Edinburgh tram project bosses payments revealed

An Edinburgh MSP calls for the former directors of the city's trams company to return the £400,000 given to them in severance pay

Related Stories

The directors of Edinburgh's failed trams company Tie received hundreds of thousands of pounds in severance payments when it was closed down.

Figures released by Edinburgh City Council show seven directors were given £406,635 in compensation.

Tie was disbanded after a long and expensive dispute with the project's main contractors, which resulted in delays and spiralling costs.

The details were published despite the council's initial refusal to do so.

A £776m tram line between Edinburgh Airport and St Andrew Square is due to be completed by summer 2014.

The original plan had been for the tram line to run from the airport to Newhaven.

Tram company bosses - compensation for loss of office

Directors Level of compensation

For more detail see table below

Steven Bell, tram project director

£87,211

Richard Jeffrey, chief executive

£82,825

Alastair Richards, managing director (ETL)

£49,130

Frank McFadden, Infraco director

£49,857

Susan Clark, programme director

£66,864

Dennis Murray, commercial director

£39,893

Gregor Roberts, finance director

£30,855

Details released by the council show project director Steven Bell received £87,000 in compensation, while chief executive Richard Jeffrey took home nearly £83,000.

Both managing director Alastair Richards and Infraco director Frank McFadden were given £50,000, while three other directors - Susan Clark, Dennis Murray and Gregor Roberts - shared more than £137,000 in compensation.

The figures were part of a release by Edinburgh City Council, which itemised the pay and bonus packages of its board of directors in their final year.

Tie was closed down late last year but its board of directors received full salaries and compensation.

The total earned by the board last year, including severance pay, was more than £1.3m.

Lesley Hinds, the authority's transport convener, said: "I have long called for greater transparency into the tram project and the publication of these figures is a step in the right direction - even if I don't agree with the amounts.

"This is an opportunity to draw a line under Tie's involvement and for us as councillors to ensure that, from here on in, the project is tightly managed and all spending is properly scrutinised."

Alastair Maclean, director of corporate governance, added: "The council took direct control of the tram project in 2011 at a point when it was clear a change of direction was needed.

"Following the council decision on 2 September 2011, construction is now proceeding in line with the revised budget and programme.

Start Quote

Over £400,000 in pay-offs is a slap in the face of the people of this city”

End Quote Jim Eadie MSP

"New governance arrangements were put in place and the council brought in professional project management expertise and agreed to wind down Tie Limited, as was reported on 25 August 2011.

"There was a significant cost in resolving the issues with Tie and putting in place more effective control of the project."

Edinburgh Southern MSP Jim Eadie has called for the directors of Tie to forego their pay-offs saying "there must be no reward for failure".

The SNP politician added: "It is right that the details of the severance payments have been published.

"Over £400,000 in pay-offs is a slap in the face of the people of this city.

"They will be aghast that after years of disruption and delay that public officials responsible for the catalogue of mistakes and incompetence will walk away with golden goodbyes."

David McLetchie said it was important to remember that it was taxpayer who was footing the bill.

The Conservative MSP for the Lothians said: "We have become so used to figures escalating out of control in relation to this project that it is tempting to ignore this latest payout.

"But we must never forget that it is ultimately the taxpayer who is paying for this and by any standards has had appalling value for money."

Salaries of tram company bosses

Directors Salary Bonus Other benefits Compensation for loss of office Total for 2011/12

Source: City of Edinburgh Council

Steven Bell, tram project director

£180,567

£15,113

£1,000

£87,211

£283,891

Richard Jeffrey, chief executive

£105,577

0

£5,000

£82,825

£193,402

Alastair Richards, managing director (ETL)

£186,706

0

0

£49,130

£235,836

Frank McFadden, Infraco director

£147,320

£5,124

£1,000

£49,857

£203,301

Susan Clark, programme director

£79,638

£9,182

£1,000

£66,864

£156,684

Dennis Murray, commercial director

£107,625

£5,600

£1,000

£39,893

£154,118

G. Roberts, finance director

£81,846

0

£1,000

£30,855

£113,701

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Edinburgh, Fife and East

Weather

Edinburgh

Min. Night 9 °C

Features

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.