Scottish independence: 'Havoc' warning from pensions firm

sterling Punter Southall says clients are worried about their finances should Scotland become independent

A leading pensions advice firm has voiced concerns about what it calls the "havoc" that may be wreaked on clients' finances by Scottish independence.

Punter Southall, with offices in Edinburgh and Aberdeen, has highlighted what it says are possible threats to the retirement plans of Scots.

It said clients had raised their own concerns should the 2014 referendum result be a "yes".

The Yes Scotland campaign said the company was "scaremongering".

Few businesses are willing to be as forthright in their views on independence as Punter Southall, for fear of some bruising political responses.

In private, though, it's a frequent refrain that businesses want to have less assertion and more certainty about what's proposed and what could follow from the vote going for or against independence.

Business people are often privately critical of the delay in reaching a referendum decision, and many want a clearer picture of what costs and delays would be involved in a transition to Scottish independence.

The risk of "havoc" from Punter Southall is based on fears of what might happen, using worst case scenarios, much more than a risk-weighted assessment of what will happen.

Already facing pressure over the concerns being raised, the pro-independence campaign has sought to play down the extent of sudden change to tax rates and regulation.

But it has further work to do on pensions and welfare, and how different they may look in an independent Scotland. We should learn more about that during 2013.

As pensions involve a big personal investment and commitment - both financial and psychological - the fears raised by this one pensions firm represent a potent political threat to the "yes" lobby.

Punter Southall outlined a number of concerns raised by clients in a statement released on Friday.

These included the possibility that employers could re-locate south of the Border, citing comments recently by the chairman of Royal Bank of Scotland that it may not stay in Scotland if the tax regime becomes unattractive.

Clients have also told the actuarial and investment firm that they are concerned a corporate "brain-drain" could lead to higher unemployment and a less "pensioned" population.

They have raised the possibility of less cross-subsidy within UK pension schemes, and "a regulatory black hole" where Scottish pensions are currently regulated by UK-wide bodes.

Gerry Devenney, head of Punter Southall's Edinburgh office, said: "There has been a marked upturn in concerns raised by our clients over just what independence would mean for them and their members.

"As it stands, independence could wreak havoc on pensions in Scotland. There are too many imponderables and too many unanswered questions. The longer this remains the case, and the nearer we get to the vote, the deeper the concern will be for the future of pensions in Scotland."

A spokesman for Yes Scotland said: "This sounds like yet more scaremongering. Your pension agreement is with a private company and your rights would be unaffected by independence."

Mr Devenney has written to First Minister Alex Salmond asking for answers to the points he has been raising and asking also whether the SNP intends to reverse the recent merger of the long-established professional body for Scottish actuaries.

Punter Southall has 800 UK staff in pensions, financial and actuarial advice. It claims to have 4,000 private clients and 1.5 million private sector pension scheme members, with assets worth around £90bn.

More on This Story

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More Scotland business stories



Try our new site and tell us what you think. Learn more
Take me there

Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.