Scottish independence: Think tank concern over 'Yes' state pensions

Lady The Scottish government said it had set out plans for an affordable and fair pensions system under independence

An independent Scotland with the same state pension policy as the rest of the UK may find it difficult to afford pensions, a think tank has claimed.

The Pensions Policy Institute (PPI) said a future Scottish government would need to raise tax, cut spending or accept higher debt.

Scots ministers said social protection was more affordable in Scotland.

Shadow pensions minister Gregg McClymont said the UK made them affordable north of the border.

The think tank report came ahead of the 18 September independence referendum.

In a paper submitted to the Scottish Parliament's finance committee, the PPI said, despite lower life expectancy levels overall for Scotland, the population was ageing more quickly than the rest of the UK.

The UK state pension is paid to men from 65 and women from 61, but the age is to increase to 67 for all by 2028.

The Scottish government has said the basic state pension would continue to be paid "on time and in full" under independence and that, from 2016, new pensioners would be given £160 a week.

Ministers also said an expert commission set up in the first year of independence would consider the appropriate level of the country's state pension age.

The PPI said of the Scottish government's proposals: "The overall impact of the Scottish government policy proposals on annual pensioner benefit expenditure would be to further increase expenditure per working age individual in Scotland.

line break
Background and analysis
line break

"After allowing for expected changes in earnings, and focusing on the difference between Scotland under the Scottish government proposals and the UK as a whole, the difference peaks at £330 per individual of working age in 2032, where Scotland would still have a lower state pension age than the rest of the UK - £180 of this is due to the policy changes, with the remainder due to underlying demographic differences."

The PPI added: "Although the proposals put forward by the Scottish government would increase expenditure on pensioner benefits, if implemented, they could also lead to higher state pension incomes for pensioners in Scotland compared to the rest of the UK, depending on the final level of the single-tier pension on introduction in 2016 and the rate at which it is increased."

Ms Sturgeon said her government had set out plans for "an affordable, fair and efficient pensions system" in an independent Scotland.

She added: "The fact is that social protection spending, which includes pensions and welfare, is more affordable in Scotland than in the rest of the UK - and has been so for the last five years.

"We already know that we need to grow our working age population and that is exactly why we have set out the benefits to our economy of improving productivity, increasing employment and securing population growth, which can deliver an additional £5bn a year by the end of a 15 year period.

"The challenge of supporting an ageing population comes regardless of the outcome of the referendum - but it is only independence that gives us tools to tackle it."

Mr McClymont, speaking on behalf of the Better Together campaign for the Union, said: "Pooling and sharing our resources across the whole of the UK means pensions are more affordable in Scotland.

"Experts have made clear that if we walk away from the UK we would need tax rises or spending cuts to pay for pensions in Scotland.

"We don't need to take that risk. If we say 'no thanks' to leaving the UK, we can have the best of both worlds - a strong Scottish Parliament, with more powers for Scotland guaranteed; and the protection for our pensions that comes from being part of the larger UK."

More on This Story

More Scotland politics stories

RSS

Scotland Live

  1.  
    08:57: Excitement builds in Edinburgh Edinburgh Evening News

    tweets: Good Morning Edinburgh! Big day today. The Commonwealth Games are back in the Capital today as Diving comes to the Commie pool. Excited?

     
  2.  
    Morning Call 08:46: Louise White Presenter, Morning Call

    This morning, we're talking about driverless cars and para sport.

    With the government announcing that driverless cars could be on the roads as early as January 2015, I'm asking whether you'd welcome them on your street.

    Also, with will Scotland's success in para sports at Glasgow 2014 help change attitudes towards disability?

    Lines are open now - call 0500 92 95 00, text 80295 or email us at morningcallscotland@bbc.co.uk.

    You can listen live by clicking on the link at the top of this page.

     
  3.  
    08:34: "Off day" for Bolt?

    He may be the most popular athlete in the world, but Usain Bolt has risked the wrath of Glaswegians by calling the Commonwealth Games "a bit s***".

    Usain Bolt poses with children at Glasgow 2014

    Speaking to The Times newspaper, Bolt, who is set to run for Jamaica in the 4 x 100m relay at Hampden on Friday and Saturday, said "the Olympics were better".

    A spokesman for the Commonwealth Games Federation dismissed Bolt's comments and described Glasgow 2014 as "fantastic". He added that the athletics superstar must be "having an off day".

     
  4.  
    08:30: Listen live
    Gary Robertson

    Click on the link at the top of page to listen to Gary Robertson and Hayley Millar on Good Morning Scotland.

     
  5.  
    08:08: Record breaking

    Glasgow 2014 is Scotland's most successful ever Games following Tuesday's men's team gymnastics silver.

    Scotland's Jen McIntosh

    Swimmer Daniel Wallace added to that tally when he won silver in the men's 200m individual medley after arriving at the pool wearing a kilt.

    Shooter Jen McIntosh, pictured above, also won silver in the 50m rifle 3 positions - becoming the first Scottish woman to win five Commonwealth medals in the process.

    And a bronze at the end of the day for hammer thrower Mark Dry at Hampden Park took the host nation's medal tally to 37.

     
  6.  
    08:02: Bigger and better Marianne Taylor BBC Scotland news

    If you click on the Scotland Live link on the BBC News Scotland homepage, you'll notice that we've moved to a new and improved format.

    The main change is that the page is bigger, brighter and more lively and we'll be able to bring you more high quality pictures and video.

    If you click on the Key Video tab, you'll find video highlights of Team Scotland's successes in swimming, shooting and gymnastics, and footage of Princes William and Harry meeting Usain Bolt.

    We hope you like it - let us know what you think using Twitter #ScotlandLive or by email.

     
  7.  
    07:35: Games travel BBC Scotland Travel Latest

    There's lots going on at the SECC precinct today, so Exhibition Centre station will be particularly busy.

    If you're going to the athletics at Hampden, don't forget to leave plenty of time for your journey - Mount Florida station is likely to be exceptionally busy. Shuttle buses are running from the city centre.

    On the roads, the Clyde Expressway eastbound is restricted near Finnieston Street, so only use it for essential journeys and expect delays if you do.

    In Edinburgh, diving gets under way at the Royal Commonwealth Pool this morning, with restrictions in place around Holyroodpark Road and Dalkeith Road.

     
  8.  
    07:27: Good Morning Scotland BBC Radio Scotland

    Hayley Miller and Gary Robertson are live on BBC Radio Scotland with all the latest national and international news and analysis, including a preview of the day's sporting action at Glasgow 2014.

    Listen online here.

     
  9.  
    07:15: Today's weather BBC Scotland Weather Latest

    It's a cloudy start for many of us with some outbreaks of rain across parts of the west from Argyll stretching across to Dundee and north of the Great Glen.

    The showers will become less frequent and more scattered during the morning and it will continue to brighten up as we go into the afternoon. It'll be mainly dry with some brightness in the east for much of the day, with more sunshine coming through for the afternoon.

    It'll be a noticeably breezy day with a fresh westerly - strong along the north coast and up through the Northern Isles. Winds ease as we go through the afternoon, with temperatures holding up at 20C to 21C at best, most likely through Inverness and down the east coast from Aberdeen, down through Dundee and Edinburgh.

    Closer to 18C in and around the Glasgow area, 17C for the Western Isles and a cooler and fresher 15C up through the Northern Isles.

     
  10.  
    06:55: Welcome Marianne Taylor BBC Scotland news

    Good morning and welcome to BBC Scotland Live, your minute-by-minute guide to all the action and atmosphere at day seven of Glasgow 2014.

    We will, of course, also bring you all the latest news, sport, weather and travel from across the country.

    Let us know what you think and send us your pics. You can tweet us using #ScotlandLive, email us here or text using 80295.

     

Features

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.