Mixed results for Scottish jobs market

Sign on Jobcentre window The number claiming benefits rose by 1,200

Related Stories

Official labour market figures have presented a mixed picture with the number out of work down, but the claimant count is up.

In the three months to the end of April, the number of people who were not in work fell by 10,000 to 207,000.

However, in separate figures released at the same time, the number of people claiming benefits rose by 1,200.

Secretary of State for Scotland Michael Moore described the rise in the claimant count as "disappointing".

He added: "The fall in unemployment over the three months to April is welcome news but we recognise these are challenging times for the Scottish labour market."

The number of people economically active in Scotland, which counts those who are in work or available for work, also fell by 16,000 and now stands at 2,680,000.

The unemployment rate stands as 7.7% - the same as the UK as a whole.


Three figures explain the mixed picture in this month's unemployment survey data. Don't just look at the reduced number of people looking for work in February, March and April, down by 10,000.

So far so good, continuing a six-month trend. But it's also worth looking at the reduced number of people who are in employment, down by 7,000.

How can both be true? Because of the reduced number of people in the workforce. That's down by 16,000, as people take early retirement, start full-time education or as family care duty calls.

While the number seeking work is down, the number on Jobseekers Allowance is up by 1,200 to 139,300. A similar pattern - the survey data improving, while the claimant count worsens - exists for the UK as a whole.

That's not uncommon. If anything, it suggests the numbers seeking work at some point during a three-month survey period are becoming more likely to stay out of work so that they start qualifying for benefits. And the claimant count was a snapshot from May, making it more up-to-date than the survey data.

Over the past year to April, the number seeking work has fallen by only 10,000. Unemployment has been remarkably stable, while 43,000 more Scots are in work.

And delving into the data from the Office of National Statistics, perhaps the most striking figure is the lack of strikes.

In April, there were 14 disputes, only four of them in the private sector, and in the year to April, there were only 102 disputes. The lack of militancy is extraordinary when set against widespread wage freezes and the pension squeeze.

The finance and employment secretary, John Swinney, said the Scottish employment rate was above the UK as a whole, and the economic inactivity rate also remained lower than the rest of the UK.

He added: "While I welcome continued falling unemployment, there can be no grounds for complacency and more needs to be done to support jobs, secure investment and boost economic activity across Scotland.

"That is why this government is seeking new job-creating powers in the Scotland Bill, so that we can do more to support economic recovery and advance the interests of the people and economy of Scotland."

The Scottish Chambers of Commerce (SCC) said Scotland's job market could now be at a crossroads.

Chief executive Liz Cameron said: "On the one hand, the private sector is picking up and new jobs are being created, or part-time jobs are being converted to full-time roles.

"On the other hand, we are only just beginning to experience the effects of contraction in the public sector as a result of spending cuts.

"The remainder of 2011 will be crucial in determining whether private sector growth will be enough to match public sector contraction in Scotland."

In the UK as a whole, unemployment fell by 88,000, between February and April taking the jobless total to 2.43 million, the biggest quarterly fall for a decade.

However, once again the number of people claiming Jobseeker's Allowance (JSA) jumped by 19,600 last month to 1.49 million, the worst figure for more than a year.

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More Scotland business stories



Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.