Scottish independence: Salmond and Darling clash in TV debate

 

The issue of which currency an independent Scotland might use was among those on which Alex Salmond and Alistair Darling went head to head

Alex Salmond and Alistair Darling have clashed in a TV debate ahead of the Scottish independence referendum.

Scotland's first minister said the nation was being run by Westminster parties it did not vote for.

Mr Darling, leader of the pro-Union Better Together campaign, said independence campaigners had failed to answer key questions.

The STV debate, from the Royal Conservatoire of Scotland, in Glasgow, came ahead of the 18 September vote.

Alex Salmond: "No one will do a better job of running Scotland than the people who live and work in Scotland"

Alistair Darling MP: ''No thanks to the risk of independence''

Mr Salmond told the 350-strong studio audience that very few people disputed Scotland could be a successful, independent country.

He said 49 of the 71 countries which took part in the Glasgow Commonwealth Games were the same size or smaller than Scotland, yet thousands of children with families were reliant on food banks, while the UK government was spending an "obscene" amount of money on nuclear weapons, based on the Clyde.

"For more than half of my life, Scotland has been governed by parties the we didn't elect at Westminster - and these parties have given us everything from the poll tax to the bedroom tax, and they are the same people who, through 'Project Fear' are telling us that this country can't run our own affairs," said Mr Salmond.

"My case this evening is simple - no one, absolutely no one will do a better job of running Scotland than the people who live and work in Scotland.

"On 18 September, we have the opportunity of a lifetime - we should seize it with both hands."

line
Analysis
Programme

By Colin Blane, BBC Scotland correspondent

This was a lively, sometimes ill-tempered verbal contest with the two politicians remaining in entrenched positions.

Alex Salmond opened by saying an independent Scotland would place a much greater emphasis on social justice.

Alistair Darling insisted that by remaining in the UK, voters in Scotland could have the best of both worlds.

There were noisy exchanges. Alistair Darling pressed Alex Salmond repeatedly about which currency he would use if the rest of the UK refused to enter a currency union.

For his part, Alex Salmond urged Mr Darling to accept that Scotland could be a prosperous independent country. Again and again he asked him to say if he agreed.

The audience showed its irritation on occasions when the two men seemed to be dodging questions. It remains to be seen who will be judged the winner.

line
'Blind faith'

Alex Salmond and Alistair Darling disagreed on whether the political status quo was democratic or not

Mr Darling said the referendum was about Scotland's future, not patriotism.

"There are times that, for the love of our family and the love of our country, it's sometimes best to say 'No' - not because we can't, but simply because it is not the best thing to do," he said.

"In six weeks' time, we will make the biggest decision that we've ever made here in Scotland - and remember this, if we decide to leave, there is no going back - there's no second chance."

The Scottish Labour MP said a referendum "No" vote was not a vote for no change, and hitting out at Mr Salmond, the former UK chancellor said: "We cannot make this decision on the basis of guesswork, fingers crossed or his blind faith."

"Let's say with confidence, let's say with pride, let's say with optimism, 'no thanks' to the risks of independence and let's say 'let's have the best of both worlds, not just for us but for generations to come."

line
Debate fact check
TV debate

By Anthony Reuben, head of statistics, political analyst Emily Craig and data journalist Marc Ellison

  • In the TV debate "spin room", Deputy Scottish First Minister Nicola Sturgeon said Scotland was one of the wealthiest countries in the world. This claim is about GDP per head (that's the total amount of goods and services produced by the economy divided by the population). The current rankings of GDP per head among OECD countries puts the UK is in 18th place and the "Yes" campaign reckons an independent Scotland would be in 14th place
  • Alistair Darling said the working age population was falling faster in Scotland than the rest of the UK. That is confirmed in this report from the UK Statistics Authority, which says: "The dependency ratio in respect of elderly people is projected to increase faster than for the UK"
  • Alex Salmond said Scotland had contributed £8bn to UK finances. According to Scottish government figures, Scotland has contributed more to the Treasury per head than the UK average, if you assume a geographic share of North Sea revenues. In 2011-12, it was £1,500 more per head (the figure Mr Salmond quoted) and, if you multiply that by the Scottish population, you come to £8bn
  • Alistair Darling said that, for the last 22 years, Scotland had spent more than it has collected in tax. This is supported by Scottish government statistics with the exception of 2000-01, when there was a £2.1bn surplus. The figure is based on dividing North Sea oil on a geographic basis
line

The two rivals clashed on a range of other issues during the two-hour programme, including:

  • Mr Darling said Scotland would get "substantial" new powers if it stayed in Union. Mr Salmond said SNP MPs would "vote for more powers" in the event of a "No" vote, but insisted: "We're anticipating a 'Yes' vote."
  • Mr Salmond said an independent Scotland could keep Sterling, insisting: "It is our pound as well as England's pound." Mr Darling said leaving the UK but keeping the pound was "a bit like getting a divorce and keeping the same joint bank account".
  • Mr Darling said there was a question mark over how long it would take an independent Scotland to become an EU member. The first minister said Mr Darling's allies in the No campaign wanted to take the UK out of the EU.
  • On finance, Mr Darling, said: "In the last 22 years Scotland has spent more than it has put in, so we have benefited from being part of the United Kingdom. Mr Salmond argued: "In each one of the last 33 years, Scotland has paid more in tax per person than the average of the UK."

Following the debate, Blair Jenkins, head of the Yes Scotland campaign for independence, said: "This was a clear win for the 'Yes' campaign - a positive, optimistic and visionary case presented by the first minister, against another dose of negativity and scaremongering from Mr Darling.

Better Together campaign director Blair McDougall, added: "The nationalists had arrogantly said this would be 'Salmond's Bannockburn'. It may yet turn out to have been his Waterloo."

Meanwhile, it is understood there were technical issues with the STV player during the debate, which allowed viewers to watch the debate online.

The BBC had asked for permission to stream the debate live online and use it on other platforms, but the request was declined by STV.

A second debate is to take place on the BBC later this month.

 

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

Comments

This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
 
 

Comments 5 of 1167

 

More Scotland stories

RSS

Scotland Live

  1.  
    10:55: Shetland church fire

    An investigation has been launched following a fire at a Shetland church.

    Firefighters were called to St Clements Church in Lerwick's St Olaf Street at about 20:45 on Monday.

    The church building has been undergoing refurbishment and the fire was described as having caused "serious" damage to an extension.

    A joint Scottish Fire and Rescue Service and Police Scotland investigation is under way.

     
  2.  
    10:48: Ferry services cancelled

    In Orkney, Pentland Ferries has cancelled all of its services today and Northlink's 16:45 sailing from Stromness and the 19:00 sailing from Scrabster have also fallen victim to the weather.

    Orkney Ferries say that because of worsening sea conditions the MV Graemsay has cancelled the rest of today's sailings to both Graemsay & Moaness.

    Also on the Hoy Head service the last sailing from Houton today will be 1315. The 13.30 sailing from Kirkwall to Westray and Papa Westray and the return has also been cancelled.

     
  3.  
    10:36: Bridge storm driver banned

    A delivery driver who attempted to drive his van across the Forth Road Bridge during a storm last year has received a 12-month driving ban.

    David Stanley from London ignored signs warning not to use the bridge when it was being buffeted by 90mph winds last December.

    Van blown by wind

    The van swayed and toppled onto railings causing the bridge to be closed to all traffic for two hours.

    Stanley claimed he only saw a sign saying the bridge was closed a mile in advance - by which point he had missed the last slip road.

     
  4.  
    10:29: National Trust chief to step down

    The National Trust for Scotland will appoint a new chairman after Sir Kenneth Calman announced he will step down in a year's time.

    Sir Kenneth will have been at the head of Scotland's largest conservation charity for five years when he completes his term of office.

    Sir Kenneth Calman

    He will formally relinquish his role at the charity's AGM in September 2015.

    Sir Kenneth said: "There is still much to do and I look forward to continuing to be part of a great organisation."

     
  5.  
    10:22: Drunk teens The Scotsman

    Thousands of children and young people were treated for alcohol-related injuries or illnesses by Scotland's NHS in the last three years.

    Nearly 5,000 young people aged between 10 and 18-years-old, received medical help following alcohol-related incidents.

    Read the full story.

     
  6.  
    Text 80295 10:14: Bad driving - Your Views

    Jim Ewing: I reported a driver to police Scotland five weeks ago. This driver overtook me in a 20mph zone during school lunch hour. I told them the incident had been recorded on an in-car camera and they could come to my house to view the evidence. I have had no contact from the police whatsoever. I am now left wondering why I bothered to report them if the police do nothing when they have concrete evidence!

     
  7.  
    10:07: Seal of approval

    A Shetland woman who has been caring for sick animals for more than 27 years is to receive a prestigious award.

    Jan Bevington, 67, rescued her first seal in 1987, and then established the Hillswick Wildlife Sanctuary.

    Jan Bevington

    And she played a key role in the wake of the Braer oil tanker running aground in 1993, which saw almost 85,000 tonnes of crude oil spill.

    She is to receive a special award from the International Fund for Animal Welfare (IFAW) at the House of Lords.

     
  8.  
    09:59: Neglected sheep The Press and Journal

    Tweets: Aberdeenshire sheep farmer fined for animal neglect.

    Read the full story here.

     
  9.  
    09:55: Travel update BBC Scotland Travel Latest

    The Skye Bridge is completely closed to all vehicles. The Forth Road Bridge, Dornoch and Erksine Bridges are closed to high-sided vehicles. Tay Road Bridge is closed to double deckers with a speed restriction in place. There are localised problems on the roads from Inverness to the Borders, with leaves on the roads and falling branches around wooded areas.

    The ferries are taking the brunt of the weather. CalMac say no sailings today between Stornoway and Ullapool. Oban to South Uist is off, and Islay cancelled until at least 6pm. Northlink, Orkney and Pentland ferries showing some disruption here and there. Argyll ferries are back on a full service.

    On the trains, not been too bad so far weather-wise, but Argyle Street station was closed in Glasgow because of a fire alarm.

     
  10.  
    Text 80295 09:54: Bad driving - Your Views

    Katie, Glasgow: Motorway driving is atrocious and no sign of police dealing with middle lane and outside lane hoggers who cause most of the problems!

    Martin, former Strathclyde Police Officer, Glasgow: It's sad that we are discussing this as an idea. A good police officer always has had the power to give someone a talking to. Police officers' greatest power is that of discretion. It shouldn't be black and white, there are instances where education should always be an option. Simply applying a fixed penalty is a way of alienating someone who, in the main, is probably a law-abiding citizen and may simply have had a lapse in concentration.

     
  11.  
    #ScotlandLive 09:47: Your Views

    Edinburgh Tom tweets: With more & more wind farms generating ever more wind is it any wonder it's come to this? Environmental correctness gone mad.

     
  12.  
    09:41: Moffat power cut

    Up to 100 homes in the Dumfries and Galloway town of Moffat are without power after this morning's stormy conditions.

    Scottish Power says their network in the town sustained "extensive damage" because of the weather.

    A spokesman apologised for any inconvenience and said the company hopes to have most, if not all, residents re-connected by midday.

     
  13.  
    09:34: University strike threat

    Staff at several Scottish universities have backed strike action in a row over pensions.

    Nine Scottish universities including Aberdeen, St Andrews and Strathclyde were balloted by The University and College Union (UCU) as part of their UK wide ballot.

    University library

    It said more than three-quarters (78%) of those who voted supported strikes, while 87% were in favour of action short of walkouts.

    The UCU will take part in talks on Wednesday in the hope to avoid industrial action which could potentially affect hundreds of thousands of students.

     
  14.  
    Text 80295 09:26: Bad driving - Your Views

    Marlko, Clydebank: There is nothing new in traffic officers dishing out verbal warnings. I was a road patrol officer in the late 60's and 70's in the Glasgow Police. VW were issued everyday and recorded in the VW register at the road patrol office. We could check the register to see if an offender had been warned before; if so, we could change our way of dealing with the case.

    Andy in the Borders: I hope while the police have their purge on bad drivers they will also do something about the drivers blatantly flouting the law by driving with their lights on. Also, the new phenomenon of daytime running lights, drivers using them and nothing else in dark hours. I'm sure I can't be the only driver being affected by these idiots.

     
  15.  
    09:21: UK-wide benefit fraud campaign

    A campaign is being launched across the UK today by the Department for Work and Pensions focussing on benefit fraud and the penalties attached to it.

    Job centre logo

    In Scotland, the initiative concentrates on Edinburgh, West Dunbartonshire and Fife and warns claimants that not updating changes in circumstances may tip them into making fraudulent claims.

    But while the UK Government is pushing the message that new systems for gathering data help them identify false claims, critics say that it is the inefficiencies of the system which ought to be targeted, rather than claimants.

     
  16.  
    09:19: Taking to the slopes

    A new ski resort is expected to open in southern Scotland within weeks.

    The Lowther Hills Ski Club has applied for planning permission to build a clubhouse and a 600m rope tow on the slope near Wanlockhead.

    Lowther Hills in winter

    It is hoping to attract snowsports enthusiasts from across Scotland and the north of England to the village in Dumfries and Galloway.

    It is part of a wider plan to market the area as a year-round sports resort.

     
  17.  
    09:11: BBC Scotland Weather Latest

    Hi Kawser here. Heavy rain now clearing north east. Sunny spells and squally showers today, with hail and thunder. Winds still very strong with warnings.

     
  18.  
    09:00: Paralysed man walks again John Beattie BBC Scotland

    Wouldn't it be great if this was the first step to a permanent repair? - Paralysed man walks again after cell transplant.

    A paralysed man has been able to walk again after a pioneering therapy that involved transplanting cells from his nasal cavity into his spinal cord.

    Paralysed man walking

    BBC One's Panorama programme had unique access to the project and spent a year charting the patient's rehabilitation.

    You can watch Panorama's To Walk Again this evening at 22:35 on BBC One.

     
  19.  
    08:54: BBC Scotland Travel Latest

    Orkney Ferries - no sailings Stromness and North Hoy, and North Hoy and Graemsay, bad weather.

    Banchory B974 closed by overturned car btwn A93 High St/ B976. A car is on its side about 1/2 mile prior to Strachan. No delays reported.

    It is taking approximately 24mins to get to Charing Cross on westbound GW M8 from about junction 10.

     
  20.  
    08:52: Weather update James Cook Scotland Correspondent, BBC News

    tweets: Bridge restrictions. Some trees down. Ferry disruption. All fairly standard for an autumn gale in Scotland so far:

    ex-Hurrican Gonzalo
     
  21.  
    08:51: Pedal power

    Edinburgh hopes to move a step closer to hosting a stage of the Tour de France, if funding for other cycling events is approved.

    Councillors will meet later to discuss bringing the Tour of Britain and the Pearl Izumi Tour Series to the city.

    tour de france

    They hope it could pave the way to being part of the world's most famous bike race after they narrowly lost out to Yorkshire as the hosts of the Grand-Depart this year.

     
  22.  
    08:47: Tune in Louise White Presenter, Morning Call

    The number of verbal and physical assaults on school staff has risen in nearly half of Scottish council areas, according to statistics. Is a zero tolerance approach the best way to deal with abusive pupils?

    Louise White

    And motorists are facing a major crackdown by police, who will target bad drivers as they focus on roadside re-education. Do you think a warning can stop bad driving?

    The lines are open now, 0500 92 95 00 or text 80295.

    You can listen live here.

     
  23.  
    08:39: After the big vote... Graham Fraser BBC Scotland

    The majority of people in Motherwell who voted in last month's referendum supported an independent Scotland. A month after the vote that rejected independence, what is the feeling on the streets of the North Lanarkshire town?

    Peter Ross joined the SNP following the referendum result
     
  24.  
    08:36: High winds 'biggest issue'

    As strong winds hit Scotland as the remains of Hurricane Gonzalo pass over the country, Transport Minister Keith Brown has been speaking on Good Morning Scotland about the weather concerns.

    Transport Minister Keith Brown

    "We have some localised issues - for example, fallen trees on some roads," he said. "We have some flooding and some disruption to ferry services, because of the high winds which seems to be the biggest issue just now."

    Mr Brown also advised people using Scotland's transport network today to "give themselves more time".

    "Giving yourself that additional time means you get to your destination safely and on time," he added.

    "For some parts of Scotland, the weather will particularly become more pronounced through the evening hours. The same advice is true."

     
  25.  
    08:25: Back-page headlines

    Rangers boss Ally McCoist is optimistic about funding talks between former Ibrox director Dave King and the current board, report The Herald and The Scotsman.

    On-loan Celtic striker Teemu Pukki says he is tempted to stay at Brondby beyond the January transfer window.

    Rangers boss Ally McCoist

    And Sir Alex Ferguson has led the tributes to Glenn Gibbons, the former chief football writer of The Scotsman, who has died aged 69.

    Read the rest of the headlines making the back pages here.

     
  26.  
    08:21: Living with a smoker

    Non-smokers who live with a smoker are exposed to three times the officially recommended safe levels of damaging air particles, according to a study.

    The researchers found that living with smokers is the same as living in smoke-free homes in heavily polluted cities such as Beijing or London.

    A man smoking

    They said moving to smoke-free homes could have major health benefits for non-smokers.

    The study, published online in the BMJ's Tobacco Control journal, was carried out by researchers at the universities of Edinburgh and Aberdeen.

     
  27.  
    08:15: Wet weather BBC Scotland Weather Latest

    The worst of the wet weather is across the north east at the moment and it will continue to clear away eastwards and be replaced by showers throughout the day.

    We are looking at some snow over the hills, the Highlands and Grampian. There will be a few wintry showers over the highest road routes, but nothing will settle.

    Man with umbrella

    It will stay cold throughout the day - highs of eight or nine degrees, falling to four or five in the showers. It is the winds that are of concern throughout the day. A Met Office Yellow 'Be Aware' warning is in force - gusts of 60 to 70mph across the west, up to 80mph for Orkney, 50-55mph across the central belt.

    Those strong winds will transfer to the north east through the day.

     
  28.  
    08:10: Today's papers

    The Scottish Sun and the Daily Record lead with an alleged assault on Celtic goalkeeper Lukasz Zaluska.

    Front pages 21 October

    Meanwhile, The Scotsman looks at statistics which it says shows an increase in the number of assaults on teachers.

    Read the rest of our newspaper review here.

     
  29.  
    08:03: Travel disruption BBC Scotland Travel Latest

    Blustery, but we're managing! Main problem around many roads from Inverness to Borders are leaves and falling branches around wooded areas. Cal Mac services Arran 08:20 from Brodick & 09:45 from Ardrossan have been cancelled.

     
  30.  
    08:01: Weather sparks travel warning

    Winds up to 75mph are expected to hit Scotland as the remnants of Hurricane Gonzalo pass over the country.

    The west coast is predicted to be worst affected, with heavy rain also forecast throughout today.

    High waves at Ardrossan

    The Met Office has issued a yellow "be aware" warning of wind throughout Scotland.

    The A87 Skye Bridge has been closed to high-sided vehicles, as has the A90 Forth Road Bridge and there has also been disruption to some ferry services.

    Traffic Scotland has warned of difficult driving conditions and the potential for some disruption on the roads.

    There are reports of fallen trees and other debris on the roads, but police say all major routes are open.

    The strongest gust so far has been 64mph recorded on the Forth Road Bridge shortly after 06:00.

     
  31.  
    08:00: Welcome Thomas McGuigan BBC Scotland News

    Good warming and a very warm welcome from the Scotland Live team as we bring you a comprehensive round-up of the latest news, sport, travel and weather between now and 18:00.

     

Features

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.