Scottish government reintroduces alcohol pricing bill

 

Health Secretary Nicola Sturgeon said minimum pricing was not a magic bullet, but a part of the solution

Related Stories

Plans to reintroduce a minimum price for a unit of alcohol in Scotland have been announced.

Health Secretary Nicola Sturgeon said it was important that Scotland's "battle with alcohol misuse" was tackled.

Official figures have suggested Scots drink more than people in other parts of the UK.

A first attempt by the SNP to push through a similar price proposal failed during the last parliament.

MSPs rejected the idea before the May election, but after the SNP's majority win at that poll this fresh plan is set to become law before next summer.

At this stage, the Scottish government has not fixed a unit price.

During the first attempt to bring forward the legislation, the SNP minority government proposed setting the minimum price at 45p per unit.

That would have resulted in;

  • an own-brand bottle of vodka increasing in price from from £8.35 to £11.85
  • a two-litre bottle of cider going up from £1.20 to £3.75
  • and the cost of a bottle of wine moving from £3.75 to £4.20

A unit figure will be suggested in the new year after research by the University of Sheffield, which is re-running its minimum price modelling to produce the most up-to-date data.

Political analysis by James Cook Health analysis by Branwen Jeffreys

"Pioneering is by definition an uncertain business. So it is with minimum pricing for alcohol. As Scotland prepares to become the first country in Europe to introduce the policy, evidence of precisely what it will achieve is thin on the ground. This doubt is recognised by the Scottish government. Health Secretary Nicola Sturgeon told last month's SNP conference that "being first with a policy means that it comes with no absolute certainties"....."read more

"A minimum price for alcohol based on strength is a radical health policy which is likely to attract attention from around the world. Scotland is not the only country to have considered this step, but would be the first in the world to implement it in an area where alcohol is sold relatively freely. A minimum price per unit of alcohol has the largest affect on the cheapest and strongest drinks which is why it has attracted a wide range of support from health campaigners....."read more

Ms Sturgeon promised her party's annual conference on 21 October that a new minimum pricing on alcohol bill would be back before MSPs "within the month".

Following the introduction of the new bill at Holyrood, the health secretary said Scotland's unhealthy relationship with alcohol was one of the "most pressing public health challenges facing us as a nation".

Ms Sturgeon added: "We have introduced a ban on quantity discounts, and promotions in off-sales have been restricted, but already we have seen that without minimum pricing these attempts to take action on Scotland's alcohol problem are being undermined.

"By setting a minimum price for a unit of alcohol, we can raise the price of the cheap supermarket white ciders, lager and value spirits sought out by problem drinkers.

"I hope that this time around MSPs will do the right thing and back this policy that has the support of doctors, nurses, the police and growing numbers of the general population. I will not shirk from leading the way in addressing this challenge. It is time for Scotland to win its battle with the booze."

The Scottish government has estimated that the country's alcohol problems cost £3.56bn each year - or £900 for every adult.

'Probably illegal'

What is a unit of alcohol?

Scottish Labour's health spokesman Dr Richard Simpson said his party did not believe minimum unit pricing was the answer to tackling the country's drink problem.

He claimed the move would deliver a £140m annual windfall for big supermarkets "without providing a single extra penny for our NHS".

Dr Simpson added: "Scottish Labour has proposed a whole raft of measures that we believe will help tackle Scotland's relationship with alcohol, but the SNP's narrowly-defined bill - designed to shut down debate - means other proposals cannot even be considered.

"The SNP think minimum unit pricing is some sort of magical silver bullet, but unfortunately no one measure is going to tackle Scotland's relationship with alcohol.

"If the SNP government is serious about tackling alcohol abuse it should drop its dogmatic approach, broaden its bill so a range of other proposals can be included."

The Scottish Tories have also suggested that a blanket minimum pricing policy would not work.

Changing culture

The party's health spokesman Murdo Fraser said: "Evidence has shown that problem drinkers are those most resistant to moderate changes in pricing, meaning that this bill would end up penalising only responsible drinkers.

"This is in addition to the hugely questionable legality of the measure, which has already been labelled by the UK government as 'probably illegal', therefore potentially rendering the bill utterly meaningless."

However, the SNP move won support from the Liberal Democrats whose health spokeswoman Alison McInnes said it was "a positive and confident step towards changing the culture of excessive drinking in Scotland".

Drink The minimum unit price will be decided in the new year

She added: "Alcohol abuse has a devastating impact on the lives of individuals and families across Scotland.

"It is a blight on our society and that is why I wish to work constructively with Ministers to make forthcoming minimum pricing legislation the most effective it can be. We need to examine all possible action to change Scotland's relationship with alcohol."

The Scottish Green Party also backed the government's bill, as it had done when the first attempt at acohol pricing legislation came before Holyrood.

Patrick Harvie said: "The evidence presented on alcohol pricing last session was robust and convincing, and we're still convinced. A minimum price for alcohol will help tackle irresponsible drinking and deliver substantial health benefits.

He added: "SNP ministers could and should go further than the half measures they're proposing today. They have a strong democratic mandate but they also pledged to govern inclusively.

"It's not too late for ministers to allow new ideas into this bill, to focus the response on the harm caused by big business while protecting community pubs and small producers, the businesses which make their living from quality instead of volume sales."

 

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

Comments

This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
 
  • rate this
    +1

    Comment number 490.

    I think most people look at this the wrong way.
    The people with the drinking problem, won't think, oh it's to expensive at all.
    A drinker will do anything to drink, so instead of getting the drink legally, now it will be illegally or we lead to crime to enable them having money to have drink. In my opinion, this does not help at all.

  • rate this
    +12

    Comment number 388.

    Having seen my best friend die from alcohol related disease, I think a problem like this needs serious attention. Just increasing the price won't do it by itself, any more than increasing the price of tobacco would have by itself stopped me smoking. The glib comments on here about drinking as much as you want are from people who have no idea what alcohol abuse really does to you. It isn't pretty.

  • rate this
    +13

    Comment number 300.

    People who drink decent/reasonable wines and spirits will not be affected by this - only the cheap ciders, wines and lagers will go up.
    "They will make their own home brew" Yeah sure, brewing or distilling will be so easy to acomplish. "Carlisle will be used for "duty free" .
    How many bottles of cheap wine will compensate for the petrol used to get there and back ?

  • rate this
    +7

    Comment number 238.

    I see the "ivory tower" brigade are out in force with this topic, scoffing and mocking an attempt to redduce alcohol abuse, instead of applauding a government's efforts to solve the problem. I'll bet there are quite afew people residing on the streets of our major towns and cities who agree with what the government is doing.

  • rate this
    +2

    Comment number 225.

    A PR gimmick, unfortunately. As with cigarettes, economically speaking, and for those with alcohol problems who this is aimed at, alcohol is inelastic. The issue of alcohol misuse is a lot more fundamental than pricing, is cultural and requres efforts over generations to tackle. People who want/need alcohol will still buy somewhere.

 

Comments 5 of 19

 

More Scotland politics stories

RSS

Features

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.