains: No reported problems

    Ferries: Cal Mac- No sailings to and from Lewis-(Ullapool -Stornoway). Tomorrow's sailings are on amber alert.

    Northlink- Possible disruption between Aberdeen and Lerwick.

    07:10: Firefighter deaths 'should have been prevented'

    The deaths of some firefighters in the UK since 2004 "could and should have been prevented", a report has said.

    Building on fire

    The report - commissioned by the Fire Brigades Union (FBU) - looked into 14 deaths of firefighters in the last 10 years and warned "good practice" had sometimes been ignored.

    Research was carried out at the University of Stirling.

    07:04: More snow and ice forecast

    The Met Office has issued yellow "be aware" warnings for snow and ice across Scotland this morning.

    Snowy composite

    The warnings will also remain in place for northern and western regions of the country for Saturday, Sunday and Monday.

    Showers of sleet and hail are also expected, with between 1-3cm of further snow at lower levels.

    The A77 Girvan to Stranraer road was described as "just passable" due to snow.

    07:00: Good morning Sandy Murray BBC Scotland news

    Hullo and welcome to Scotland Live on Friday.

    If you are driving anywhere this morning, leave enough time to clear your car windows. Like I should have done.

    Throughout the day, we will keep you up to date with the latest weather, travel, news and sport.



  • SnowIn pictures

    Images of the snow which has fallen across many parts of Scotland

  • WW1 gas mask being demonstratedTrench terror

    Did the soldiers of WW1 have an irrational fear of poison gas?

  • Gabrielle Derameaux in her class Class struggle

    French teachers on the front line after Charlie Hebdo attack

  • ManDay in the life

    What really goes on in a care home?

  • Baby in boxStrange case

    The remarkable appeal of the Finnish baby boxes

Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.