Scottish independence: 'Yes' vote means leaving pound, says Osborne

 

Chancellor George Osborne said the pound was not an asset to be divided up, during a speech in Edinburgh

UK Chancellor George Osborne has said a vote for Scottish independence would mean walking away from the pound.

His statement came after the senior civil servant at the Treasury, Sir Nicholas Macpherson, said currency unions were "fraught with difficulty".

Mr Osborne was backed by Labour and the Liberal Democrats.

Scottish First Minister Alex Salmond said the Westminster parties were trying to "bully" voters ahead of the 18 September independence referendum.

The Scottish government has argued that keeping the pound and the services of the Bank of England as part of a currency union under independence made sense for both Scotland and the rest of the UK.

But Mr Osborne said there was "no legal reason" why the rest of the UK would want to share sterling with an independent Scotland.

Start Quote

What's really striking is the publication of the normally private advice of the top Treasury mandarin Sir Nicholas Macpherson”

End Quote

The chancellor, Labour shadow chancellor Ed Balls and Lib Dem Chief Secretary to the Treasury Danny Alexander said they could not recommend such a plan.

Speaking in Edinburgh, Mr Osborne said: "The pound isn't an asset to be divided up between two countries after a break-up like a CD collection.

The instinct of the Scottish National Party may well be to dismiss the head of the Treasury's unambiguous advice to the Chancellor that he should not enter into currency union with an independent Scotland as the public-school and Oxford establishment closing ranks to save the union.

But the letter from Sir Nick Macpherson (Eton and Balliol) to George Osborne (St Paul's and Magdalen) is a significant constitutional event.

It is unusual for the permanent secretary to the Treasury to write a public letter on any issue at all, let alone one as momentous as whether institutional arrangements should be put in place so that an autonomous Scotland could have an influence on monetary and financial-regulation policy while continuing to use the pound.

The relevant issue for Mr Salmond is only to a limited extent whether Macpherson and the Treasury are right or wrong that monetary union with an autonomous Scotland would be contrary to the interests of a still-united England, Wales and Northern Ireland.

"If Scotland walks away from the UK, it walks away from the UK pound."

He went on: "There's no legal reason why the rest of the UK would need to share its currency with Scotland.

"So when the Nationalists say the pound is as much ours as the rest of the UK's, are they really saying that an independent Scotland could insist that taxpayers in a nation it had just voted to leave had to continue to back the currency of this new, foreign country?"

Mr Osborne added: "The UK is growing faster than any other advanced economy in Europe, and within the Union, Scotland is growing faster than the rest."

"Nothing could be more damaging to economic security here in Scotland than dividing our United Kingdom."

The chancellor's speech came as he published the Treasury's latest currency analysis paper, which said:

  • The UK's successful union with its shared monetary policy and risk would be lost in an independent Scotland.
  • Countries with more direct control over monetary policy can better cope with severe economic problems.
  • An independent Scotland would be more exposed to risks from the "volatile" energy and finance industries.
  • The eurozone crisis had shown that agreed fiscal rules are not enough to ensure a stable currency union.
  • There is no rule or principle in international law requiring the continuing UK to formally share its currency with an independent Scotland.

And in a highly unusual move, the chancellor also published civil service advice from Sir Nicholas, the Treasury's permanent secretary, who stated:

  • "Currency unions between sovereign states are fraught with difficulty. They require extraordinary commitment, and a genuine desire to see closer union between the peoples involved."
  • "What worries me about the Scottish government's putative currency union is that it would take place against the background of a weakening union between the two countries, running counter to the direction of travel in the eurozone."
  • "The Scottish Government is still leaving the option open of moving to a different currency option in the longer term. Successful currency unions are based on the near universal belief that they are irreversible. Imagine what would have happened to Greece two years ago if they had said they were contemplating reverting to the Drachma."
  • "Scotland's banking sector is far too big in relation to its national income, which means that there is a very real risk that the continuing UK would end up bearing most of the liquidity and solvency risk which it creates."
  • "If you follow Treasury advice and this week rule out a currency union in the event of Scottish independence, you can expect the Scottish Government to threaten not to take on its share of the United Kingdom's debt. I do not believe this is a credible threat."
George Osborne George Osborne's speech came as he published the latest Treasury analysis on the nature of a currency union in an independent Scotland

Mr Salmond responded: "This is a concerted bid by a Tory-led Westminster establishment to bully and intimidate - but their efforts to claim ownership of sterling will backfire spectacularly in terms of reaction from the people of Scotland, who know that the pound is as much theirs as it is George Osborne's.

Analysis

This feels like a defining moment in the independence referendum campaign.

There will be others but this is arguably the most important so far with the possible exception of the publication of the Scottish government's White Paper.

It set out the case for Scotland to keep using the pound Sterling in a formal currency union with the rest of the UK in the event of independence.

Scottish First Minister, Alex Salmond has repeatedly said this would be in the economic interests of both countries.

Today, his pro-union opponents in all three major UK parties are effectively saying that it would not be and that they will not let it happen.

They hope to seriously undermine the credibility of the nationalists' promise of currency continuity.

The Scottish government hopes referendum voters will see it as an attempt to bluff and bully and that it will backfire.

They are determined not to abandon their preferred currency option for an alternative - using the pound anyway, creating a new Scottish currency or applying to join the Euro - that may seem much riskier.

They have also said that if the rest of the UK is not prepared to share the currency that an independent Scotland would not be obliged to take a share of UK debts.

The stakes in this campaign just got a lot higher.

"Mr Osborne's claims are based on a caricature of a currency union rather than the reality, and his claims, for example on the size of Scotland's banking sector, do not reflect that reality."

The Scottish first minister added: "The reality is that a formal currency union with a shared sterling area is overwhelmingly in the rest of the UK's economic interests following a 'Yes' vote, and the stance of any UK government will be very different the day after a 'Yes' vote to the campaign rhetoric we are hearing now.

"To do otherwise would involve a prospective Westminster chancellor of any party standing on a platform which was not only vastly at odds with majority public opinion across Scotland and the rest of the UK but would seriously damage the economy of the rest of the UK as it would cost their own businesses hundreds of millions of pounds a year, blow a massive hole in their balance of payments and it would leave them having to pick up the entirety of UK debt."

But Mr Alexander said the Treasury had provided "crystal clear" analysis that a currency union would create unacceptable risks both for Scotland and the rest of the United Kingdom.

He also called on the Scottish government to set out an alternative currency proposal.

Mr Alexander added: "As a Scot and as Liberal Democrat Chief Secretary to the UK Treasury, on the basis of this analysis, I couldn't recommend a currency union to the people of Scotland and my party couldn't agree to such a proposition for the rest of the UK.

"The SNP continue to pretend that an independent Scotland could continue to share the pound. It couldn't, without agreement."

The Scottish Lib Dem MP said: "This isn't bluff, or bullying, it's a statement of fact."

Start Quote

The dominant parties at Westminster sought to avoid any pre-negotiation - but now they've broken their own rule. We now have one, very important piece of pre-negotiation, by declaring no negotiation at all.”

End Quote

Mr Balls, added: "Alex Salmond is saying to people that you can have independence and keep the pound and the Bank of England - that is not going to happen.

"It would be bad for Scotland, it would place an unacceptable burden on the UK taxpayer, it would repeat the mistakes of the euro area, in fact, worse.

"It won't happen, I wouldn't recommend it. Scotland will not keep the pound if Scotland chooses independence."

It is understood former Chancellor Alistair Darling, who is leading the Better Together campaign to keep the Union, was instrumental in getting the three Westminster parties to agree a joint currency position.

The referendum will see Scots asked the Yes/No question: "Should Scotland be an independent country?"

 

More on This Story

Comments

This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
 
  • rate this
    0

    Comment number 5151.

    At last! In the past few years of the independence debate we have had no answers to our questions no straight talking from politicians. We now know one think about this referendum and that is we will not have the pound in a currency union. I live near the border, will I have to change my money every time I want to go to Carlisle for a meal or a drink?

  • rate this
    0

    Comment number 5150.

    5140. Dont believe the Hype

    True but the real news here is that so do SNP politicians. They're still politicians and by definition they are liars and cheats as well. Just like all politicians, you'll believe whatever you want to believe.

  • rate this
    +1

    Comment number 5149.

    Cant help thinking this is a bit like a 16 year old announcing to their parents that they want to leave home and move into a flat without any real idea of how they will pay their way in the world. Then asking the parent to act as guarantor for the rent and bills.

  • rate this
    -2

    Comment number 5148.

    Given that Scotland has contributed more in REAL terms than it has received in recent times AND that it growing faster than the rest of the UK (stated above) surely getting out now is the perfect time?
    For those who say Scotland COULD not use the GBP then I give you this. How can so many countries use USD without formal currency unions with US?
    Scotland could use it's own pound if it has to.

  • rate this
    0

    Comment number 5147.

    Arguing now about a minor matter like currency is a distraction. The key issue is independence to manage affairs as Scots see fit.
    If Scotland votes for independence, then the relationship with the pound will alter, but that is to be negotiated after the event. Lots of smaller countries manage independent and shared currencies OK. Independence is much bigger than currency.

 

Comments 5 of 5151

 

More Scotland politics stories

RSS

Scotland Live

  1.  
    Surveillance law concern 12:57:

    The Scottish government has expressed concern that it was not sufficiently consulted by its UK counterpart prior to today's announcement on surveillance powers.

    Computer keyboard

    An emergency law is to be introduced at Westminster next week to ensure that police and security services can continue to access people's phone and internet records.

    In a statement released this lunchtime, the Justice Secretary, Kenny MacAskill said: "We are disappointed at the lack of prior consultation and discussion from UK Government on today's announcement given how much this legislation potentially impinges on areas of Scots law that are clearly devolved and under the jurisdiction of the Scottish Government or our law enforcement agencies, including the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service."

     
  2.  
    No inquiry commitment 12:46:

    Transport Minister Stephen Hammond has refused to commit to a full public inquiry into offshore helicopter safety.

    The call was made during transport questions in the Commons following the publication of the Commons Transport Select Committee's report into the issue this week.

    The question came from Aberdeen North Labour MP Frank Doran.

     
  3.  
    Wizzing to Poland 12:41:

    Two new Polish destinations from Glasgow Airport have been announced.

    Wizz jet

    Wizz Air, the Hungary-based low-cost airline, will offer flights to Katowice and Poznan from October.

    It already operates flights to Gdansk and Warsaw.

     
  4.  
    Your photos 12:21:

    Reader Alan Tough sent us this stunning image of noctilucent clouds from the Covesea Lighthouse near Lossiemouth in Moray.

    Alan Tough

    You can send us your pictures via email or twitter using and we'll feature the best online.

     
  5.  
    Community cash 12:02:

    Communities in Glasgow and southern Scotland have landed more than £1m each from the Big Lottery Fund for "much-needed" facilities in their areas.

    Johnstonebridge

    A village "hub" will be built next to the primary school at Johnstonebridge in Dumfries and Galloway.

    And a new community centre is to be constructed at Cadder in Glasgow.

     
  6.  
    Edinburgh-Abu Dhabi flights 12:00:

    Etihad Airways has announced that it is to launch its first service from Scotland next year.

    The national airline of the United Arab Emirates will start a direct daily flight from Edinburgh to its home base of Abu Dhabi from June.

    Etihad link

    Edinburgh is Etihad's first Scottish destination - and its third departure point from the UK.

    Scotland's Transport Minister, Keith Brown, said: "This new route between Edinburgh and Abu Dhabi is fantastic news for Scotland, building on our already strong links with the United Arab Emirates and providing a major boost to our international connectivity."

     
  7.  
    Traffic Update

    Traffic Scotland tweets: Inverness: #A82 @ Tomnahurich Bridge - RE-OPENED after earlier abnormal load.

     
  8.  
    Golf latest 11:49: Tom English BBC Scotland

    tweets: Four birdies in a row for Rory McIlroy. 5-under. Outrageously good golf in very testing conditions

     
  9.  
    Sweet for Swede 11:45:

    Sweden's Kristoffer Broberg has set a new course record at Royal Aberdeen to take an early lead in the first round at the Scottish Open.

    Kristoffer Broberg

    However, despite his bogey-free 65, he finds himself only one stroke ahead of rampant Rory McIlroy, the Irishman lying one stroke behind after 11 holes of his round following four birdies in a row.

    Russell Knox and fellow Scotsman Marc Warren lie in a large grouping, which also includes defending champion Phil Mickelson, three strokes off the lead as they near the ends of their rounds.

     
  10.  
    On the picket beat 11:33: John Beattie BBC Scotland

    After spending time this morning chatting to workers picketing for a better pay deal, I want to hear your views on whether you support the thousands of public sector workers who are on strike across the country.

    We also discuss whether your tattoos should affect your work prospects after the news that a woman lost her job when her body art was deemed unacceptable by her employers.

    You can get in touch via email, Twitter and texting on 80295.

     
  11.  
    11:14:
  12.  
    Slow progress 11:07:

    A public body set up more than a decade ago to improve local services has only made "significant progress" in the last year, a spending watchdog says.

    Moray Community Planning Partnership is said to have failed to show leadership and make big decisions following its 2001 launch.

    The body brings together organisations such as the council, health board, police, fire services and voluntary sector.

    It was criticised by the Accounts Commission and Auditor General for "many years of being ineffective".

     
  13.  
    Bag warning 10:57:

    Many of us will have seen horrific photographs via the internet of animals around the world killed as a result of human waste products and RSPB Scotland has issued a warning to people to take care when discarding unwanted plastic bags.

    It comes after a rare bird was photographed with one caught in its beak.

    Red-throated diver with plastic bag

    The red-throated diver was pictured by a visitor to a lochan in a remote part of North Uist.

    The birds are on the RSPB's amber list - its second most critical group in terms of conservation priority - after a recent decline in numbers.

    Jamie Boyle, site manager of the RSPB's Uist reserves, said plastic bags can kill birds if they eat, or become entangled, in one.

     
  14.  
    Your views - Compassion for the homeless 10:46:

    The news that a barrier had been used to deter rough sleepers from a street in Glasgow's city centre - before it was removed by a member of the public - has provoked a strong reaction from our readers.

    Isabel from Renfrew texts: We really have to do something as a society to help people who find themselves in a homeless situation. Not only a place to live but help to integrate themselves into society again. Lottery money should be sought to help their situation.

    Chris texts: Most of us are just a couple of month of rent money away from homelessness.

    Tom in Clarkson texts: With regard to the matter of spikes in shop doorways, I would like the good people of Glasgow to quite simply boycott these businesses and show them for what they are - uncaring, heartless individuals.

     
  15.  
    Public sector strikes 10:30:

    Thousands of public sector workers are picketing across the country in a 24-hour strike over pay.

    Members of the Public and Commercial Services Union say they want the Scottish government to continue to move away from UK chancellor George Osborne's austerity policies. Picket lines have been set up across a number of government buildings, including the Northgate passport office in Glasgow.

    Northgate picket line

    More than a million public sector workers across Britain are expected to walk out as part of a dispute with the UK government about pay, pensions and spending cuts.

     
  16.  
    Scotland's back pages 10:23:

    With the Rangers tax case dominating the front pages and Argentina's World Cup semi-final win over the Netherlands splashed on the back, there are slim pickings as far as other major sports stories in the morning newspapers.

    Celtic and England goalkeeper Fraser Forster

    However, the Daily Record is suggesting that Southampton will battle it out with Benfica for the signature £8m-rated Celtic goalkeeper Fraser Forster.

    Meanwhile, The Sun is reporting that relegated Hibernian have rejected two offers from English Premier League outfit Swansea City for young striker Jason Cummings.

    West Brom midfielder James Morrison is quoted in several papers insisting that Scotland do not fear their Euro 2016 meeting with Germany in September - despite Joachim Low's side trouncing hosts Brazil 7-1 in the first World Cup semi-final on Tuesday,

    How do you think Scotland will fare against the German machine - and can Argentina stop them lifting the World Cup? Give us your thoughts at #ScotlandLive, by email at newsonlinescotland@bbc.co.uk or via text on 80295.

    Keep up to date with the newspaper sports gossip here.

     
  17.  
    Birdie fest 10:13:

    Russell Knox is the best-placed Scots golfer so far during the first round at the Scottish Open in Aberdeen.

    Russell Knox

    The 29-year-old, who was born in Inverness and is now based in the United States, said before the event he was relishing the Royal Aberdeen challenge.

    At two under par, he's four off the current lead.

     
  18.  
    Fewer turbines 10:12:

    Scaled-down plans have been lodged for a wind farm development in the Scottish Borders.

    Welsh-based West Coast Energy Ltd initially wanted to construct 11 turbines at Hag Law near Romanno Bridge in Peeblesshire.

    Wind farm

    However, an application submitted to Scottish Borders Council now contains plans to erect eight turbines reaching up to 100m tall.

    The company predicts Hag Law will produce clean electricity for 10,000 homes.

     
  19.  
    Pensioner accused 09:56:

    An 81-year-old woman has appeared in court accused of causing death by dangerous driving following a crash in November.

    Police accident

    Former showjumper Jacqueline Low-Mitchell is alleged to have caused the death of Adam Maxwell in Fife.

    The crash happened on the A916 near Craigrothie, south of Cupar, at about 11:45 on 13 November.

     
  20.  
    Murder charge 09:51:

    A man has appeared in court charged with the murder of a former boxer on Monday.

    Police cordoned off streets around the scene in Stenhousemuir after the discovery of the victim, Andrew Main, 57.

    His son, Derek Main, 35, appeared at Falkirk Sheriff Court on Wednesday, charged with murder.

    He made neither plea nor declaration at a brief hearing.

     
  21.  
    Morning Call 09:42: Louise White Presenter, Morning Call

    According to a report on attitudes towards faith and belief in Scotland, the majority of the people surveyed said they believed that prayer could change the world, that there is life after death and that not everything can be explained by science. On BBC Radio Scotland now, Louise White is asking: "Do you believe in the power of prayer?"

    Elsewhere, a row has erupted over what's thought to be the first case in Scotland of a barrier being erected to deter rough sleepers from a street in Glasgow's city centre. They were taken down by members of the public the next morning. Louise wants to know: "Have we lost our compassion for the homeless?"

    And there's more! A US pilot ordered pizzas for a plane full of passengers as they were stuck on the tarmac for two hours. We'd like to hear your random acts of kindness?

    The lines are open now: 0500 92 95 00, or text 80295.

    You can listen live here.

     
  22.  
    No bully 09:40:

    The current chief executive of the Scotch Whisky Association (SWA) has said no-one has attempted to bully him during the referendum campaign.

    David Frost

    David Frost, who took up his role in January, said he had been involved in "vigorous discussions" with both sides in the debate.

    But he said these had always been conducted in a "reasonable manner".

    His predecessor, Gavin Hewitt, has accused the SNP of attempting to "neuter" business opinion.

     
  23.  
    What the papers say 09:36:

    Most of the Scottish papers lead with HMRC losing its appeal against Rangers, with the tax authority losing its £50m court battle with former Rangers owner Sir David Murray.

    The Daily Record says David Murray blames the taxman for Rangers' liquidation, with The Herald saying angry fans of the Glasgow club are preparing a legal claim over damage caused to the club after the taxman's so-called Big Tax Case was dismissed.

    papers composite

    The Daily Mail reports that the number of Scots taking anti-cholesterol drugs is set to hit a million for the first time.

    The Press and Journal highlights a Highland woman who has reached the grand old age of 100 - 99 of them living in the same farm house.

    The Courier reports that complaints about anti-social behaviour are on the rise in Stirling and Falkirk.

    The Daily Telegraph has one of Europe's major banks saying savers could pull their money out of Scotland within hours if the country votes for independence.

    Read our review of the papers here.

     
  24.  
    Queen's Baton Relay 09:28:

    The baton relay continues its journey through Scotland ahead of the start of the Commonwealth Games. Today, it travels through the Orkney Islands before it begins to head back down towards Glasgow.

    BBC

    If you want to go out and cheer the baton bearers today, you can catch them at the following times.

    10.35 Stromness 13.50 Skara Brae 14.30 Dounby 15.50 Finstown 17.35 Kirkwall

    Don't forget you can watch live footage and text commentary of the baton's relay on the BBC Queen's Baton Relay page.

     
  25.  
    Headlines
  26.  
    Drive time 09:06:

    The Scottish Open golf championship in Aberdeen is in full swing this morning.

    Phil Mickelson

    Defending champion Phil Mickelson, Rory McIlroy and local favourites Paul Lawrie and Richie Ramsay are in the field.

    The leaderboard can be followed on the European Tour external website.

    The early leader is Sweden's Kristoffer Broberg, who is an impressive five under par through 11 holes.

     
  27.  
    Today's weather 09:02: Judith Ralston BBC Weather presenter

    The recent good weather continues, with a fine day to come.

    Early morning will see a few patches of mist and fog, especially in the Highlands, where it could be quite chilly to start. This will soon burn off leaving long spells of sunshine for much of Scotland.

    The exception will be the coastal parts of the North East and across the Northern Isles, where it will be cloudier. Here, some light rain will edge in this afternoon, mainly over Shetland.

    Temperatures will be warm for many, reaching a high of 22C or 23C. It will be a cooler 16C for coastal parts of Grampian and the Northern Isles due to a brisk northerly breeze.

    You can watch a full weather forecast here.

     
  28.  
    Good morning 09:00: Bryan Quinn BBC Scotland News

    Good morning and welcome to today's BBC Scotland Live, your minute-by-minute update of the all the day's news, sport, weather and travel.

    You can get in touch via email, Twitter using #scotlandlive, or text to 80295.

     

Features

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.