Maria Miller expenses row: What led to her quitting?

Maria Miller: "I wish I could have stayed"

Related Stories

Maria Miller has resigned as culture secretary following a row over her parliamentary expenses, but what was the dispute all about?

Who is Maria Miller?

An LSE graduate and teenage Conservative activist who grew up and was educated in Bridgend, Maria Miller was elected as MP for Basingstoke in 2005 and rose to become one of the most senior women in the Conservative Party.

She became culture secretary in 2012 - one of four women in David Cameron's cabinet - having previously been a minister at the Department for Work and Pensions.

She was in a high-profile job, having been in charge of getting laws through Parliament to legalise same-sex marriage and to overhaul regulation of the newspaper industry in the wake of the phone-hacking scandal.

line break
What was she accused of?

In December 2012, the Daily Telegraph published a story suggesting that Mrs Miller had claimed £90,718 in expenses over a four-year period towards mortgage payments on a house in south London that she shared with her husband, her children and her parents.

The newspaper said this appeared to be a breach of the rules on parliamentary allowances in force before 2010, which allowed MPs to claim back mortgage interest and other costs associated with having a second home.

Questions subsequently arose about whether Mrs Miller - who funded the purchase of her home with an offset mortgage - had failed to reduce her mortgage claims as interest rates fell.

Houses of Parliament MPs were banned from claiming mortgage interest on second homes in 2010
line break
Was this investigated?

Yes. Following a complaint by the Labour MP John Mann, the parliamentary commissioner for standards starting investigating the case in 2013.

In her report, Kathryn Hudson cleared the MP of making false expenses claims and said her parents had not benefited financially from the arrangements in relation to her second home.

But she concluded that Mrs Miller over-claimed by £45,000 for expenses towards mortgage interest payments and council tax on the family home in London on the basis of the rules that were in place at the time.

She recommended that the MP should repay this precise sum.

line break
So, did that happen?

No.

According to parliamentary rules, the commissioner can only make recommendations on such complaints.

The final say over what sanctions an MP should face is left to a committee of fellow MPs and lay members - the Commons Committee for Standards. The 10 MPs have a vote; the three lay members do not.

When they considered the matter, they decided Mrs Miller only needed to pay back £5,800 to cover over-claiming of mortgage expenses.

The discrepancy sprung from the difference between the size of Mrs Miller's mortgage, which was £525,000 when she entered the Commons in 2005, and the £237,500 purchase price of the five-bedroom property.

The commissioner believed she should only have been able to claim expenses for interest payments on the original 1996 mortgage of £215,000 and additional claims were outside the rules.

The committee disagreed and said the claims should extend to additions to the mortgage. However, it also said Mrs Miller should apologise to the House of Commons because her "attitude" to the commissioner's inquiry had breached the parliamentary code of conduct.

line break
How did Mrs Miller react?

Maria Miller: "I fully accept the recommendations of the committee"

Maria Miller said she "fully" accepted the committee's recommendations and apologised "unreservedly" to Parliament.

However, the length and manner of her 32-second apology was criticised by many newspapers.

They suggested it did not reflect the critical tone of the commissioner's report and she had been let off lightly compared to other MPs - who had had to repay much larger sums in the wake of the 2009 expenses scandal.

They also focused on aspects of the commissioner's report which suggested the MP had challenged the parameters of the investigation and raised the lack of supporting and documentary information provided.

line break
Why did newspapers feel so strongly?
Sunday Telegraph front page - 06/04/14 Pressure from the press for Mrs Miller to stand down from her role has intensified

The former editor of the Daily Telegraph has acknowledged that the press may not be seen as impartial observers, given their resistance to the new system of press regulation backed by the government following the phone-hacking scandal and subsequent Leveson Inquiry.

Tony Gallagher has admitted the press "do have a dog in the fight" regarding Mrs Miller's expenses but has denied waging a vendetta against her.

Former Telegraph editor Tony Gallagher: 'Miller's resignation unavoidable'

However, he raised the bar by accusing Mrs Miller's special adviser and a close aide to David Cameron of trying to warn journalists off the original story in 2012 by raising the spectre of tougher press regulation.

The paper subsequently published the details of a phone call between its reporter Holly Watt and Jo Hindley, Mrs Miller's special adviser, in an effort to back up its claims that it had been "menaced".

Craig Oliver, the No 10 director of communications, has strongly denied threatening the paper, saying he contacted them to relay Mrs Miller's concerns about the paper approaching her elderly father.

line break
Why did Maria Miller go?
David Cameron The prime minister continued to support Maria Miller

While David Cameron continued to back Mrs Miller, one of his loyal supporters, pressure for her to go built up within the Conservative Party.

Former chairman Lord Tebbit was the first senior figure to suggest resignation, but others questioned the impact she was having on the party, just over a month before the European Parliament elections.

Mrs Miller made a last-ditch attempt to save her cabinet career on Tuesday, with her parliamentary aide Mary Macleod taking to the airwaves to say there was a press "witch-hunt" against her. The culture secretary wrote in her local newspaper that she was "devastated" to have "let down" her constituents.

But this failed to change the mood, with former House of Commons Speaker Baroness Boothroyd saying she should resign as a matter of "honour".

With the pressure from the media continuing and even growing, Mrs Miller decided to quit, saying the controversy had become a distraction for the government.

In his blog, Channel 4 News' Gary Gibbon says she was "discreetly pushed" by Downing Street, with "someone close to the prime minister" visiting to tell her the "game was up". But Mrs Miller insisted in a TV interview that it had been her own decision to go.

Mr Cameron is certain to have come under pressure over her position at prime minister's questions on Wednesday.

In his response to her resignation letter, the prime minister said he hoped she would return to government "in due course".

More on This Story

Related Stories

More Politics stories

RSS

Politics Live

  1.  
    07:21: Tidal lagoons

    Ed Davey, the energy secretary, has been speaking to the BBC about plans to generate electricity from the world's first series of tidal lagoons in the UK. The lagoons will capture incoming and outgoing tides behind giant sea walls, and use the weight of the water to power turbines. A £1bn Swansea scheme, said to be able to produce energy for 155,000 homes, is already in the planning system. Mr Davey told BBC News: "I can't make a decision on this yet because discussions are ongoing. But I'm very excited by the prospect of tidal power. We have got some of the biggest tidal ranges in the world and it would be really useful if we could harness some of that clean energy."

     
  2.  
    07:19: Banking tax explainer
    The city

    Here's a bit more on the Liberal Democrat plan to tax banks to pay off more of the deficit and how it would work. Corporation Tax is applied on a company's annual profits and is set to fall 1% to a rate of 20% from next month. But the Lib Dems say they wish to impose an additional corporation tax rate of 8% on banks only from April 2016. The party says this measure would raise £1bn a year and would go towards closing the structural budget deficit of £30bn. It said because failings in the banking system had caused the financial crisis, it was fair that banks helped repair the economy. Banks already pay a bank levy which has yielded £8bn over the past four years. The Conservatives may resist the proposals though. They've said they would cut the deficit solely by reducing spending. Labour says it would tax bank bonuses and re-impose the 50p top rate of income tax.

     
  3.  
    07:14: 'Drop migration target'
    Ken Clarke

    Elsewhere this morning, Ken Clarke has said David Cameron's net migration target should be dropped. Mr Clarke, a former home secretary, said it would be impossible to reach without "severely" damaging the UK economy. He told the Times: "I am afraid that the net migration target has proved to be a mistake. It has been defended to me as almost returning to the figures to those when I was home secretary. This is true, but we weren't in a globalised economy then to the extent we are now. We will have to drop the target. It would not be possible to achieve it without damaging our economy quite severely."

     
  4.  
    07:11: 'Beauty contest of ideas' Ross Hawkins Political correspondent, BBC News

    Despite us thinking we're a nation of homeowners, the proportion of people who actually own their own home, and live in it, has been falling in England for more than 10 years now as house prices have rocketed up. Labour have actually outbid the Conservatives by far on the number of homes they say that they would build - they are promising 200,000 homes a year by the end of the next Parliament and they say they have a plan to do it. You won't hear anyone today say the housing market is just fine, there isn't a problem here. You'll see a beauty contest of ideas, if you like, to sort it out." More on the housing announcement.: "

     
  5.  
    @campbellclaret Alastair Campbell, former Labour spin doctor

    tweets: Hope he never gets chance but would be interesting to see if @David_Cameron meets his 200k housing pledge as quickly as NHS waiting pledge

     
  6.  
    06:52: Defence spending
    Raymond Odierno

    Over the weekend, former defence secretary Liam Fox warned of a potential Tory rebellion if defence spending targets are not met. And now the head of the US Army - Chief of Staff General Raymond Odierno - has said he is "very concerned" about the impact of cuts in Britain. He said the falling proportion of the UK's national wealth being spent on the military could mean British troops end up operating within US ranks, rather than divisions working alongside each other. More here.

     
  7.  
    06:46: Newspaper review
    Metro and Telegraph fronts

    Just sitting down for your first coffee of the day? Here's our overnight newspaper review, featuring today's announcement on homes from the Conservatives and a warning on UK defending spending.

     
  8.  
    @rosschawkins Ross Hawkins, BBC political correspondent

    tweets: Housing on @BBCBreakfast - part of the reason you can't afford a home: building not yet back at pre crash levels

    Graph from Twitter
     
  9.  
    06:28: Bank tax
    Danny Alexander

    The Liberal Democrats have announced plans to tax Britain's banks with an additional £1bn levy. Danny Alexander, the coalition's chief secretary to the Treasury, wants to effectively strip banks of the benefit of recent corporation tax cuts. The money, the Lib Dems say, would be used to pay off the deficit. More here.

     
  10.  
    06:25: Housing pledge
    Generic homes

    Later, David Cameron will promise to make 200,000 homes available to first-time buyers in England by 2020 if the Conservatives win the election. Plans for 100,000 cut-price homes for people under 40 have already been announced by the coalition. Labour has pledged to build 200,000 new homes by 2020, while the Lib Dems have set out plans to build 300,000. More here.

     
  11.  
    06:20: Good morning

    Hello and welcome to a fresh Monday's political coverage. Nick Eardley and Victoria King will bring you all the action, reaction and analysis in text and you'll be able to watch and listen to all the main BBC political programmes, from Today and Breakfast through to Newsnight and Today in Parliament. Don't forget you can get in touch by emailing politics@bbc.co.uk or via social media @bbcpolitics. Here's how Sunday unfolded.

     

Features

  • A very clever little girlBrain gain

    Why are people getting better at intelligence tests?


  • BeefaloBeefalo hunt

    The hybrid animal causing havoc in the Grand Canyon


  • A British Rail signBringing back BR

    Would it be realistic to renationalise the railways?


  • Banksy image of girl letting go of heart-shaped balloonFrom the heart

    Fergal Keane on the relationship between love and politics


Try our new site and tell us what you think. Learn more
Take me there

Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.