Scottish independence: Pensions and the referendum debate

Elderly person How an independent Scotland would fund pensions for an ageing population has come into sharp focus during the referendum debate

How to fund an increasingly ageing population is a 21st Century problem that weighs heavily on the minds of governments across the world.

And it certainly matters in Scotland - the issue of pensions has consistently registered as one of the key issues in the independence debate.

A recent BBC poll found that pensions came second in a list of the 10 things that mattered most to voters - only the economy was deemed more important.

The Think Tank Reform Scotland raised the issue again in a report criticising Westminster for failing to make clear how "uncertain, unfunded and unsustainable" the current system is.

The Scottish government has said pensions would be "fully protected" in an independent Scotland, but bodies including the Institute of Chartered Accountants of Scotland (ICAS) and the National Association of Pension Funds (NAPF) have warned that more clarity is needed.

Here, we look at some of the key points in the pensions debate.

The current set-up
Pension tag Under UK government plans, the pension age will be raised to 66 by 2020, then to 67 between 2026 and 2028

At the moment, state pensions are managed by the UK government, which pays £110.15 a week for a single person and £176.15 a week for a couple. The pension age is currently 65 for men, while women are in the process of being raised to that entitlement age.

Once that equalisation process finishes in 2018, the pension age will be swiftly raised to 66 over the next two years, rising yet again to 67 between 2026 and 2028.

In his autumn statement, Chancellor George Osborne announced the pension age would go up to 68 sometime in the mid-2030s, about 10 years earlier than originally planned.

Currently, some public sector pension schemes (such as those on offer to nurses, teachers, police, civil servants and members of the armed forces) are administered by the UK government, while others are managed by the Scottish government.

A recent study of Scotland's demography by the University of Ottawa suggested the number of working age people in Scotland will grow at a slower rate than in the rest of the UK, partly due to lower rates of immigration.

Researchers said this will put an extra burden of taxation on workers, amounting to about 1.4% of national income by 2035.

However, the authors also pointed out that this burden is a smaller factor than the overall pressures from demographic change affecting the whole of the UK and other countries.

Pensions post 'Yes'
Pounds The Scottish government proposes setting up a new pensions regulator in an independent Scotland

The Scottish government has laid out its plans for the state pension in the event of a "Yes" vote in its White Paper for Independence and a separate pensions analysis paper.

It proposes a new single tier state pension, to be paid at a similar rate to the UK pension, that would be protected by the "triple lock" - whichever is higher from earnings growth, inflation or 2.5%.

The paper also says all rights and entitlements to public service pensions will continue to be protected after independence, and that there would be no difference to individual contribution rates.

According to research by the National Institute of Economic and Social research, an independent Scotland could delay the rise in the state pension age by 12 years, as Scots, on average, have a lower life expectancy than other parts of the UK.

That mortality gap is closing, however. It is projected to remain for those currently aged between 30 and 60, but life expectancy is expected to be closer to UK levels for those in Scotland now under 30.

And such a delay could cost the Scottish government about £750m a year, according to the institute.

Meanwhile, a new Scottish Pensions Regulator would support a pan-UK approach to the regulation of private pensions, according to the Scottish government, while its preference would be to maintain the current UK-wide Pension Protection Fund, though there would be an option to establish a Scottish version of the fund.

What the campaigns say
People in Buchanan St, Glasgow Life expectancy in Scotland is expected to rise in the coming years, while the number of working age people will grow at a slower rate than in the rest of the UK

Finance Secretary John Swinney has said pensions would be more affordable in an independent Scotland and would "continue to be paid in full, and on time, as now", while the pro-independence Yes Scotland campaign criticised successive Westminster governments for mismanaging pensions.

Nicola Sturgeon, in her introduction to the Scottish government's pensions paper, said independence offers "a genuine opportunity to deliver an affordable, fair and efficient pensions system".

However, former Labour Prime Minister Gordon Brown said a "Yes" vote would put pensions at risk and cost more, adding that people in Scotland currently get a higher contribution to their pension pot than people elsewhere in the UK.

Speaking on behalf of the pro-Union Better Together campaign, Labour's pension spokesman Greg McClymont said the UK systems worked well through the pooling of resources and the spreading of risk.

What the industry bodies say
Pensioners at the seaside Pensions body the NAPF has called on both the Scottish and Westminster governments to clarify their plans for pensions if Scotland becomes independent

Earlier this month, accountancy body ICAS published a report on pensions, which highlighted uncertainty over whether an independent Scotland or the rest of the UK would pay some state entitlements.

The report said there was no clear plan on how pensions would be managed if Scotland votes "Yes", and claimed employers with under-funded cross-border schemes could be faced with "substantial" costs or even closure due to EU rules.

In November, the NAPF called on both the Scottish and Westminster governments to clarify their plans for pensions if Scotland becomes independent.

In a report called Scottish independence: the implications for pensions, the association concluded that independence would have "substantial implications" for pensions and questioned how the proposed regulatory scheme would work.

More on This Story

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More Scotland politics stories


Scotland Live

    Collins Plots Progress 13:33:

    Celtic assistant manager John Collins is relishing the chance to help the club book their place in the Champions League.

    The Scottish champions are in Iceland ahead of tomorrow night's second round first leg qualifier against KR Reykjavik.

    Celtic assistant boss John Collins

    "Of course it's going to be a test. But it's a test we're looking forward to and this is where we want to be," said Collins.

    "We want to be on the big stage and we know we've got to take care of this team tomorrow night. It won't be easy, it never is at the start of the season.

    "We've got to look forward to it, it's a good challenge."

    Reporting Scotland 13:24:

    Watch BBC Reporting Scotland live online at 13:30 for a round-up of the day's headlines.

    He Did Relay Well 13:11:

    Ally tweets: "My son Liam @NakedNelis, so proud of him @batonrelay2014"

    Liam with Queen's Baton
    Child-like Enthusiasm 13:00:

    Eilidh Child will be carrying the hopes of a nation when she takes to the Glasgow 2014 track and is relishing the prospect of glory on home soil.

    Eilidh Child

    The 27-year-old from Perth recorded a season's best for the 400m hurdles at Hampden's Diamond League meeting.

    And Child is aiming to go one better than the Commonwealth Games silver medal she won in Delhi four years ago.

    "I want to go there and run to form and for my fastest race of the year to be at Hampden," she told BBC Scotland.

    Weather Update 12:52: Judith Ralston BBC Weather presenter

    A mainly dry start to the afternoon, however, a band of rain will continue to move into western Scotland and spread across the country fragmenting as it does. Best of any sunshine across Caithness and the Northern Isles. Southerly winds will strengthen for many for a time this afternoon. Feeling humid with highs of 19 or 20C.

    Glasgow 2014 12:40:

    Tickets are still available for some of the most sought after events at the Commonwealth Games, with just over a week until the opening ceremony.

    On the Glasgow 2014 ticketing website customers can still buy seats at a number of medal sessions, including the men's and women's 100m finals.

    Commonwealth Games site

    There is "high availability" for the 5,000m final, in which Mo Farah is due to compete.

    Organisers said the unsold seats were a small part of the overall capacity.

    Auld Enemy Clash - Your Views 12:20:

    Debbie McKeown tweets: "Think Scotland could do it, England team not great at the moment."

    Auld Enemy Clash - Your Views 12:10:

    EFM tweets: "Can Scotland not get to play a better team than England? We're really scraping the bottom of the barrel! #yes"

    Never Miss A Beat 12:00: John Beattie BBC Scotland

    The John Beattie Show is getting under way on BBC Radio Scotland.

    John Beattie

    Today John is trying to uncover the secret to Germany's World Cup-winning efficiency. Listen live here.

    Murder bid 11:38:

    Police are treating an attack on a 85-year-old woman in Edinburgh as attempted murder.

    Police generic

    They say the 85-year-old was stabbed, and possibly sexually assaulted, in her home in the Morningside area on Friday.

    A man police want to trace is described as aged 18 to 30, of average build, with short dark hair.

    Afjordable investment 11:30:

    Oil services firm Wood Group's strengthened its operation in Norway with the acquisition of Agility Projects.

    It's paying just under £96m for the engineering, procurement and construction management firm based in Sandefjord, which employs 650 people.

    German Efficiency 11:27: John Beattie BBC Scotland

    "I am wondering this morning what makes Germany so successful..."

    Baton Crowds Wowed 11:21: Keir Murray BBC Sport Scotland

    "Great scenes at Ravenscraig Stadium as the Queen's Baton comes to Greenock ahead of the Commonwealth Games."

    Crowds at Ravenscraig Stadium for the Queen's Baton Relay

    England Expects 11:19:

    Scotland manager Gordon Strachan is relishing the prospect of locking horns with England at Celtic Park on 18 November.

    The friendly, four days after the Euro 2016 qualifier against the Republic of Ireland at the same venue, offers the chance to avenge the 3-2 defeat at Wembley in August 2013.

    "Like our supporters, I was really heartened by the performance against England at Wembley and believe we had a great opportunity to record a win we could all have talked about for years," said Strachan.

    Kenny Miller scoring for Scotland in the 3-2 defeat by England at Wembley in 2013

    "Now, we have that chance again and I am sure the players and the fans will be even more determined to take it.

    "The atmosphere at Wembley was incredible and I am sure with Celtic Park filled with Scotland supporters, it is a game the whole country will look forward to."

    Celtic's Euro Hopes 11:11:

    With attention returning to club football following Germany's World Cup victory, Celtic are plotting European progress under new manager Ronnie Deila.

    Deila takes his troops to Iceland on Tuesday to face KR Reykjavik in the first leg of their Champions League second round qualifier.

    Celtic manager Ronny Deila

    "It's important we score a goal in Iceland - as many as possible," the Norwegian told the club's website.

    "We want to push the tempo as it will develop players and get good results."

    The first leg will be broadcast live on BBC One Scotland, kick off is at 20:00 with coverage on Radio Scotland 810MW and online.

    Referendum Plea 10:50:

    Important questions on Scotland's future remain unanswered ahead of the independence referendum, according to the Law Society of Scotland.

    The professional body for solicitors urged pro-independence campaigners to provide more information on the economy, currency and EU membership.

    Ronnie Anderson from Edinburgh waves a Saltire flag beside the "18 September 2014" sign outside the Scottish Parliament

    And it pressed the main pro-UK parties to spell out when more powers would be devolved to Scotland.

    The Society said it had a "firmly non-partisan role in the debate".

    Auld Enemy Clash

    The Scottish FA have confirmed that Scotland will host England in Celtic Park on 18 November.

    Pundit Bows Out 10:37:

    Football pundit Alan Hansen is hanging up his microphone after 22 years. The Scot made his final appearance for the BBC on Sunday during the World Cup final in Rio.

    Hansen was famous for his rants at "diabolical" defending and will also be remembered for his "you can't win anything with kids" verdict on Manchestter United's young bucks in 1995.

    Alan Hansen

    "It was the line that made me," said Hansen. "I'd be at Euston station or Heathrow airport and they'd be shouting it at me. To this day, I stand by that line. How many times have you seen a manager pick experience over youth, it happens all the time."

    Who is your top/least favourite pundit in sport and why? Is there a common line they trot out that has you throwing a slipper at the TV or radio in frustration?

    Is there a commentator or pundit at the top of their game?

    Text 80295, email us or tweet using #ScotlandLive

    Women MPs - Your Views 10:24:

    Badgertwo: "No, we need effective ones, regardless of their race, creed, colour and gender! That is all!! #endpoliticalcorrectness"

    Sarah Winton: "We just need more MP's with some common sense!!"

    Mags: "As a woman I don't really care if we have an equal split of MPs or MSPs, I would just like to see the best we have. No matter what sex."

    Ali in Dundreich: "We should definitely have more women in Parliament but on merit and ability, not just to fill a quota."

    Listen to the final minutes of Morning Call here.

    BBC Scotland Live - Your Views 10:20: Thomas McGuigan BBC Sport

    What do you think of BBC Scotland Live? We'd like your feedback about this service.

    We've introduced the rolling minute-by-minute commentary to bring you the latest news, sport, travel and weather all in one place.

    Tell us what you think.

    Driving Ambition 10:18:

    Justin Rose tweets: "Morning!! What a great week at the #scottishopen #Aberdeen."

    The Full Monty 10:13:

    Colin Montgomerie is currently sporting a smile as wide as the River Clyde after winning the US Senior Open.

    Monty came from four shots behind overnight leader Gene Sauers to win a play-off at Oak Tree National in Oklahoma.

    Colin Montgomerie celebrates his play-off victory

    "You talk about the Ryder Cup and one-on-one - I'm usually quite good," said the 51-year-old Scot.

    "A play-off in a golf tournament is like a penalty shoot-out in the World Cup. You don't know what's going to happen.

    "I've lost in a play-off (1994) and been one shot behind a couple of times (1997 and 2006) and you have to wait to 50 to finally win one!"

    The Borderlands 10:04:

    Westminster's Scottish Affairs Committee's launched a consultation on what it calls "the Borderlands of Scotland".

    Border sign

    It's the area covered by Dumfries and Galloway and Scottish Borders Councils.

    The committee says the region's been consistently overlooked and inadequately served by successive governments.

    Weather Update 09:58: Judith Ralston BBC Weather presenter

    "Rain will edge in to the west coast and spread eastwards. The Northern Isles will be dry with sunny spells over Shetland. Rain will bring a humid feel to the day with temperatures of 18 to 20C..."

    Cliff rescue 09:56:

    A walker's been rescued after falling from a cliff-top coastal walk at Thurso.

    Thurso lifeboat

    The alarm was raised early this morning that a person had fallen from the Victoria Walk on to rocks below.

    Thurso lifeboat was launched from Scrabster Harbour and used a small craft to get three volunteers to the shoreline.

    The walker is being treated in hospital.

    Assisted Dying - Your Views 09:52:

    Morning Call has been asking for your views on this issue...

    K in Islay: "We would not let an animal suffer the way we let humans suffer."

    Marjory in Edinburgh: "I am listening to your caller, Alan. What a powerful message."

    Big Boab from Linwood: "How many times have you heard at funerals people saying it was a blessing they finally passed away? Is it maybe selfishness of relatives rather than the patient keeping them alive."

    You can listen to the programme here.

    Things Looking Rosy 09:41:

    Following his win at Royal Aberdeen, Justin Rose will aim to add The Open title to his Scottish Open success.

    "Rose's odds on adding a second major to the US Open he won last year when he lines up at Royal Liverpool next week are shortening all the time," writes BBC Scotland's Tom English.

    Justin Rose

    "This year's Open venue at Hoylake is, he says, a course without tricks.

    "It's a straightforward track and he feels all the better about facing it after what he has done at Royal Aberdeen."

    Read the rest of Tom's column here.

    Cummings and goings? 09:30:

    Celtic have joined a long list of clubs keen on taking Ghana winger Christian Atsu on loan from Chelsea, according to the Daily Mail.

    In-demand Hibs striker Jason Cummings is not letting interest from Swansea upset his preparations for the new season, say a number of papers this morning.

    Hibs striker Jason Cummings

    And Rangers striker Nicky Clark aims to split up the potential attacking partnership of Kenny Miller and Kris Boyd who have returned to Ibrox this summer.

    Read the rest of our gossip column here.

    Queen's Baton Relay 09:20:

    It's Day 31 of the Queen's Baton Relay, yes indeed! Today, the relay is travelling through Invercylde, starting at Inverkip before spending time in Greenock and Kilmacolm before finishing the day in Greenock once more.

    If you're going out to watch the relay today, here is rough guide to where and when you can see the baton:

    Weather graphic
    • 10:10 Greenock
    • 11:45 Quarrier's Village
    • 12:20 Kilmacolm
    • 14:00 Port Glasgow
    • 15:10 Greenock

    You can follow live coverage of the baton on our BBC live service here.

    Up for debate 09:15:

    Audience members are being sought for a BBC Radio Scotland independence referendum debate in Inverurie.

    The event's being held on the evening of Wednesday 20 August, and offers the chance to question some of the region's leading figures.

    Anyone interested can contact

    Blooming great 09:10:

    Justin Rose woke up this morning as the Scottish Open golf champion after a flawless final round at Royal Aberdeen.

    Justin Rose

    Rose was winning his second consecutive tournament - and will now hope to emulate last year's winner, Phil Mickelson, by going on to win The Open this week.

    Englishman Rose's bogey-free six under closing round saw him beat Sweden's Kristoffer Broberg by two shots.

    Scotland's Marc Warren was third, with compatriot Stephen Gallacher tied for fourth.

    Morning Call with Cathy McDonald 09:05:

    This morning we're asking if you've changed your views on assisted dying, and if so, what has influenced your decision? And would more women in parliament improve democracy and make for a fairer society? The lines are open now, 0500 92 95 00 or text 80295.

    Listen to the programme here.

    Making headlines 09:03:

    Images of Germany's extra-time World Cup triumph over Argentina last night dominate the front pages of the Scottish newspapers.


    As for the lead stories, The Herald reports a catering expert has launched an attack on the quality of NHS Glasgow hospital food.

    The Scotsman says a poll has shown that support for independence would increase in the run-up to the referendum if Scots feared the UK would exit the EU.

    The Times says lawyers have demanded answers from First Minister Alex Salmond about an independent Scotland's currency, tax system and EU membership.

    The Daily Record says a Scots dad has told how a ticket tout scandal robbed him and his young son of their World Cup final dream.

    Read our full round-up here.

    Latest headlines
    09:00: Thomas McGuigan BBC Sport

    Good morning and welcome to BBC Scotland Live, your minute-by-minute update of the all the day's news, sport, weather and travel.

    Get in touch using #ScotlandLive, by email, or via text on 80295.



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.