Melissa Young jailed for Christmas Day murder in Edinburgh

Edinburgh Sheriff Court The Crown earlier rejected Young's plea of guilty to culpable homicide

Related Stories

A woman who stabbed her neighbour to death in Edinburgh on Christmas Day has been jailed for life after being found guilty of murder.

Melissa Young, 37, must serve at least 20 years before she can apply for parole for killing Alan Williamson at a Glenure Loan flat on 25 December 2013.

The Crown earlier ejected her plea of guilty to culpable homicide.

Passing sentence, Judge Lord Boyd told Ms Young she had been convicted of a "cruel and wicked attack".

He said: "Having murdered him you set about trying to persuade health professionals that you were suffering from diminished responsibility.

"While it's true that you have a severe personality disorder it's clear it played no part in what happened that night.

"You showed no remorse, in fact you told this court that you were 'indifferent' to his death."

Devil Lucifer

He said it would be for the parole board to decide whether Ms Young should be released on licence. The sentence was backdated to 27 December last year when she was remanded in custody.

Before the five-day trial began Young admitted killing Mr Williamson on the grounds of "abnormality of mind" but she denied murdering him.

She claimed she saw a bright light and heard voices in her head before she "flipped" and stabbed Mr Williamson 29 times.

Young, who has a tattoo of the Virgin Mary on one arm and the Devil Lucifer on the other, said the archangel Saint Michael had taken over her body and used her as an instrument of God to punish the "unclean demon".

She attacked Mr Williamson after he rejected her Christmas present of a pair of unisex trainers and a copy of the Sun newspaper's 2014 calendar.

Young said if he had accepted the gifts from her she would not have stabbed him.

Shocked community

The jury heard that when police arrived at her flat in Clermiston, Edinburgh, Ms Young's hands were covered in blood and Mr Williamson was lying dead behind her front door.

Jim Keegan QC, defending, said in his closing speech doctors had revealed his client was liable to "violent and dangerous outbursts".

He added: "This can only have been a frenzied and savage attack. It's a very tragic case."

Det Insp Grant Johnston, of Police Scotland, said: "Melissa Young carried out a violent attack on her neighbour and the severity of the injuries inflicted led to his death.

"Officers in attendance quickly detained Young and at no time was there ever any risk to other members of the public although this incident did shock the local community

"The length of sentence handed down today reflects the violent nature of this offence."

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Edinburgh, Fife and East



Min. Night 13 °C

Referendum Live


    When will we know the result? It is very difficult to predict. The bulk of the local results are expected to come in between 03:00 and 06:00.

    22:12: Postal votes

    In East Lothian, they are reporting that at least 94% of postal votes have been returned - the authority's previous record was 65%.

    Elsewhere, the Dumfries count reports a 95.5% return rate on postal votes. And there may be some handed into polling stations.

    22:09: Count under way Andrew Black Political reporter, BBC Scotland

    Counting is getting under way for Edinburgh at the national count centre in Ingliston.

    Postal votes are first, with the first ballot boxes expected to start arriving at about 22:45, we're told.

    22:03: On-the-day poll John Curtice Professor of politics at Strathclyde University

    YouGov have announced they will release the results of their on-the-day poll at 22:30.

    22:03: Vote registrations

    There were 4,285,323 people registered to vote - that is about 97% of the possible electorate.

    There were 789,024 postal vote applications, which was the largest volume of registration for postal votes ever in Scotland.

    22:00: Polls closed

    The polls have now closed at polling places across Scotland. The referendum on Scottish independence is all over bar the counting.

    "Should Scotland be an independent country?" was the questioned answered by voters.

    We should know the verdict of the people of Scotland by breakfast time.

    21:58: Scotland decides John Mullin BBC referendum editor

    On television, on radio and online, the BBC is mounting its most comprehensive coverage ever of a major political event as Scotland decides. Our correspondents are at every count - all 32 of them - and beyond, to tell the full story of this momentous referendum. And, sometime tomorrow morning, they will deliver the answer that Scottish voters have given to the six-word ballot paper question: "Should Scotland be an independent country?"

    Before voting began at 7am today the polls told us it was too close to call - at this moment in time it could hardly be more exciting.

    The referendum - which sees 16 and 17 year olds given the vote for the first time - is the culmination of a campaign signalled more than three years ago when the SNP's Alex Salmond was returned again as first minister with an overall majority and on a manifesto pledge to deliver a referendum.

    Prime Minister David Cameron agreed, via the Edinburgh Agreement, but the third option - to vote neither for independence or the status quo but for further devolution - was ruled off the ballot paper.

    Throughout the night, the BBC news website will - on this page - bring you all the key developments, as soon as they happen. And you'll have plenty of reasons to stay with us because we'll have detailed stories, the key moments in pictures and video, analysis and reaction.



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.