Scottish independence: Politicians row over energy market post-yes

Electricity pylon and wind turbines A row has broken out over the future of energy in the event of independence

A row over the future of the UK energy market has erupted between politicians on the two sides of the Scottish independence debate.

Shadow Energy Secretary Caroline Flint believed consumers would face higher energy bills post-independence.

However, Scotland's Energy Minister Fergus Ewing said the Labour MP's intervention was about political point scoring.

Voters in Scotland will decide on their country's future in September.

They will be asked the straight "yes/no" question: "Should Scotland be an independent country?"

Claims analysed

  • If you want to make sense of what Shadow Energy Secretary Caroline Flint and Scotland's Energy Minister Fergus Ewing are saying, read an expert view from energy specialist Euan Phimister.

Ms Flint questioned why English and Welsh households would want to continue "subsidising" renewable energy investment north of the border.

She claimed that Scottish consumers contributed less than a tenth of the cost of supporting clean energy and they benefited from the UK's ability to spread costs.

But the Scottish government's White Paper on independence said current levels of subsidy from across the UK should be maintained, with the retention of a single Great Britain-wide energy market keeping prices stable and energy supplies secure.

Ms Flint told BBC Radio's Good Morning Scotland programme: "Around a third of the investment in renewables goes to Scotland, but Scottish bill payers contribute less than one tenth of the cost to the overall pot.

"So, because of our union, because of our partnership there is a sharing of both the risks and the rewards when it comes to energy. But if Scotland decides to exit the UK that changes the relationship."

She said if independence were to happen the relationship between Scotland and the rest of the UK would become a commercial one in terms of energy.

Ms Flint believed there would be an opportunity to look elsewhere for energy markets, including France, the Netherlands and Ireland.

She added that in England and Wales there were renewable and nuclear options, but if Scotland "were to have less windy days then it would look to the rest of the UK to keep the lights on".

But Scotland's Energy Minister Fergus Ewing said Ms Flint's intervention appeared to be political point scoring.

On the issue of energy availability, the SNP MSP told Good Morning Scotland: "The regulator Ofgem has issued a series of warnings to the UK government that the capacity margin over peak demand and available generation supply has dwindled to an alarming 2% with a real risk of brownouts and blackouts south of the border. In Scotland the margin is much more comfortable.

"For the foreseeable future - and this is accepted in industry and generation circles - there is a real risk of when we turn the switches on, the lights south of the border will not come on because there will not be electricity there."

He added: "The reality is the market in the UK relies, and will continue to rely, on the importation from Scotland of substantial quantities of our electricity.

"It is a shame that Caroline Flint is more concerned about making political threats than addressing the reality of the electricity market in the UK."

More on This Story

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More Scotland politics stories


Scotland Live

    High Note 09:13:

    Revellers are flocking to T in the Park for the festival's last year at Balado.

    T in The Park

    Scotland's biggest music festival gets fully under way later, with 85,000 fans expected to attend and thousands already setting up camp.

    The event is set to move across Perthshire to Strathallan Castle from next year, after health and safety concerns were raised about an oil pipeline at Balado airfield.

    Biffy Clyro, Arctic Monkeys and Calvin Harris are the headliners at this year's event...

    Queen's Baton Relay 09:09:

    Day 28 of the Queen's Baton Relay sees the baton travel from the Orkney Islands down to the Highlands.

    It was an early start for today's runners, with the relay beginning in St Mary's at 06.20 BST.

    Day 28

    If you're planning to head out and cheer the baton bearers you can watch them at the following times:

    • 09.55 Wick
    • 13.15 Brora
    • 14.35 Golspie
    • 15.35 Tain
    • 17.05 Alness
    • 18.20 Dingwall

    You can watch live footage and text commentary of the baton's journey on the BBC Queen's Baton Relay page.

    What the papers say 09:06:

    The Rangers tax case latest makes the front page of both The Herald and the Daily Record today.

    papers composite

    While the Scottish Sun leads on drugs issues in Glasgow ahead of the Commonwealth Games.

    You can see more of the day's front pages here.

    Tyre blaze 09:02:

    Firefighters are continuing to battle a large blaze which broke out at an industrial site west of Glasgow.

    It broke out at 22:00 BST on Thursday near Meadowside Street on the banks of the River Clyde at Renfrew.

    Glasgow fire

    It is thought to have started in a scrapyard near a bus depot.

    Extra fire crews were drafted in overnight to help control the blaze with 55 firefighters still at the scene.

    Do you have pictures or video from the fire? You can send them to us via email or twitter using #scotlandlive.

    Today's weather 09:01: Gillian Smart BBC Scotland Weather Presenter

    Early mist and fog will clear to leave another fine, sunny day across most of the country with plenty of warm sunshine.

    There will be a damp, murky start over the Northern Isles, with low cloud affecting the East Coast in places too, but the rain will clear and the cloud will thin and break through the morning. Shetland will be the exception, holding on to patchy mist and low cloud throughout the day.

    It'll become warm inland, with temperatures widely reaching up to 24C. Onshore breezes will keep coastal areas a shade cooler.

    Latest Headlines
    09:00: Thomas McGuigan BBC Sport

    Good morning and welcome to today's BBC Scotland Live, your minute-by-minute update of the all the day's news, sport, weather and travel.

    You can get in touch via email, twitter using #scotlandlive or text to 80295.



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.