Scottish independence: Parties demand 'Yes' cost release

Alex Salmond Alex Salmond has attacked the UK government's estimate of the set-up costs of an independent state

Scotland's main opposition parties have jointly called on First Minister Alex Salmond to publish the cost of setting up an independent Scottish state.

They said voters needed the figure to make an informed choice, ahead of the 18 September independence referendum.

A spokesman for the first minister said much of the infrastructure for an independent Scotland "already exists".

And he said the letter was an attempt to divert attention from "misleading" UK government figures on the issue.

A letter to Mr Salmond, signed by Johann Lamont, Ruth Davidson and Willie Rennie - the respective Labour, Conservative and Liberal Democrat leaders - claimed it was now known that Finance Secretary John Swinney agreed in 2012 to produce a report on the issue.

It added that, last week, a spokesman for the first minister said the figure had not been calculated and that no such estimate would be given.

"It is simply unthinkable that a government would pursue such a radical and irreversible policy such as independence without first undertaking any modelling work or providing any estimates for the cost of that change," stated the letter from the three politicians.

"There are now little more than 100 days until the people of Scotland go to the polls. We now urge you to publish this important information without further delay.

"Without it, voters will not be in position to make an informed choice when they go to the polls in September."

letter Opposition leaders set out their demands in a joint letter to the first minister

Mr Salmond previously rubbished UK Treasury analysis putting the start-up cost at £1.5bn - a figure the Treasury said could be twice as much, if based on a different study by Prof Patrick Dunleavy, of the London School of Economics.

Prof Dunleavy later accused UK ministers of a "ludicrous" use of his research, prompting Mr Salmond to say the case for the figure had been "destroyed".

The academic later estimated the Scottish cost could be between £150m and £200m - a suggestion the first minister said was reasonable.

A spokesman for the first minister said of the opposition letter: "This is a blatant attempt to divert attention from the fact the UK Treasury were last week caught red handed trying to cook the books on an independent Scotland's finances - that was a deeply dishonest attempt to mislead people, for which they should now apologise and withdraw their bogus figures.

"The question the Westminster parties now need to answer is how much they plan to slash Scotland's budget by in the event of a 'No vote' - what are their secret plans to cut Scotland's cash and will they be straight with the people of Scotland before the referendum?"

The spokesman added: "Much of the infrastructure for an independent Scotland already exists, and we already pay our fair share of running costs for all services.

"We are also entitled to a fair share of all UK assets."

More on This Story

More Scotland politics stories


Scotland Live

    Pool Party 08:08:

    It was Scotland's pool party, but where was the poster boy? BBC Sport's Aimee Lewis reflects on Scotland's success in the pool and the disappointments for Michael Jamieson.

    Michael J
    07:50: Via Twitter Huw Williams BBC Scotland reporter

    tweets: Crew of the Lerwick registered Swan taking part in @Flotilla2014 and live on @BBCRadioScot Out of Doors.

    Commonwealth flotilla crew

    Listen live to Radio Scotland.

    Last night at the Games 07:33:

    It was another great night in the pool for Scotland last night as Daniel Wallace won gold in the 400m Individual Medley.

    Daniel Wallace

    Meanwhile, Neil Fachie and Craig Maclean won Scotland's first Commonwealth Games cycling gold with victory in the Para-cycling 1000m tandem time trial for blind and visually impaired athletes.

    However, it was disappointment again for Michael Jamieson after he finished fifth in the 100m breaststroke semi-final meaning he will miss the final.

    Sir Jackie's car up for sale 07:13:

    Racing legend Sir Jackie Stewart's first ever race car is set to go under the hammer.

    The 1960 Marcos GT Xylon is being offered for sale this weekend by Silverstone Auctions.

    Sir Jackie Stewart's car

    Only nine Xylons were built by Marcos, which was founded in 1959 by racer Jem Marsh and engineer Frank Costin.

    The auction estimate is between £35,000 and £50,000.

    Commonwealth flotilla 07:07:

    The largest flotilla ever seen on the River Clyde will sail from Greenock to Glasgow later as part of the city's Commonwealth Games celebrations.

    Commonwealth flotilla

    About 250 boats are due to leave from Greenock at 10:00 and arrive at Pacific Quay, home of BBC Scotland, at 13:00.

    Small ships, leisure yachts and clipper and working boats will be taking part.

    Good morning 06:58: Graham Fraser BBC Scotland

    Good morning and welcome to BBC Scotland Live. We'll be here until 23:00 bringing you all the latest news, sport, weather and travel from across the country, including all the action and atmosphere from the Glasgow 2014 Commonwealth Games.

    Keep in touch and send us your comments and pics via Twitter using #ScotlandLive, by email or by text on 80295.



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.