Scottish independence: Energy market claims analysed

lightbulb The future of the energy market has become a key debate in the referendum campaign

The question of whether energy bills would rise in the event of Scottish independence has come into sharp focus.

Shadow Energy Secretary Caroline Flint has insisted householders would pay more post-yes, but the Scottish government's Energy Minister Fergus Ewing hit back saying her claim was about "making political threats".

Both politicians spoke to BBC Radio Scotland's Good Morning Scotland programme.

Here, Euan Phimister, professor of economics at Aberdeen University with expertise in energy markets, looks at their claims and counter claims.

line break
Gas ring

Caroline Flint (pro-Union): Energy bills would go up in an independent Scotland because bill payers in the rest of the UK (rUK) would not want to continue subsidising the Scottish renewable sector. A third of the UK's renewable subsidy currently goes to Scotland, while Scots pay only one tenth of the cost.

Fergus Ewing (pro-independence): This is not the full picture. Even bigger subsidies go to nuclear power in England, which Scottish bill payers are contributing to.

Euan Phimister (expert): "Bills are going to rise in all cases due to increased subsidy to renewables and nuclear (in the UK case), replacement of infrastructure and of power plants which are coming offline due to environmental regulations.

"How much they will rise is ultimately uncertain. It is true that if an independent Scotland chose to support renewables at the current level and no subsidy was coming from the rUK, this would represent a burden either for Scottish bill payers or for Scottish taxpayers. However, an independent Scotland would have choices, for example cutting some subsidies which could alleviate this."

line break
Energy bill

Fergus Ewing (pro-independence): A UK-wide energy market would serve an independent Scotland and the rUK best. Scotland and the rUK would continue to work together in the best interests of all.

Caroline Flint (pro-Union): The market would be hugely changed by independence and would move to a purely commercial relationship, leading to energy bills going up in Scotland.

Euan Phimister (expert): "Independence would clearly change the relationship and there could be no guarantee that electricity produced in Scotland would definitely be bought by consumers in rUK. However, Fergus Ewing's point about OFGEM predictions about the low margins of capacity over demand over the next few years are correct and it likely that rUK electricity demand for Scottish electricity overall would remain significant.

"This is also where it is I think important to distinguish between existing capacity and new capacity. Existing capacity across the UK already supplies the electricity market on a 'commercial basis 'and that would remain the case, even if the subsidy was cut because all the capital costs have already been made. However, for investment to be made in new renewable capacity (or nuclear) by commercial companies, then they do still need the promise of subsidy. So the threat after independence is possibly more to the future development of renewables rather than paying for existing installed capacity."

line break
Coloured bulbs in a row

Caroline Flint (pro-Union): England helps keep the lights on in Scotland by providing energy from nuclear power when the wind isn't blowing in Scotland. Scotland would continue to need this capacity in the future.

Fergus Ewing (pro-independence): Scotland is keeping the lights on for the rUK at the moment. The rUK's capacity over its demand is very precarious, more so than in Scotland. Scotland currently exports 26% of its energy to England and Wales - an increase of 45% since 2010. - the rest of the UK needs Scotland's surplus energy now, and would continue to need it if Scotland became independent.

Bullet points on the referendum

Euan Phimister (expert): "Both are right but also somewhat miss the point about markets. The whole point of a market for energy is that it is balanced across the system at any point in time, so there will always be parts of the system which are in deficit or surplus. Markets work better when they are integrated, which explains why at European level (EU plus Norway) they are attempting to construct a market to allow a wider system to balance.

"Patterns of trade can change over time and it is quite possible in the longer term that in a pan-European market, Scotland's production of electricity would be less important for the rUK, but the argument also holds the other way too, i.e. the rUK market would be less important for Scotland's exports."

line break
Wind farm

Caroline Flint (pro-Union): The rest of the UK could meet its renewables targets without Scotland's help.

Fergus Ewing (pro-independence): Scotland is key to helping the rest of the UK meets its renewables targets, and would be just as important after independence.

Euan Phimister (expert): "The latest figures from DECC show the UK produced 4.1% of all UK energy consumption against the 2020 target of 15%. This is slightly above the predicted level for this stage but attaining the 2020 target is still very challenging.

"Renewable electricity production is a key part of attaining this target, so while it may be possible for the rUK, without the output from Scotland it would be much more difficult to achieve. Also, implementation of the current Electricity Market Reforms (EMR) plus the proposed cap on wholesale market prices if Labour wins the next election, have increased uncertainty and arguably negatively affected the investment plans of the energy firms. If so, this will have made the targets even more difficult to meet."

line break
Electricity pylon

Caroline Flint (pro-Union): The rest of the UK doesn't need energy from Scotland all the time. Post-independence it could choose to import from the likes of France, the Netherlands and Norway.

Fergus Ewing (pro-independence): Import capacity from mainland Europe is limited, so the UK government can't assume the capacity would be there. The EU market couldn't deliver same day energy to the UK.

Euan Phimister (expert): "The rUK doesn't decide who it imports from, the consumers do and they would want to have electricity at the lowest price. So supply would sometimes be from France, the Netherlands, Norway or Scotland, depending on relative prices across the various markets.

"Fergus Ewing's answers assume that nothing changes i.e. no investments occur to alleviate capacity constraints. In fact, although National Grid is investing in new capacity, there are current constraints across the Scottish-rUK border which limit Scottish exports.

"The wider is point is that the attempt to construct a European-wide market (including Norway) is to make it easier to balance the system at any point in time. This will increasingly be a problem - and already is in Germany - when there is significant amounts of electricity coming from wind and solar power. This is also why a capacity market is being introduced within the UK system. This is where new generating plants, which can react quickly when demand is very high, will be paid for simply by being available, i.e. when they are not producing."

More on This Story

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More Scotland politics stories


Scotland Live

    RBS claims 08:54:

    Royal Bank of Scotland has warned Scottish independence could have a "material adverse effect" on its business.

    The Edinburgh-based bank, 80% owned by the taxpayer, said a "Yes" vote in the 18 September referendum could cause uncertainty and hit credit ratings.

    More medal hopes... 08:47:

    After the heroics of Eilidh Child, Alex Gladkov, Daniel Keatings and Daniel Purvis yesterday, Scotland have medal hopes in today's athletics, gymnastics and lawn bowls at the Glasgow 2014 Commonwealth Games.

    Bowler Darren Burnett contests the gold medal match in the men's singles against Canada's Ryan Bester and Scotland's fours team will also be competing for gold medal when they take on England.

    Adam Cox, Frank Baines, Keatings and Purvis are in gymnastics action and Lynsey Sharp goes in the final of the 800m at Hampden this evening.

    Read our day nine preview.

    Travel news 08:43:

    @BBCTravelScot tweets: Police dealing with RTC on the A92 Ladybank. Road in Fife..there's a closure in place at the Northerly junction to Ladybank from A92

    Euro woes 08:36:

    Last night was a disappointing one for Scotland's Europa League representatives in the third qualifying round first leg.

    Aberdeen defender Shay Logan and St Johnstone defender Frazer Wright

    Aberdeen went down 2-0 against Real Sociedad in Spain while St Johnstone were 2-1 losers at home to Spartak Trnava. Both Scottish Premiership sides face an uphill task to reach the play-off round.

    Morning call 08:33:

    Cathy MacDonald (on today's Morning Call) asks: Do we really need alcohol on holiday flights, or does it mark the start of our bad reputation abroad?

    Also on the programme: Whose responsibility is it to look after you in your later years?

    Call 0500 92 95 00; text 80295; or email

    Listen on Radio Scotland from 08:50.

    Clyde cone 08:07:

    Glasgow 2014 mascot Clyde has been paying tribute to the city's most famous statue.


    Michael Jackson-Matthews took this picture outside the Glasgow Victoria Infirmary.

    We'd love you to email us any images you have taken in and around the Games.

    Games heroes 07:54:

    Missed any of the action from Day Eight at Glasgow 2014? We have a video catch-up of all the best bits.

    Eilidh Child
    On the Fringe 07:44:

    "There's a six-and-a-half-foot drag queen in the ladies' bathroom. In leopard skin dress and towering platforms, he apologises but he's onstage any minute and the ladies is much closer than the gents."

    Drag queen

    Our arts correspondent Pauline McLean is looking ahead to the Edinburgh Fringe.

    Avoid or be patient

    @trafficscotland tweets: Hotspot Map for August 1st - @GamesTravel2014 Day 9 Commonwealth Games - check busy areas here :)

    Glasgow map

    There's more detail in the Traffic Scotland website.

    Ebola test negative 07:34:

    An athlete has been tested for Ebola and cleared at the Commonwealth Games in Glasgow, organisers have confirmed.

    Coloured transmission electron micro graph of a single Ebola virus, the cause of Ebola fever

    A spokesman for Glasgow 2014 said the competitor was given tests for a number of conditions after he fell ill last week and was admitted to hospital.

    Sierra Leone road cyclist Moses Sesay, 32, competed in his event, the men's individual time trial, on Thursday.

    Sunshine and showers 07:33:

    @BBCScotWeather tweets: Rain moving into south this morning, clearing northwards. Then a day of sunshine & heavy showers. N Isles dry til eve. Highs of 16 to 19C.JR

    School closures 07:27:

    New rules on school closures have come into force across Scotland.


    Learning minister Alasdair Allan said they would provide "important safeguards" for rural communities.

    Local authorities will be required to carry out more rigorous consultation, especially before shutting rural schools

    Good morning Sandy Murray BBC Scotland news

    Welcome to BBC Scotland's live coverage of news, sport, travel and weather on 1 August.

    I know, August already.

    We'll have reports from across the country, including all the best action from Glasgow 2014.



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.