Lees of Scotland and Tunnock's win Snowball tax appeal

Snowballs packet HMRC had contended that snowballs were confectionery and not cakes

Two Lanarkshire-based confectionery firms are set to receive a windfall tax rebate after judges ruled Snowball snacks were technically cakes.

Lees of Scotland and Tunnock's faced a combined tax bill of £2.8m after HM Revenue and Customs insisted Snowballs did not enjoy the same exemption from VAT as tea cakes.

The firms refused to accept snowballs were "standard-rated confectionery".

Judges at the First-tier tax tribunal ruled in their favour on appeal.

Start Quote

A Snowball looks like a cake. It is not out of place on a plate full of cakes. A Snowball has the mouth feel of a cake”

End Quote Judge Anne Scott First-tier tax tribunal

They decided the issue after being presented with a plate of Jaffa Cakes, Bakewell tarts, tea cakes, Lees Snowballs, Waitrose meringues and mini jam snow cakes during the hearing.

Judge Anne Scott said: "We found that the plate looked like a plate of cakes. We were also left with samples of all of these, together with Tunnock's Snowballs.

"We tasted all of them, in moderation, either at the hearing or thereafter.

"A Snowball looks like a cake. It is not out of place on a plate full of cakes. A Snowball has the mouth feel of a cake", she added.

Lees and Tunnock's insisted their Snowballs should be VAT-free, in the same way as Jaffa Cakes.

However, HMRC was equally adamant that they were, in fact, confectionery.

Claims for a £2m VAT rebate by Coatbridge-based Lees of Scotland Ltd, and for £800,000 by Uddingston-based Thomas Tunnock Ltd, were rejected in 2012.

'Not a biscuit'

At the tribunal, Judge Scott said it was not disputed that Snowballs were a "sweetened prepared food which is normally eaten with the fingers" and that everyone "agreed that a Snowball is certainly not a biscuit".

Snowballs are described by Lees as "soft fluffy mallow with a chocolate coating and sprinkled with the finest flakes of coconut to create a delicious sweet treat".

They are believed to derive from a shaved ice New Orleans snack, first on offer before the 1940s.

The judge described Snowballs, which are boiled and not baked, as "very fragile", "very sweet" and observed that their mallow core was "similar" to that found in tea cakes.

She said Snowballs and tea cakes made by Lees - often manufactured for supermarket's own brands - were sometimes promoted together, appeared on the same shelf and were sold at similar prices.

Tunnock's, which only make their own brand Snowballs, produce a snack "much softer and more fragile than the tea cake". It is usually offered alongside its best-selling product, Caramel Wafers, in the biscuit aisle.

'Confection to be savoured'

Judge Scott said: "Most people would want to enjoy a beverage of some sort whilst consuming a Snowball.

"It would often be eaten in a similar way and on similar occasions to cakes - for example to celebrate a birthday in an office."

She said the tribunal was "wholly agreed" that a Snowball was a "confection to be savoured but not whilst walking around or, for example, in the street".

She added: "Most people would prefer to be sitting when eating a Snowball and possibly, or preferably... with a plate, a napkin or a piece of paper or even just a bare table so that the pieces of coconut which fly off do not create a great deal of mess.

"Although by no means everyone considers a Snowball to be a cake, we find that these facts, in particular, mean that a Snowball has sufficient characteristics to be characterized as a cake.

"For all these reasons the appeals succeed."

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More Scotland business stories

RSS

Scotland Live

  1.  
    Morning Call 08:34: BBC Radio Scotland

    It was a massive weekend for Glasgow with an estimated 700,000 visitors to the city for the Commonwealth Games. While this has seen a big boost for the hospitality sector, it hasn't all gone smoothly, with travel delays starting to bite.

    Presenter Cathy Macdonald asks: how are you coping with the Commonwealth Games?

    Also, with women's boxing taking its place at the Games for the first time, we'll be talking to Olympic champion Nicola Adams's mum. How would you feel if your daughter wanted to be a boxer?

    Call 0500 92 95 00, text 80295 or email morningcallscotland@bbc.co.uk.

     
  2.  
    08:20: Via Twitter BBC Scotland Travel Latest

    Games - heavy exit slip cos of the volume of Games traffic on M8 Westbound at J19 Anderston

     
  3.  
    Today at the Games 08:19:

    Scottish highlights today include two-time Paralympic silver medallist Libby Clegg racing in the T12 100m at the athletics in Hampden.

    Libby Clegg

    Elsewhere, Alex Marshall and Paul Foster could win gold for Scotland in the lawn bowls pairs. Their match against Malaysia will begin at 12:45.

    Wales will play Scotland's women in the hockey at 16:00, while Commonwealth champion swimmer Hannah Miley is in action again in the pool in the 800m freestyle alongside Camilla Hattersley.

    The men's 100m sprint qualifying continues at Hampden, with the likes of the Jamaicans Nickel Ashmeade, Jason Livermore and Kemar Bailey-Cole taking on English hopes Adam Gemili, Richard Kilty and Harry Aikines-Aryeetey.

    Meanwhile, Olympic champion Nicola Adams will begin her challenge in the boxing ring.

    Remember, you can keep across all the action on the BBC. Watch on TV from 09:00, online and listen on the radio.

     
  4.  
    Your first time? 08:11: Marianne Taylor BBC Scotland news

    I had an absolutely fantastic time at the team Badminton at the Emirates last night, where England beat India in an electrifying best of five matches across singles, doubles and mixed doubles.

    Badminton at the Emirates Arena

    I'd never seen live elite badminton before - it was fast, furious and hugely competitive. Which sports have you seen for the first time and what was the experience like?

    Tweet us your thoughts and pictures to #ScotlandLive, email them here or text us on 80295.

     
  5.  
    Eyes on the prize 08:00:

    Team Scotland remain just one gold away from their best-ever Commonwealth Games total and are edging closer to matching their overall best for all medals.

    After Sunday's successes, Scotland have 30 medals following four days of events.

    Scotland's judo team collected 14 medals in Glasgow

    Our best-ever total was 33 medals in Edinburgh, in 1986, a Games boycotted by many African, Caribbean and Asian nations.

     
  6.  
    Good Morning Scotland 07:54: BBC Radio Scotland

    Gary Robertson is live on air bringing you the latest national and international news and analysis.

    Listen live to Good Morning Scotland here.

     
  7.  
    Games travel 07:40: BBC Scotland Travel Latest

    The athletics started yesterday at Hampden, so Mount Florida station, Battlefield and the immediate area around the stadium is going to be very, very busy for the next six days.

    The first session starts at 10:00 with doors opening two hours before, so plan your journey carefully and make sure you leave plenty of time.

    Following yesterday's park and ride problems, organisers say they're putting more resources into the system from today.

    At the Barry Buddon Shooting Centre in Carnoustie, public transport and roads are expected to be particularly busy today and tomorrow. The centre is about a 40-minute walk from Carnoustie railway station.

    Generally speaking, if you are catching a train this morning, services towards Central station from Ardrossan, Largs, Paisley Canal, East Kilbride, Neilston, Newton, Motherwell, Lanark and Larkhall are all expected to be exceptionally busy.

    Peak services to Queen Street station from Stirling, Perth, Cumbernauld, Falkirk and Edinburgh via Airdrie are expected to be the same.

     
  8.  
    Yesterday at the Games 07:33: Graham Fraser BBC Scotland

    It was another great day at the Commonwealth Games for Scotland yesterday.

    The undoubted highlight was the success of Erraid Davies, the 13-year-old swimmer from the Shetland Islands.

     Erraid Davies

    Erraid, the youngest competitor at Glasgow 2014 and Team Scotland''s youngest ever competitor, won a bronze medal in the SB9 100m breaststroke. and her smile melted many a Scottish heart.

    Chris Pritchard proposes to girlfriend in the velodrome

    While we are all feeling a bit soft, how about the moment Scottish cyclist Chris Pritchard proposed to his partner Amanda Ball in the stands of the Sir Chris Hoy Velodrome after racing in the keirin?

    In all, there was two silver medals and three bronze for Scots. There was a second silver of the Games for Aileen McGlynn and Louise Haston in the para-sport tandem time trial. McGlynn also became engaged after her triumph.

    Katie Archibald took bronze in the women's cycling 25k points race in the velodrome, while in the pool Scotland took silver in the 4x200m freestyle relay and Hannah Miley won bronze in the 200m individual medley.

     
  9.  
    Today's weather 07:17: Christopher Blanchett BBC Weather presenter

    It'll be a misty start in places with some patches of low cloud. This should burn off quite quickly to leave a dry morning with bright spells. Through the day it stays dry with bright or sunny spells and light winds.

    The best of the sunshine is likely to be around the coastline with cloud building at times inland. Afternoon highs around 20C to 21C, with a few spots climbing to around 23C in west central Scotland and the south.

     
  10.  
    Latest updates
  11.  
    Welcome 06:59: Marianne Taylor BBC Scotland news

    Good morning and welcome to BBC Scotland Live. We'll be here until 23:00 bringing you all the latest news, sport, weather and travel from throughout the country.

    It's Day five of the action at Glasgow 2014 and there are 27 medals to to be won - we'll have all the latest Team Scotland news as it happens.

    Send us your comments and pictures using #ScotlandLive, by email or by text on 80295.

     

Features

  • 13-year old Erraid Davies wins swimming bronzeDay Four

    Some of the key moments from Day Four of Glasgow 2014


  • SyedTanks not toys

    Lyse Doucet on the plight of children in Syria and Gaza


  • Boy with head stuck in railingsSmall Data

    Heads stuck in banisters - the official statistics


  • The two sisters in their bakeryBaking hot

    Why two Spanish sisters started a bakery in the desert


  • A farmer walks in front of a construction site of new residential buildings in Hangzhou, ChinaPrice drop

    Sharp falls in China's property market


BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.