Church of Scotland General Assembly votes to allow gay ministers

 
General Assembly of the Church of Scotland The decision followed a passionate debate at the General Assembly of the Church of Scotland

Related Stories

The Church of Scotland's ruling General Assembly has voted to allow actively gay men and women to become ministers.

Assembly commissioners in Edinburgh voted in favour of a proposal that allows liberal parishes to opt out of the church's policy on homosexuality.

Legislation will be drafted for next year, then go to regional presbyteries and return for final approval in 2015.

Divisions were caused when the first openly homosexual minister was appointed by the Kirk four years ago.

Two congregations and six ministers broke away.

Analysis

The Church of Scotland has done everything it can to minimise the impact of today's momentous decision.

It insists that the church's traditional policy - that sex should take place only within heterosexual marriage - remains intact and says it's just that liberal congregations will be able to opt out to recruit ministers in gay relationships.

It's true that the decision still needs to be legally drafted and sceptical presbyteries consulted.

But there's no escaping the huge significance of today's decisive vote, which accepted that homosexual activity is permissible - and open even to the church's clergy, so often seen as role models and moral arbiters.

If and when it the decision is enacted, the church's insistence that nothing substantial has changed will become all but impossible to sustain.

The vote to allow gay ministers in civil partnerships follows a report by the church's theological commission, which set out arguments on both sides.

General Assembly rules dictate it must be approved at a presbytery level. Draft legislation will be presented at next year's assembly, go out to regional presbyteries and then get official approval at the 2015 gathering.

The Moderator of the General Assembly of the Church of Scotland, the Right Reverend Lorna Hood, said: "This is a massive vote for the peace and unity of the Church."

The Kirk said that after a "full but gracious debate" it affirmed its current doctrine and practice in relation to human sexuality but moved to permit sessions wishing to depart from the traditional position to do so.

Mrs Hood added: "This was a major breakthrough for the Church but we are conscious that some people remain pained, anxious, worried and hurt. We continue to pray for the peace and unity of the Church."

The dilemma faced by the Church of Scotland goes back to 2009, when the openly gay minister Scott Rennie was appointed to the Queen's Cross parish in Aberdeen.

He was backed by most of his congregation and by the General Assembly, but the decision resulted in protest and the break-away of a small number of congregations and ministers.

The Rev Scott Rennie Gay minister Scott Rennie was appointed at Aberdeen's Queen's Cross Church in 2009

Speaking to BBC Radio Scotland, Reverend Rennie said the General Assembly vote was a "good decision" and a "fair compromise".

Tom French, from the Equality Network, welcomed the move by the Kirk.

He said: "This is a positive step forward for a more equal society, and speaks to the progressive values of 21st Century Scotland."

A Free Church of Scotland spokesman said: "We don't understand what's going on in the Church of Scotland, and suspect the vast majority of the Scottish public don't have a Scooby either.

"We believe that Scotland needs the guidance of the national church rooted in the teachings of the Bible, irrespective of public opinion and pressure to conform."

At the Kirk's gathering in 2011, commissioners voted to accept gay and lesbian clergy - on the condition they had declared their sexuality and were ordained before 2009.

At that General Assembly, the theological commission was set up to report this year, before a final decision was taken.

Protesters at the General Assembly of the Church of Scotland Protesters who opposed any change also gathered outside the assembly

Last June, a Glasgow Kirk became the first to split from the Church of Scotland over the issue of gay clergy. St George's Tron Church said its 500-strong congregation believed the General Assembly's decision in 2011 had "marginalised the Bible".

And in February, the Rev Dominic Smart and his congregation of 300 at Gilcomston South in Aberdeen left the Church over the same issue.

A total of six ministers have now left the church over gay ministers.

The General Assembly is the supreme court of the Church of Scotland and its annual national business meeting.

The Assembly was first held in 1560, the year of the Scottish Reformation which marked the beginning of the Protestant Church in Scotland.

About 850 church commissioners - mainly ministers and elders - from across the church's 48 presbyteries, gather in the Assembly Hall on the Mound in Edinburgh for a week in May.

 

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

Comments

This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
 
 

Page 1 of 11

 

More Scotland stories

RSS

Features

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.