Sir Walter Scott's legacy 'should be recognised'

Bust of Sir Walter Scott at his former home, Abbotsford House The finishing touches are taking place at Abbotsford House

Related Stories

An academic has called for greater recognition of Walter Scott's legacy as his novel Waverley marks its 200th anniversary.

Prof Alison Lumsden, of the University of Aberdeen, said criticism of Scott over the 'shortbread tin lid' view of Scotland should be put aside.

Academics from around the world will gather in the city this week at a conference to discuss his legacy.

Prof Lumsden said the complexity of Scott's work should be recognised.

She said: "At the time of the publication of Waverley in 1814 Scott was already a best-selling poet and the anonymous Waverley was soon to become a phenomenal success, with sales of the novel outstripping those of all others combined that year.

"But Scott has often been given a bad press for producing a redundant image of Scotland that is based on tartan, stags and romantic Highland scenery.

"This is far from the full picture and the more we read his work and talk about it to those outside Scotland the more we recognise its complexity.

Sir Walter Scott factfile

Sir Walter Scott
  • Born in Edinburgh, 15 August 1771
  • Works included The Lady of the Lake, Waverley, Rob Roy, The Heart of Midlothian and Ivanhoe
  • Described as "a born storyteller who could place a large cast of vivid and varied characters in an exciting and turbulent historical setting"
  • Died at Abbotsford, 21 September 1832
  • Considered a founder of a "virtually new literary form" -the historical novel
  • A literary prize is presented in his name annually

Source: Encyclopaedia Britannica

"While some of the many adaptations of Scott offer such cliched stereotypes of Scotland, Scott writes fiction that confronts many of the issues that are relevant for Scotland today and offers surprisingly modern conclusions."

Prof Lumsden has been part of a team, led by Professor David Hewitt, also from the University of Aberdeen, which has spent almost three decades restoring Scott's work to produce the Edinburgh Edition of the Waverley Novels.

She says this edition has identified and eliminated many of the errors made by printers - but frequently attributed to Scott himself.

She suggested those errors may have arisen as printers rushed to meet demand for his work and to decipher his famously "spidery" writing.

"As a result of the speed at which Scott's novels were produced, the printers often misread words and got the punctuation very wrong," she said.

"People used to say he was a sloppy writer but almost every example of poor writing we have come across in the novels involves errors in the production process."

She added: "It is time to put an end to the common belief that Scott was sloppy and slapdash as many of these errors are now recognised as resulting from the printing process."

To mark the bicentenary of Waverley, Prof Lumsden will welcome delegates from around the world to the university's Sir Duncan Rice Library, which houses one of the best collections of print materials related to Scott anywhere in the world.

They will use the collection, which contains not only all of Scott's works but also comic books, dramas and other items derived from Scott, to re-examine his output and the legacies he has left to modern Scotland.

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More Scotland stories


Scotland Live

    Broadcasting's future 08:31:

    What happens to the BBC and broadcasting in general if there is an independence Yes vote?

    Shadow Secretary of State for Scotland, Margaret Curran, told Good Morning Scotland: "The proposals are to take Scotland out of the BBC and replace it with a new state broadcaster.

    "I think that would be bad for viewers and I think that would be very bad for the industry in Scotland because ultimately it would lead to a higher licence fee or lower quality.

    "Currently we put £300m in through our licence fee and we get £3bn back. I think the idea of a completely new separate state broadcaster wouldn't have support in Scotland."

    Travel update 08:27: BBC Scotland Travel Latest

    Traffic is slow on the A90 Dundee Road with gas works causing congestion in both directions at Longforgan.

    There are also delays on the M90 at Perth and Kinross with a lane closed at Junction 9 near Balmanno Hill.

    In Edinburgh, a broken down car on A720 Edinburgh City Bypass is causing queues eastbound back to Hermiston Gait.

    The B1936 through Glenlivet remains closed along with School Road in Hopeman following last week's heavy flooding.


    Paper review 08:20:

    The Scotsman has a front page picture of Shelley Kerr, the first female manager in Scottish senior football, but its main story is about the referendum.


    It picks up on comments from Alex Salmond that he "would retire from politics tomorrow" if it would guarantee a Yes vote in the independence referendum.

    In other referendum stories, both the Herald and the Times Scottish edition have similar headlines, declaring the English are seeking a "heavy price" for the referendum.

    And the Scottish Daily Mail carries a warning from former BBC director general Lord Birt that Scottish independence would result in cuts to BBC programmes and services.

    See the front pages here in our paper review.

    Morning Call 08:14: BBC Radio Scotland

    On today's Morning Call we want to know your views on Scotrail's decision to raise peak-time fares by 2.5% next year. The increase is based on the Retail Price Inflation (RPI) figure for July, at which level the Scottish government had said it would cap increases.

    Louise White asks: Is travelling by train still value for money?

    In a speech earlier this week, the Prime Minister highlighted that grandparents are getting a "raw deal" after stepping in to look after children whose parents have died or are unable to provide adequate care themselves. He signalled that thousands could be given parental rights to paid leave and greater financial support.

    Louise asks: Should grandparents be given more recognition?

    Tell us what you think by calling 0500 92 95 00, texting 80295 or emailing. The lines are open now.

    You can listen live to the debate here.

    Today's weather 08:09: BBC Scotland Weather Latest

    It will be a cold start to the day but it will soon break to see some bright weather and only a few showers in the north. The rain will gradually spread into the northwest and the west Highlands.

    Temperatures will range from 14C in the far north to 17C in parts of the south and east.

    You can watch a full forecast here.


    Traffic Scotland tweets: A9 both ways at Gleneagles Station Jct - Lane 1 on both carriageways will be closed *continuously* from 20th Aug to 10th Sept.

    08:00: Steven Brocklehurst BBC Scotland news website

    Good morning. News, sport, weather and travel from across Scotland coming up between now and 6pm.



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.