Cuts and pay freeze unveiled in Scottish budget

Finance Secretary John Swinney delivers his Scottish budget - from Democracy Live

Related Stories

The Scottish government has announced plans to cut spending and bring in a public sector pay freeze in its budget plans for the year ahead.

Finance Secretary John Swinney said he was facing a UK government-imposed cut of more than £1bn.

Housing, education and tourism spending will be cut, while business rates will rise for large retailers.

Mr Swinney also told parliament he would freeze public sector salaries for a year and end big bonuses.

Unveiling his spending plans and draft budget, he said a 3% "efficiency savings" target would be imposed across public services.

He also confirmed he plans to introduce a pay freeze for public sector workers earning £21,000 a year or more.

Staff earning below £21,000 will receive a minimum annual increase of £250.

The move will apply to Scottish government staff, as well as those working in government agencies and non-departmental public bodies.


Government departments have been told their budgets and the cuts they face.

Click on the links to discover more detail.

It also "sets a framework" for discussions on pay with NHS staff, teachers, police and firefighters, Mr Swinney said.

He said public sector pay represented more than 50% of his budget, and that restricting it would save thousands of jobs.

The finance secretary has also offered a deal to Scotland's councils, agreeing to limit cuts in local authority spending to 2.6% if they delivered SNP priorities such as continuing the council tax freeze for a fourth year.

As part of the deal, the councils would also have to maintain police officer numbers - which have been boosted by 1,000 since the SNP came into power in 2007.

The deal has been accepted by the local government umbrella body Cosla, but Mr Swinney warned that authorities would see their budgets cut by 6.4% unless their leaders agreed to it.

The commitment to officer numbers has been welcomed by the Scottish Police Federation, although it said the 2.6% cut in police budgets would "create challenges".

Mr Swinney also told MSPs that spending in other areas would be protected, such as the NHS, although there is a pledge to reduce the number of senior managers in the health service by 25% over the next four years.

BUDGET FOR 2011-12

BUDGET FOR 2010-2011

Office of the First Minister-£255m

Office of the First Minister-£279m

Finance - £2.219bn

Finance - £2.473bn

Health - £11.758bn

Health - £11.662bn

Education - £2.481bn

Education - £2.715bn

Justice - £1.267bn

Justice - £1.435bn

Environment and Rural - £539m

Environment and Rural - £594m

Administration - £236m

Administration - £262m

Crown Office - £108m

Crown Office - £118m

Local Government - £9.046bn

Local Government - £9.585bn

Scottish Parliament and Audit Scotland - £95m

Scottish Parliament and Audit Scotland - £98m

TOTAL - £28.007bn

TOTAL - £29.224bn

The Scottish government policy of abolishing prescription charges completely next year will still go ahead in 2011, and the existing eligibility for free bus travel for the over-65s will be maintained.

Mr Swinney said spending on capital projects would be sustained, by moving £100m from this year's budget, and plans were still on track for constructing a replacement for the Forth Road Bridge.

Funding for the prison service is one of the biggest losers in the budget, facing a 22% cut while housing will see a cut of 19.3% in the next year.


The winner? The NHS with a real terms increase - although health staff would undoubtedly tell you that rising demand and rising costs cancel that out.

The losers? Housing, colleges and universities (although the big cut is in capital, not revenue), prisons.

There are cuts too in rail services and motorway maintenance among the spread pain.

Will the Budget get through? As of tonight, no.

Each of the opposition parties is declaring that it falls short - with Labour particularly vituperative about the absence of detailed planning beyond next year.

There will be less money for rail and motorway services, and the axe has also fallen on the education budget with a 12% cut to colleges and universities.

But Mr Swinney said university places would be maintained without the introduction of tuition fees in Scotland, and he also made a commitment to keep smaller class sizes in primary schools.

University and Colleges Union Scottish official, Mary Senior, said: "The cut in higher education funding is much more severe than the overall cut in the Scottish budget.

"However, universities must not use the cuts as an excuse to push for higher student fees or to axe jobs."

However, Scottish Labour's finance spokesman Andy Kerr accused the finance secretary of putting party political interest before that of the country by bringing forward a one-year rather than a three-year budget.

He said: "He is not running a country - he is running an election campaign.

"It is outrageous that our local authorities, health service, our universities, further education colleges, police and fire services are being denied the ability to plan effectively.

"They are all demanding clarity so that they too can set budgets, deliver services and reassure staff, but they cannot because of the SNP."

'Election campaign'

The Scottish Conservatives' finance spokesman Derek Brownlee welcomed the freeze in public sector pay and council tax but also said Scotland needed a "longer-term budget".


Ministers claim they've surpassed expectations in recent years, when efficiency achievements were recycled within departments.

Now, it seems only councils will be allowed to recycle their savings - as part of their deal with Mr Swinney.

Every other department - including health - will have to get by with the assumption that they're driving their allocations at least 3% harder. Previously, they had a 2% target, and each year you look for savings, they tend to get harder to find.

That answers the question of whether the biggest single-year spending cut, starting next spring, will involve services being axed, or salami-sliced. It looks like thin strips of Italian sausage are on the pre-election menu - £876m-worth of them.

The party's transport spokesman, Jackson Carlaw, said: "It is entirely fair that the roads budget should shoulder its share of savings, not least because of the costs involved in the new Forth crossing.

"It would however be regrettable if the reduction in the budget for the maintenance and improvement of our motorways and trunk roads led to greater long-term costs as a result of the roads infrastructure being allowed to deteriorate below an acceptable standard."

Jeremy Purvis, for the Scottish Lib Dems, said: "On the day when unemployment is going up in Scotland but down in the rest of the UK, the SNP are wrong to cut support for enterprise, colleges and tourism, but not to cut high pay, bonuses and waste.

"The budget is too hard on services because it's too short-term.

"This is a dangerous way for every school, hospital and college to try and plan ahead. They can't take sensible decisions if they don't have the future plans."

The leader of the Scottish Green Party, Patrick Harvie MSP, said: "As expected, ministers have decided to defend their outdated, polluting and divisive investment in pet schemes such as the additional Forth Road Bridge, sacrificing socially beneficial projects like housing in particular, and failing to address the central challenge - will the Scottish Parliament prove its worth and use progressive taxation to defend this country against cuts?"

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More Scotland stories



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.