'Swivel-eyed loons' or voice of the people?

Michael Fabricant's Twitter account

Related Stories

David Cameron has had to reassure Conservative Party members no-one in his inner circle thinks they are "swivel-eyed loons". But does the row illustrate a deeper problem with British politics?

Political leaders arguably need party members more than the party members need them.

Without thousands of unpaid volunteers willing to stuff envelopes and knock on doors at election time, the party leaders would stand no chance of gaining power.

All the party members ask in return, they would argue, is a little respect. The feeling their views are being listened to, that they have some influence over the way the country is being run.

But how representative are those views of the wider electorate?

Some have argued the rows over same-sex marriage and Europe, which prompted the alleged jibe by a member of Mr Cameron's inner circle about "swivel-eyed loons", shows how out-of-touch Tory activists are with modern life.

It has, inevitably, been adopted as an ironic badge of honour by some Conservative traditionalists, such as party vice-chairman Michael Fabricant, who has adopted a new Twitter avatar depicting pop-eyed comedy legend Marty Feldman.

Party membership

  • 1951 Conservative 2.9 million - Labour 876,000
  • 1971 Conservative 1.3 million - Labour 700,000
  • 1981 Conservative 1.2 million - Labour 277,000
  • 1991 Conservative one million to 500,000 - Labour 261,000 - Lib Dem 91,000
  • 2001 Conservative 311,000 - Labour 272,000 - Lib Dem 73,000
  • 2013 Conservative 130,000 - Labour 200,000 - Lib Dem - 66,000 (Source: Estimates based on party reports and House of Commons Library)

Rachel Sylvester, writing in the Times newspaper, says the row highlights a deeper problem affecting all three of the main parties at Westminster.

As party membership has shrunk, only the most committed and strident activists remain, which tends to make the parties less representative of the wider population than perhaps they would have been in the past, she says.

There is also a growing generation gap. Mr Cameron and the other main party leaders at Westminster are all in their 40s, while grassroots party members tend to belong to an older generation.

According to the Conservative campaign for Democracy the average age of Tory members is 68.

A report earlier this year suggested the average age of local councillors, across all parties, was 60.

There are, of course, plenty of younger political activists - and those with no party affiliation - who disagree with Mr Cameron's plans to legalise same-sex marriage.

But social issues often tend to divide along generational lines.

One recent opinion poll suggested the majority of under-40s would vote for a party that backed same-sex marriage, compared with 10% of those aged above 60.

Why is party membership declining?

  • Only about 1% of the British population now belong to a political party
  • Political scientists Patrick Seyd and Paul Whiteley say people have more choices over how to spend their leisure time. leaving less time for political activism
  • They also suggest people can sign up to single issue protest groups, reflecting a more individualistic age
  • And parties do not need members as much as they once did
  • A single person can send out a mass email, negating the need for legions of activists to go delivering leaflets
  • Former Tory MP Paul Goodman, writing on Conservative Home, blamed the Tory defeat at the Eastleigh by-election on a weak local party, saying clever computer systems were no substitute for "having local people on the ground"
  • Tory MP Douglas Carswell has written on his blog that political parties are run a bit like the failed music retailer HMV, when they should be run like the internet music service Spotify, which offers users a very wide choice of music at low cost
  • He says parties should be easier and cheaper for people to join, and that they should be able to use them "as a vehicle to change things", even if this is a single issue rather than the whole political programme on which traditional parties focus

An unnamed Tory source, quoted by Sylvester, says: "The activists are not swivel-eyed loons, they're your parents. They are conservative with a 'small c'."

The relative youth of Britain's political leaders feeds into a wider sense that they live in their own world, far removed from the concerns of ordinary voters.

The rise of UKIP, a party which currently has no MPs on the House of Commons benches, is seen by some as a howl of protest against an elitist, self-satisfied, and even sneering, political class at Westminster.

UKIP leader Nigel Farage never tires of berating Mr Cameron, Ed Miliband and Nick Clegg as "college kids" with no experience of the real world.

The anti-EU group claims to be the fastest growing political party in the country, with 26,000 members.

That is still a drop in the ocean compared with the mass political movements of days gone by.

Few are predicting a return to those days.

But it would be dangerous and wrong to write off mass-membership political parties as relics of the past, pundits on all sides have warned.

There are plenty of innovative ways in which party membership can be made a more attractive option to the next generation of politically motivated activists.

Mark Ferguson, writing on the grassroots Labour List website, says: "For the first party that really grasps what party membership could and should be like in the 21st Century, there are bountiful rewards."


More on This Story

Related Stories


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 341.

    Little_Old_Me "..This Government, specifically the Tory part of it, don't give two figs about us ordinary folk ..."
    Who are you kidding - very little to choose between Conservative, Labour and Liberal parliamentary parties, they are all metro-neocons supporting and supported by a wealthy minority of the electorate.

  • rate this

    Comment number 340.

    Why oh why do we expect political leaders with absolutely no life or work experience outside of politics to be able to lead the country out of recession ? They are so out of touch with the population that it would make you weep. To listen to the schoolboy evasion of answering questions at PM question time is absolutely shocking. We (the country ) deserve batter than this.

  • rate this

    Comment number 339.

    "Prime Minister David Cameron has said the coalition will continue "right up until polling day" in 2015."
    Yes and with only ONE single Scottish Conservative MP left sitting in the House of Commons he's got to go through the Scottish Referendum for Independence on Sept 18th 2014 first.
    This will be FUN!..............lol

  • Comment number 338.

    This comment was removed because the moderators found it broke the house rules. Explain.

  • rate this

    Comment number 337.

    The 3 main parties are now very similar I am is termed moderate old labour Wilsonite say, mixed economy, committment to full employment, strict immigration controls ,Eurosceptic, same views I had 30 years ago the party changed not me. All parties neo liberal economy may as well vote UKIP as at least get 2 out of the 4 above.


Comments 5 of 341


More Politics stories



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.