Driver whose car killed Mhairi Convy and Laura Stewart branded reckless

Mhairi Convy and Laura Stewart Mhairi Convy (left) and Laura Stewart were both students at the former Central College of Commerce

Related Stories

A man whose car mounted a pavement in Glasgow killing two students has been accused of lying and being reckless for not disclosing he suffered blackouts.

William Payne appeared as a witness at an inquiry into the deaths of Mhairi Convy, 18, and Laura Stewart, 20, in Glasgow on 17 December 2010.

The 53-year-old refused to answer some questions after being advised he did not have to if it may incriminate him.

A previous criminal case against Mr Payne was dropped by the Crown.

Following this, the fatal accident inquiry was then arranged to look at the circumstances of the deaths of Ms Convy and Ms Stewart.

Sheriff warning

They were killed by Mr Payne's Range Rover on North Hanover Street in Glasgow.

Appearing as a witness, Mr Payne was advised that his examination did not constitute a bar to criminal proceedings.

He was warned by Sheriff Normand that he was not required to answer any question which may show him to be guilty of a crime or offence but he did have to answer questions that did not incriminate him.

Crash scene The students died after being struck by the Range Rover on North Hanover Street

During his appearance, Mr Payne faced a series of questions from Dorothy Bain - the QC representing the families of the two women - but he refused to answer many of them.

Ms Bain still quizzed him on the renewal of an HGV licence in July 2010 - five months before the accident.

The QC said the "no" box was ticked on a document asking if Mr Payne had suffered any blackouts in the last five years.

However, the court heard a number of claims Mr Payne had collapsed during that time - including once while taking his dog to the vet.

'Utterly unreliable'

Ms Bain accused Mr Payne of being "totally and utterly unreliable about his medical history".

She went on: "If you had answered 'yes' (on the document), you would not have been allowed to drive.

"You were reckless to the safety of other people using the streets because as we have seen today you are just looking out for number one.

"That should be your mantra - number one, that is what matters."

Mr Payne replied: "I don't want to answer that."

The QC also said: "Your selfishness has taken the lives of two young women. What more serious thing has happened to you.

"Two young women perfectly innocently going out doing their Christmas shopping.

"You could have prevented that by telling the truth."

'Sorry' claim

Mr Payne again replied he could not answer what was put to him.

The QC later referred to Mr Payne's police interview after the accident in which he claimed he was "sorry".

Ms Bain said to Mr Payne: "You could have been stopped driving in the July. Do you know what would have happened?

"You would not have to be sorry or even be here today as Mhairi Convy and Laura Stewart would be alive.

"The responsibility rests squarely on your shoulders."

He replied: "I cannot answer that question."

The inquiry continues.

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Glasgow & West

Weather

Glasgow

7 °C 4 °C

Scotland Live

  1.  
    09:10: A9 cameras: 'We had to do something' BBC Radio Scotland

    Statistics will be released later on A9 speed cameras. Neil Greig, from the Institute of Advanced Motoring, told Good Morning Scotland average speed cameras seem to be the one kind of camera that drivers respect, which brings down "particularly the high end, excessive speeding".

    Traffic on the A9

    Mr Greig said: "The ultimate solution to the A9 is a dual carriageway all the way from Perth to Inverness and that will take years.

    "We had to do something, we came up with the idea of average speed cameras and it's part of an ongoing group of things; engineering solutions, police enforcement, education."

     
  2.  
    09:00: HMP Inverclyde won't go ahead Reevel Alderson Home affairs correspondent, BBC Scotland

    Plans for a new women's jail in Inverclyde have been scrapped.

    Architect's drawing of proposed HMP Inverclyde

    It follows criticism of the £75m plan to replace Scotland's women-only prison, Cornton Vale in Stirling.

    Holyrood's Justice Secretary Michael Matheson said Scotland must take a more radical and ambitious approach to female offending.

    The Scottish government will now consult on a plan to provide smaller regional and community-based custodial facilities across the country.

    In the two months since he became minister, Mr Matheson has been scrutinising the plans for the proposed prison in Greenock which was to be built on a former high school site.

    It was the idea of his predecessor, Kenny MacAskill, so that Cornton Vale could close in 2018.

     
  3.  
    08:55: What the papers say

    "We want answers" is the headline for the Daily Record which reports that the brother of one of the Glasgow bin lorry crash victims is unhappy at the lack of information from the city council about what went wrong.

    Scotland's newspapers

    The Scottish Daily Mail is launching a campaign to cut the death rate among young drivers - pointing out that 22 Scots died last year in accidents involving young or inexperienced motorists.

    The Scottish edition of the Times reports that Pauline Cafferkey, the Lanarkshire nurse who contracted Ebola while volunteering in Sierra Leone, was wearing a different type of protection equipment from her colleagues.

    Read our full review of today's papers here.

     
  4.  
    08:46: 'Help not jail' BBC Radio Scotland

    On plans for HMP Inverclyde, Scottish Labour Deputy Leader Kezia Dugdale tells Good Morning Scotland that "prison doesn't work for women" and alternatives to custody are three times more effective.

    She says: "We're talking about women who've suffered extreme trauma, physical and sexual abuse, mental health problems, addiction. What they need is help, not jail.

    "It's not about being soft or hard on crime. It's about focusing on what works. Just 5% of the women sentenced to jail last year were jailed for serious and violent offences. And 76% of the population are in for six months or less."

    Ms Dugdale says they should be in smaller facilities close to their community, so they can keep links to children.

     
  5.  
    Text 80295 08:39: Coming up...

    Morning Call is about to get under way on BBC Radio Scotland, with Louise White asking would you ever support fracking in Scotland? We also want to know, six months on from the Commonwealth Games, what difference has Glasgow 2014 made to you? Text 80295 and listen to the show here.

     
  6.  
    08:31: Gas prices down

    Energy company SSE has said it is cutting its domestic gas prices by 4.1% from 30 April, a move which will save the average household £28 a year.

    pylons

    SSE is now the fifth of the "big six" energy firms to have reduced gas prices, following cuts from E.On, British Gas, Scottish Power and Npower.

    EDF is the only one of the big six yet to announce price cuts.

    The moves follow a fall in wholesale gas prices of about 20% since the end of November.

    SSE also said it would extend its guarantee not to increase its gas and electricity prices until July 2016.

     
  7.  
    08:22: Body found in park

    Police have found a woman's body in the east end of Glasgow.

    The body was found in a park near Tynecastle Street in the city's Cranhill area at 16:00 yesterday.

    Police are treating the death as unexplained.

     
  8.  
    08:15: 'Bluster' over A9 cameras BBC Radio Scotland

    With stats out later on the controversial average speed cameras on the A9, Mike Burns, spokesman for the "A9 Average Speed Cameras are Not the Answer" campaign, tells Good Morning Scotland he expects "bluster and false positives".

    Average speed camera

    "There's no denying there has been an effect on the A9, however the opinion varies on what the effect is.

    "You now have vehicles travelling in convoy on a single carriageway, but when people move onto a dual carriageway, as one driver described it, it's like champagne corks popping out of bottles because people are putting their foot down to get past the queues because they're frustrated.

    "The cameras don't solve the problem of the A9. The SNP government have sat on their hands on the A9 for the past eight years. There were improvement projects due to start in 2007/8 which they cancelled and we ended up with this absolutely ludicrous A9 safety quango."

     
  9.  
    08:06: The back pages...

    Celtic fans have triggered a storm of protest from their Glasgow counterparts after they paid for a full page newspaper advertisement claiming Rangers are a new club and that the "Old Firm" derby was dead.

    craig gordon

    The game itself is not a foregone conclusion according to Celtic keeper Craig Gordon, who insists his side's chances of beating Rangers in Sunday's League Cup semi-final are only 50-50.

    It's another day of Scottish football gossip and you can read our full review here.

     
  10.  
    07:56: Fracking row BBC Radio Scotland

    Mike Weir, SNP energy spokesman at Westminster, tells Good Morning Scotland a moratorium on fracking is a "sensible" idea.

    He says he is backing the move because the devolution of some aspects of unconventional oil and gas production, including licensing, is not due until after the general election under Smith Commission recommendations.

    Mr Weir continues: "At the moment there are existing licenses, and there's the potential for the department of energy and climate change to grant new licenses in the interim. We don't think that should happen.

    "We have very strong reservations about fracking. There is increasing evidence from the United States that fracking can have environmental impacts, and concerns about it. We think we need to look at this very very closely indeed."

    He adds: "We're talking about fracking in an area of central Scotland that's densely populated. I don't think it's sensible to rush ahead with this."

     
  11.  
    07:47: Fracking moratorium

    MPs from several parties are to try to put the brakes on the shale gas industry by demanding a moratorium on all developments until the dangers have been properly assessed.

    fracking graphic

    The move coincides with a warning from Westminster's Environmental Audit Committee that the process could pose a risk to public health and is incompatible with this country's climate change commitments

     
  12.  
    07:38: Murray ready for partisan crowd

    Scotland's Andy Murray is ready to deal with a partisan home crowd when he faces Nick Kyrgios in the Australian Open quarter-finals tomorrow.

    Andy Murray

    The pair will meet in the night session match on Rod Laver Arena at 08:15 GMT.

    Kyrgios, 19, is the first Australian man for 10 years to reach the last eight and hopes to become the first for 39 years to win the title.

    "Obviously the crowd will be right behind him, understandably so," said Murray, 27.

     
  13.  
    07:32: Lord Smith heads Games legacy project

    Lord Smith of Kelvin has agreed to chair of one of Scotland's largest regeneration projects, Clyde Gateway.

    Lord Smith of Kelvin

    Lord Smith, who chaired the Smith Commission on Scottish devolution, will lead Clyde Gateway on delivering the post-2014 Commonwealth Games legacy.

    The work focuses on regenerating Glasgow's east end.

     
  14.  
    07:26: BBC Scotland Travel Latest

    Roads: High wind warning on the Skye and Kessock Bridges.

    Edinburgh - One lane closed on A1 northbound for resurfacing works between Newcraighall Road and The Jewel.

    A73 Chapellhall to Newhouse Road still has a contraflow in place.

    Kilmarnock - A76 has temporary traffic lights in place at the Bellfield Interchange

    Ferries: Calmac's Fionnphort-Iona is on amber alert because of the weather.

    Disruption likely on the Oban-Colonsay sailings and likewise on the Oban-Tiree ferry.

     
  15.  
    07:19: HMP Inverclyde Reevel Alderson BBC Scotland social affairs correspondent

    "The 2012 report by former lord advocate Dame Elish Angiolini, which looked at the whole question of women in prison in Scotland, concluded that putting women in prison for minor offences wasn't the best thing for them or even for society. It said those who carry out serious crimes should be jailed but the rest, many with children outside, mental health or drugs problems, should be dealt with in smaller units.

    "That was accepted across the chamber but it seems the plans to build a jail for 300 women in Greenock flew in the face of that.

    "The Scottish government said it would make a decision by the end of the month, that's this week. I expect we will hear one way or another in the next few days."

     
  16.  
    07:10: HMP Inverclyde

    Pressure is building on the Scottish government to shelve plans for a new womens' prison in Greenock. The deputy leader of the Scottish Labour party, Kezia Dugdale, will force a vote on the HMP Inverclyde plan at Holyrood this week.

    Architect's drawing of proposed HMP Inverclyde

    The prison would have the capacity to hold 300 women and replace Cornton Vale which is due to close in 2018.

     
  17.  
    07:05: A9 speed camera stats due

    Statistics linked to the setting up of average speed cameras on the A9 are expected to be released later.

    Average speed cameras on A9

    The controversial camera system was installed at 27 sites from Perth to Inverness and went live in October.

    Despite critics claiming it would have little effect on safety, it is understood both speeding and accidents are down.

     
  18.  
    07:04: BBC Scotland Weather Latest

    A breezy day to come with scattered showers, heaviest in the northwest and over the Northern Isles, where they'll bring a mix of hail, thunder and sleet, with a covering of snow over high level roads.

    Eastern Scotland: Dry and clear with a few icy patches, but this is also where we will see the best of the sunshine.

    Central and southern Scotland: A few showers and some decent bright spells.

    Noticeably colder than yesterday, at 5C to 7C.

    West or northwesterly winds -fresh for most but strong, even touching gale force - around the northwest coast and over the northern isles.

     
  19.  
    07:00: Live and kicking Paul McLaren BBC Scotland News

    Good morning and welcome to Monday's Scotland Live, where we will bring you all the latest news, sport, travel and weather updates from around the country between now and 19:00.

     

Features

Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.