Scottish election: Fears for Dunoon car ferry service

Dunoon ferry, picture courtesy of David Blackwood from Johnstone Dunoon has two ferries, but there are fears about future services

For some in the town of Dunoon in Argyll there is a sense of deja vu around the latest Holyrood election campaign.

When they went to the polls in 2007, the future of the town centre passenger car ferry service was at the forefront of many minds and, as I discovered, it remains a burning issue - with campaigners fearing the service could be in jeopardy.

What the ferry link provides to Dunoon on the Cowall penisula is seen by some as vital, as it takes more than two hours to drive from the town to the nearest city, Glasgow.

If you take one of the two car ferry services between Gourock and Dunoon, that road journey is reduced to as little as 40 minutes.

However, there are concerns Dunoon could be about to lose one of its services - with doubts hanging over the car ferry route from the town centre.

The route, currently operated by Caledonian MacBrayne, was put out to tender in 2009 following a European Commission investigation into public support for the service.

Tender documents issued to shortlisted companies in February this year stated the subsidy would only be for the "passenger element" of the service.

This has raised doubts about whether the successful bidder would offer a car ferry service and even if it wanted to, if this could be achieved by the deadline for the tendering process of 30 June this year.

Campaigners fear the end of the car ferry link from the town centre would affect local trade and hand a monopoly to Western Ferries, which operates a non-subsidised route almost two miles outside the town centre.

The Dunoon Observer's Aileen MacNicol said the ferry service had been an issue in the town for more than 30 years.

Start Quote

John Cameron Smith

I would say that public anger and frustration is intense”

End Quote John Cameron Smith

She explained: "Politicians of all colours have been accused of letting the community down, but most recently they feel that this particular administration has let them down.

"The tender was made at the end of 2009, promises were made that a vehicle service would be delivered and here we are with just a few short months before the new contract has to start and it looks like that might go passenger only, so this is sort of the realisation of everybody's fears."

In the summer of 2007 campaigners thought their calls for a new vehicle service from the town centre would be met.

During the Holyrood election campaign of that year the successful Argyll and Bute SNP candidate Jim Mather pledged to provide new boats. The boats would operate the then newly built linkspan, which was constructed under the Lib-Lab coalition government to replace the old Victorian pier.

But the linkspan is still not in use.

Dunoon ferry facts

  • Two car ferry services between Gourock and Dunoon
  • The CalMac route was put out to tender in 2009 after an EC probe into public support for ferry services in Scotland
  • Tender documents issued to shortlisted companies in February 2011
  • The deadline for the tendering process is 30 June 2011
  • Shortlisted firms for the tender are Caledonian MacBrayne, Western Ferries and Clyde Marine Services

John Cameron Smith, secretary of the Dunoon-Gourock Ferry Group, said: "The linkspan can be seen almost as an icon of government, and I'm not selecting any one party here because you had two governments over that period, but it could be described almost as an icon of government incompetence.

"It was provided, the boats weren't.

"I would say that public anger and frustration is intense and there is also a feeling, a very strong feeling, that we've been treacherously betrayed because we voted for a candidate on the basis of pledges to provide this service and that tipped the balance in the Scottish Parliament."

Some in the town are concerned about how the end of the car-ferry service would affect their business.

Phillip Norris, who runs a self-catering holiday service, said: "Yes we are worried. One inevitable consequence if we lost this car ferry service would be much queuing for the western ferry service. Queuing often puts off people.

"From memory, the value I think of day-trip tourism to Cowal is way over a £1m a year."

Car passengers speak about Dunoon ferry

Charles Black Snr, who runs a local bakery and transport company, said the ongoing row over subsidies for the route has already affected his trade.

He regularly used three different CalMac routes for business at a commercial rate. But when this was stopped he opted to go via road instead.

Mr Black said: "We now have to go by road. Everything has to go by road and this of course requires a journey of two and a quarter hours each way to Glasgow, a five-hour total, against 40 minutes from the other side of the water where we're able to cross.

"We lose five hours out of the day travelling to Glasgow as against 80 minutes."

Big issue

The shortlisted companies for the tender - Caledonian MacBrayne, Western Ferries and Clyde Marine Services - were unable to comment on the tendering process, saying it was at a commercially sensitive stage.

The Brian Souter-owned Highland& Universal Ltd withdrew its bid, citing the short timescale.

Transport Scotland said it would not be commenting further on the tender until the announcement of the preferred bidder later this year.

But it looks like the car-ferry link could be a big issue again in the constituency on 5 May.

Candidates on Dunoon ferry service

SNP - Mike Russell Labour - Mike Rice Tory - Jamie McGrigor Lib Dem - Alison Hay
  • "For the past 30 years, all parties when in government havefaced the twin challenges of EU regulation and vigorous competition.
  • "As MSP, Jim Mather delivered on his promise and has fought extremely hard for this service to continue.
  • "The SNP believe this service should continue and we are seeking to establish a strong ferry regulator to ensure a level playing field and better involvement of local communities in the tendering process."
  • "The SNP are going around saying no one has got this right for 30 years.
  • "We messed up as well, so did everyone else - but that's not good enough.
  • "The SNP has let us down. They said "no boats no votes" at the last election.
  • "If we get in, I'm not going to make any false promises, but I will campaign for prudential borrowing to build two new car-passenger boats."
  • "The SNP Scottish Government has clearly let the people of Dunoon down in a big way.
  • "I was in Queen's Hall before the last Scottish election when Jim Mather the SNP candidate clearly made promises for two new vehicle ferries for the CalMac route."
  • "They are now saying the EC is stopping them, but why have they procrastinated so long in putting the tender process forward?"
  • "People in the local community are extremely angry about the SNP's terrible handling of the Dunoon to Gourock ferry service.
  • "They have utterly failed the local community and people will remember this on the 5th May when they go to the polls."

Find out the full list of candidates for the Argyll and Bute Holyrood constituency

More on This Story

Scottish election

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More Scotland politics stories

RSS

Features

  • Lucy FranklinDouble trouble

    'Rising house prices left me high and dry - twice!'


  • NS Savannah, 1962Nuclear dream

    The ship that totally failed to change the world


  • Ed Miliband takes a selfie at a Cambridge hairdressersNo more photo ops?

    Why is Ed Miliband drawing attention to his public image?


  • Espresso cup7 days quiz

    Which city serves the strongest cup of coffee?


  • Glasgow 2014 quaichs and medalsQuaich guide

    What do the Scottish gifts given to Games medallists symbolise?


BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.