Russia: how tough a response?

Russian president Vladimir Putin Members of Vladimir Putin's inner circle have been targeted by existing sanctions

The rhetoric could scarcely sound tougher but will the reality come close to matching it?

David Cameron, writing in yesterday's Sunday Times. said that "for too long there has been a reluctance on the part of too many European countries to face up to the implications of what is happening in eastern Ukraine."

"It is time to make our power, influence and resources count," he wrote.

Ed Miliband, speaking in Washington DC on Monday, agreed, saying "the international community has not done enough to show that Russian aggression cannot be allowed to stand" and "European unity must not be an excuse for European inaction".

Whilst Nick Clegg said at his news conference this morning that the EU had so far failed to "act with the right collective resolve," adding that "we believe the time has now come for sanctions to be tightened further and that is precisely what we will be seeking to deliver in the meetings in the EU later this week".

So that's clear enough then. There's just one problem. The next round of sanctions will not be determined by Britain but by the EU's 28 member states.

Aerial view of Canary Wharf Russia has substantial financial interests in London

As my colleague Gavin Hewitt - the BBC's Europe Editor - points out on his blog, Europe has been very tentative in what it's willing to do to take on Russia and there's no reason to think that caution won't continue.

He writes that "Italy with its fragile economy, which continues to hover close to recession, is very dependent on Russian energy. Germany has 6,000 firms which do business in Russia. Some of its leading industrialists have been vocal in opposing sanctions. France has resisted pressure to halt delivery of two Mistral helicopter carriers to Russia."

You might think that The Netherlands would be leading the way in taking on Russia. Their attitude will, of course, have been changed by last week's national tragedy but remember that the EU country with the largest trade deficit is, you guessed it, the Netherlands.

The last figures showed that figure to be over 16 billion euros (£12.6bn), according to data from Eurostat.

Some EU countries argue that the most effective sanctions would be financial, stopping Russia accessing the City of London. That, of course, would hit the UK and not the rest of the EU.

City of London

You may recall that in March I revealed the existence of a photograph of a document which a senior official was carrying into a meeting in Downing Street which said that "the UK should not support, for now, trade sanctions or close London's financial centre to Russians".

Nothing has changed since then, I'm told.

So, sources tell me that we should expect some gradual movement in Brussels tomorrow rather than a dramatic tightening of the screw.

This is not just for selfish economic reasons but also because many EU countries argue that their best - or maybe their only - hope of getting access to the crash site and getting co-operation with the investigation is to maintain a dialogue with President Putin

In a news conference on Monday, Angela Merkel's spokeswoman, Christiane Wirtz, said industry-wide sanctions were not being considered but Berlin was prepared to target individual companies.

After speaking to Angela Merkel and Francois Hollande, Mr Cameron said he was "very clear that the EU will be ready to take further steps in terms of other areas, other areas of ... some forms of advanced industrial goods that might have dual uses for defence purposes as well".

In other words, even the deaths of almost 300 people in a crash which most EU countries blame Russian-backed separatists for will not lead directly to what many people will see as a tough response.

Nick Robinson Article written by Nick Robinson Nick Robinson Political editor

What a difference a day makes

In just 24 hours, Sir Malcolm Rifkind went from angry defiance to a grim-faced acceptance that he would have to quit his job as an MP and chairman of the Intelligence and Security Committee.

Read full article


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 755.

    @ 744. Billythefirst :
    Why do you need reporting on demonstrations? If you really care, you'll know they're happening long before they take place. If you really care, you'll take part. What do you need a report on it for? Or an HYS? So yo can moan and whinge and delude yourself you've done your bit? From behind your computer screen?

  • rate this

    Comment number 754.

    747. Global Yawning
    "They've changed their tune rather quickly!!" [US intelligence on Russian culpability]


    During the Cold War (and beyond), the Stasi had Operation Gladio etc. 100% tracked, so it's likely the Russians have that info too, and much of it the US would still probably very much like not to become too public.

    I'd have thought there's a basis for "businesslike" dealings there.

  • rate this

    Comment number 753.

    747. Global Yawning
    "Pro-Russian separatists probably shot down MH17 "by mistake", no link to Russia found - US intelligence"

    Oh, that means we won't need any of the "uncompromising sanctions" Osborne and DC called for. They look right muppets now. Farage might have to retract his "Putin is callous" comment, but RT won't invite him for his lucrative monthly chats for a while. US Cold feet?

  • rate this

    Comment number 752.

    Of the intended voice recorder analysis the BBC writes:

    "The information is incredibly sensitive so investigators gather in a sealed room so that only those that should be listening can listen"

    Who decides who "should" and who "should not" be listening, on what grounds, and why?

    I'm sorry. Without more, this just will not do.

  • rate this

    Comment number 751.

    At a time when there is increasing scepticism across Europe about the benefits of membership, is putting economic self interest ahead of the murder of its citizens a wise choice.


Comments 5 of 755



Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.