Clegg 'shocked' by Farage's stance on Ukraine


The issue of immigration sparked a fiery exchange - Courtesy LBC/Global TV

Related Stories

Lib Dem leader Nick Clegg has gone on the attack following his EU debate with Nigel Farage, accusing the UKIP leader of "siding with Putin" on Ukraine.

At the end of their hour-long clash, Mr Farage said the EU had "blood on its hands" for encouraging revolution.

Mr Clegg, speaking on his weekly LBC radio show, said he was "shocked" by the UKIP leader's words, which he would raise at the pair's next debate.

A YouGov/Sun poll suggested Mr Farage won their first clash by 57% to 36%.

Mr Farage will get a chance to react to the debate on Friday, when he takes part in an LBC phone-in - and the pair will stage another debate on whether Britain should stay in the EU on 2 April, which will be shown on BBC Two.

Most newspapers declared the UKIP leader the winner of the first round, taking their cue from the YouGov poll:

  • The Times said the margin of the UKIP leader's victory was "convincing"
  • "Instant poll says feisty Farage beat cool Clegg," said the Guardian, but accused the UKIP leader of trading in "polemic and distorted facts"
  • The Telegraph said both men would be satisfied with the event, which had "whetted the appetite for similar televised clashes in the general election campaign next year"
  • But Mark Wallace, writing on Conservative Home, said it could establish a precedent for "Second Division" political debates, adding "might Cameron and Miliband be able to do a head to head First Division debate next year?"
  • The Daily Mail declared: "First blood to Farage"
  • The Sun said: "Nigel fries Clegg for breakfast - he wins TV debate"

Liberal Democrat leader Mr Clegg and Mr Farage avoided personal attacks during their debate, trading blows over statistics instead - and the likely impact on the economy of Britain leaving the EU.

Start Quote

Much will be written about who won and who lost this debate. That, though, ignores the reason both men agreed to take part - they knew they could both be winners”

End Quote

The UKIP leader rubbished his rival's claim that quitting the EU would cost three million jobs, saying it was based on out-of-date, discredited research, and Mr Clegg disputed the UKIP man's claim that 75% of Britain's laws were made in Brussels, suggesting Mr Farage had made the figure up.

They also clashed over who was telling the truth about EU immigration and Mr Farage's claim that 29 million Romanians and Bulgarians have the right to come to the UK.

The impact of an EU exit on Britain's standing in the world also provoked fiery exchanges.

Asked why countries like Ukraine was keen to build closer ties with the EU, which he had described as a "failed" institution, Mr Farage said: "We should hang our heads in shame.

Mr Clegg and Mr Farage each had one minute to set out their position as the debate began - Courtesy LBC/Global TV

"The British government has actually geed up the EU to pursue effectively an imperialist, expansionist - and even Mr Barroso the commission president once said we are building an empire.

"We have given a false series of hopes to a group of people in the western Ukraine. So geed up were they that they actually toppled their own elected leader.

"That provoked Mr Putin. I think the EU frankly does have blood on its hands in the Ukraine. And I don't want a European army, navy, air force or a European foreign policy. It has not been a thing for good in the Ukraine."

Reacting to the comments on LBC, Mr Clegg said he was "extraordinarily surprised and shocked to find he (Mr Farage) agrees with Vladimir Putin".

He said it was "insulting" to people in Kiev who were "simply standing up for values that we should share and support, of democracy, of autonomy".

"It shows quite how extreme people can be, like Nigel Farage, when their loathing of the European Union becomes so all-consuming that they even end up siding with Vladimir Putin," he added.

The issue of human rights legislation and its impact on the UK divided the leaders - Courtesy LBC/Global TV

But former UKIP leader Lord Pearson said Mr Farage was "justified in what he said", adding: "It is the EU's territorial ambitions which led them to offer the Ukraine an association agreement."

Former Lib Dem leader Lord Ashdown said Mr Farage had shown "inexperience" in world affairs, but praised the UKIP leader for debating "at the highest level" with "passion and confidence".

Start Quote

They couldn't bear to look at each other, eyes fixed firmly on the studio audience or TV cameras. ”

End Quote

He said Mr Farage, Nick Clegg and the public had all been the winners after their first televised EU debate, and the two "unequivocal losers", were the Conservatives and Labour who were "too divided" to turn up and argue their case.

In his opening remarks on Wednesday evening, Mr Clegg said "a Britain that leads in the world by standing tall in our own European backyard, a Britain prepared to work with other countries on the things we can't possibly sort out on our own."

He added: "We are better off in Europe - richer, stronger, safer - and that's why I will fight to keep us in, for the sake of jobs, for the sake of our clout in the world, for the sake of Britain."

But Mr Farage replied: "This debate is between a tired status quo defending a crumbling EU that frankly isn't working any more, and a fresh approach that says let's be friendly with Europe, let's trade with Europe, but let's not be governed by their institutions."

Conservative minister Anna Soubry: "What (the public) want is the opportunity to have a referendum. "

Prime Minister David Cameron, who has promised an in-out referendum if the Conservatives win the next election and Labour leader Ed Miliband, who says he will only sanction a referendum if further powers are handed to Brussels, have opted not to take part in the debates.

Conservative minister Anna Soubry said Mr Cameron's decision not to take part was "not really of any relevance at all" and "the real question" was who could deliver a referendum.

A Downing Street spokesman said Mr Cameron did not watch the debate because he had been travelling back to Number 10 after a meeting with the Queen as it began, but he had caught up with it later on TV news bulletins.

Jon Ashworth, Labour shadow minister: "Is it the big issue on people's minds? I don't know"

Labour's shadow Cabinet Office minister Jon Ashworth said it had been an "amusing" debate but did not mean much to ordinary voters worried about the cost of living.

For the Scottish National Party, MSP Aileen McLeod said: "Scotland's always been much more pro-European than other parts of the UK

"Our interests are best served by being part and parcel of the EU."

Plaid Cymru's Leanne Wood said the two men were "not really focussing on Wales's interests, and Wales's part in this debate".


More on This Story

Related Stories


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 848.

    The tragedy here is that there are crucially important things that really make a difference to people's lives, the NHS, unemployment, education, economic growth, defence, policing, the built environment and the like, and they are being sidelined by marginal issues masquerading as important issues. We need to focus on what matters, not this slapstick.

  • rate this

    Comment number 296.

    I find it shocking that the policies of choice in the UK population are now anti EU, anti US, anti cooperation (with whomever) and blind separatism in the face of what is now a global community of humans with common global issues and interests poised on the brink of true hardship. It suggests to me than man is hell-bent on short termism and self punishment :-(

  • rate this

    Comment number 289.

    The British public are fed up with politicians trying to worm their way out of every question posed to them. You get the usual 'it's more complicated' or 'you don't understand'. Anything to avoid giving a direct answer. Farage, agree with him or disagree with him, at least he answers the questions posed. Which is what makes him unique among party leaders.

  • rate this

    Comment number 239.

    What I value more than the right of Europeans to move to the UK, is my right to move to Europe. When I finish my hard graft and it's time to retire, I don't want to stay in Britain. Why should I, when I can find a nice spot in the sun in France, Italy, the Canaries. Moving out of the EU may restrict movement into this country but it also takes away some of our freedom.

  • rate this

    Comment number 173.

    Whatever anybody thinks, Farage is actually making politics interesting again, he's making us all feel like maybe, just maybe a few things may change and our lives and our country might become a better place.


Comments 5 of 9


More Politics stories



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.