Scottish independence: Salmond outlines broadcast vision

tv studio Alex Salmond argued that broadcasting legislation has not kept up with changes in the industry

An independent Scotland should have its own public service broadcaster based on the existing staff and assets of BBC Scotland, the first minister has said.

Alex Salmond told the Edinburgh International Television Festival the strategy should be "utterly clear and utterly unsurprising".

He said Scottish viewers were being failed by "out-dated" broadcasting policy, reserved to Westminster.

The Scottish government is planning an independence referendum in autumn 2014.

Opposition parties said the first minister's plan to "break up the BBC" was lacking in evidence and detail.

Meanwhile, across the capital, former Labour prime minister Gordon Brown also raised the issue of independence during a speech.

At the politics festival at Holyrood he said it would threaten UK-wide protections, such as unemployment benefit.

In a speech at the television festival, Mr Salmond argued the independence of broadcasters in an independent Scotland would be guaranteed and their impartiality required.

He also argued a separate Scottish broadcaster, added to fiscal incentives, would mean more programme-making, while the needs of local communities would also be met.

The first minister said: "Scotland's contribution to broadcasting is unparalleled. Television was invented by John Logie Baird and the very concept of public service broadcasting was shaped by Lord Reith.

"But Scottish viewers and TV production talent are today being short-changed."

'Wider vision'

Mr Salmond argued broadcasting legislation remained "substantially unaltered" since it was put in place more than 50 years ago," adding: "In an age of digital revolution, broadcasting policy has not even adapted to devolution."

Start Quote

This is another nonsensical outburst about how everything will be better in a separate Scotland”

End Quote Jackson Carlaw Deputy Scottish Conservative leader

He said: "Television forms part of our wider vision for an independent Scotland to be a fairer and more prosperous nation.

"A stronger broadcasting sector provides major economic benefits - in 2009, Ireland was home to more than double the value of independent TV production than Scotland.

"Only then will broadcasting truly be Scotland's window on the world - bringing us the best of international content and allowing us to show the world what Scotland can create."

In 2008, a broadcasting commission set up by the Scottish government said up to £75m of public money should be spent on a new, high-quality Scottish TV channel.

The body was led by Blair Jenkins, a former BBC Scotland head of news, who is now running the official pro-independence campaign, ahead of the referendum.

Industry jobs

Shadow Scottish Secretary Margaret Curran said: "Alex Salmond told us that he's going to break up the BBC with no details about how he would do it or what it means for Scottish viewers or the people whose jobs rely on our TV industry.

"On Thursday night, millions of people tuned in to see the first episode of Waterloo Road, filmed in Greenock, broadcast across the UK.

Start Quote

There is an equal right also that if one part of the country has an economy that is failing the other part of the country has a duty to help”

End Quote Gordon Brown Former prime minister

"The question the first minister needs to answer isn't whether Eastenders will be available in an independent Scotland - it's whether programmes like this will be made in Scotland, bringing jobs and growth to our economy."

Jackson Carlaw, the deputy Scottish Conservative leader, added: "This is another nonsensical outburst about how everything will be better in a separate Scotland - the only things missing, as usual, are the evidence and the detail.

"It will take more than a handful of historic references to convince the people of Scotland of yet another spurious claim."

Delivering the inaugural Campbell Christie memorial lecture at Holyrood's Festival of Politics, Gordon Brown portrayed the union as an insurance policy that protected people in all parts of the UK.

He said: "There is equal right to unemployment benefit, there is an equal right to health insurance, there is an equal right to help when you're sick and disabled, there is an equal right also that if one part of the country has an economy that is failing the other part of the country has a duty to help."

Mr Brown also used his speech to urge one of Britain's most famous golf clubs to end the "injustice" of not allowing women to be members.

He criticised the "inequality" of the Royal and Ancient Golf Club in St Andrews following a decision by Augusta National Golf Club in the US to admit women members.

More on This Story

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More Scotland politics stories


Scotland Live

    Legacy? 09:49:

    Glasgow will benefit from the vast amount of money spent hosting the Commonwealth Games - according to Clyde Gateway Regeneration.

    Over £500m pound has been spent on hosting and an entire athlete's village built in the east end - which will be used as housing after the games.

    Especially if you live in Glasgow, how much do expect by way of lasting change?

    Contact us on or tweet using #ScotlandLive.

    Paper review 09:36:

    BBC Scotland has a guide to this morning's papers.

    Front pages 31 July

    As well as Glasgow 2014 (of course) there are reports on Nato and the Baltic states, and the challenge to the NHS in Scotland of treating an increasing number of older pensioners.

    Keep smiling 09:27:

    Debbie Paterson sent us this picture of Clydesiders at the hockey arena having fun with the local police.

    Clydesiders and police officers

    We'd love to see your images from Glasgow 2014. Send them to

    Medal haul 09:18:

    Scotland's Daniel Keatings took silver and Viorel Etko claimed bronze on day seven of Glasgow 2014.

    Medal table

    Keatings finished second in the men's all-around gymnastics final at the Hydro. Etko defeated Malta's Adam Vella to win the wrestling bronze medal in the 61kg.

    Team Scotland is currently in fourth place in the table, with a total of 39 medals. England are top with 105.

    Australian athlete held by police 09:10:

    An Australian weightlifter who won a bronze medal at the Commonwealth Games has been held by police following an assault on a Welsh athlete.

    Francois Etoundi, 29, is due to appear at Glasgow Sheriff court.

    The alleged assault on the unnamed athlete is said to have taken place at the athletes' village in Glasgow at about 06:00 on Wednesday.

    A Team Wales spokesman said: "We're aware of an incident that occurred involving a member of Team Wales."

    More rail disruption 08:59:

    Scotrail tweets: services between Glasgow Queen Street and Stirling may be cancelled, delayed or diverted via Cumbernauld at short notice

    Taking flight 08:57:

    An independent economic group has called for the future expansion of London airports to take Scotland and other parts of the UK into consideration.

    Busy airport

    The Scottish Council for Development and Industry has also lobbied for action to increase long-haul services from Scottish airports.

    Mapping the route 08:42:

    The cycling time trial is a gruelling course that takes in North Lanarkshire and parts of East Dunbartonshire before heading back to Glasgow.

    Time trial map

    Thousands are expected to line the route - don't forget to send us your pictures as the cylists whizz by. You can tweet them using #ScotlandLive or email them here.

    Today at the Games 08:29:

    Scottish athletes are in action in plethora of events today.

    Away from David Millar and Katie Archibald in this morning's time trial, individual apparatus finals in the gymnastics start at 15:00, with all-round silver medal winner Dan Keating holding Scottish hopes in the pommel-horse.

    In the athletics, Eilidh Child goes for gold in the 400m hurdles, while para athletes Meggan Dawson-Farrell and Samantha Kinghorn will compete in the T54 1500m.

    Eilidh Child

    Full coverage of every Games event is available on the BBC, across TV, radio and online.

    08:23: Contact us

    Much of the cycling time trial today can be watched free - if you can find a good vantage point.

    What has been your favourite free event of Glasgow 2014?

    And if you are at the cycling, send us your thoughts and your pictures.

    Text 80295, email or tweet using #ScotlandLive.

    08:15: Coming up Louise White Presenter, Morning Call

    Parcel delivery firms are to be given a "statement of principles" to try to improve things for people in "remote" parts of the UK. I'll be asking: When it comes to deliveries are you being punished by your postcode?

    And more than a dozen family pairings are competing in Glasgow 2014. Has sibling rivalry helped or hindered you in life?

    Morning Call on BBC Radio Scotland starts at 08:50. Phone me on 0500 92 95 00; Text 80295; email

    Listen live from 08:50.

    07:58: Train disruption

    @BBCTravelScot tweets: Disruption trains GW Queen St/ Edn Waverley,/GQS and Perth and GQS and Alloa All services through Croy being delayed or disrupted.

    07:55: Local hero

    Who to cheer on at the cycling time trial?

    David Millar

    A favourite with the crowds is likely to be defending Commonwealth Games champion David Millar.

    Also watch out for England's Alex Dowsett, who won silver at Delhi 2010.

    In the women's race, young Scottish talent Katie Archibald will get her chance to shine.

    07:40: Wild paths

    More than 120km of paths across Scotland's national parks are set to be renovated thanks to a £3m grant from the Heritage Lottery Fund.

    Highland glen

    Eroded pathways in the Cairngorms and Loch Lomond and the Trossachs are to be restored and upgraded as part of the People and the Mountains project.

    07:30: Cycling trials

    Major road closures are being made in and around Glasgow ahead of the cycling time trial.


    The 40km route - 30km for women - starts and ends at Glasgow Green.

    The single loop course takes in a huge swathe of countryside in North Lanarkshire and cuts across East Dunbartonshire before coming back to Glasgow via the city's east end.

    07:17: Kylie confirmed

    Kylie Minogue will perform alongside Lulu, Deacon Blue and Dougie MacLean at the closing ceremony of Glasgow 2014.


    (OK, it was confirmed yesterday, but who can resist another picture of Kylie?)

    07:11: Today's weather BBC Scotland Weather Latest

    It'll be cloudy, with rain through the Highlands and Islands drifting north and east.

    A wet start for the south west too, moving east to Lanarkshire but with bright spells later across Tayside, the central belt and Southern Uplands.

    However, expect some hefty showers after lunch with a risk of thunder. Less windy than of late with highs of 17C to 20C.

    07:01: Sandy Murray BBC Scotland news

    Welcome to BBC Scotland's live coverage of news, sport, weather and travel across the country on Thursday 31 July. It is day eight of the Glasgow 2014 Commonwealth Games and we'll be keeping you up to date on all the Team Scotland action. We're here until 23:00.



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.