Child benefit change is right approach, David Cameron says


David Cameron: "This will raise £2 billion a year"

Related Stories

David Cameron has said the decision to remove child benefit from better-off families is "the right approach".

He told BBC One's Andrew Marr Show "85% of families" would get the payments in "exactly the way they do now".

The prime minister also said the government was "absolutely right" to limit most working age benefits to a 1% rise, which will be the subject of a Commons vote on Tuesday.

Labour's Ed Balls called the child benefit changes "perverse".

Mr Cameron's comments come ahead of the coalition's mid-term review on Monday.

Changes coming into effect from Monday will see families with one parent earning more than £50,000 lose part of their child benefit.

It will be fully withdrawn where one parent earns above £60,000.

'Fundamentally fair'


If you or your partner get child benefit and either of you has an income of above £50,000 a year you may have to pay more tax from Monday.

The income that counts is confusingly called 'net-adjusted income'. In fact, it is your gross income before tax from all sources but minus pension contributions, child care vouchers, and gift aid donations.

If you live as a couple it is the higher income that is counted not your joint income.

If that income is more than £50,000, the person who earns it will have to pay a new tax called 'high income child benefit charge'. It will be collected through self-assessment and you must register with HMRC by 7 October.

If that income is £50,000 to £60,000, the charge will be less than the child benefit received on a sliding scale - at £55,000 it will be 50% of the child benefit received.

If that income is £60,000 or more, the charge will equal the child benefit received. In other words, one partner will get the child benefit but the higher earning partner will pay it all back in the new tax.

Q&A: Child benefit changes

Defending the policy, Mr Cameron said: "I'm not saying those people are rich, but I think it is right that they make a contribution.

"This will raise £2bn a year. If we don't raise that £2bn from that group of people - the better off 15% in the country - we would have to find someone else to take it from."

He added: "I think people see it as fundamentally fair that if there is someone in the household earning over £60,000 you don't get child benefit... I think it is the right approach."

Asked about government plans to cap working age benefits at 1% - including the rise in the pay of public sector workers, out-of-work benefits, and tax credits - Mr Cameron said "those are all in my view absolutely right decisions".

"We need to control public sector pay... we need to limit the growth of welfare payments overall - and that must include the tax credit system, and for those out of work it's right that their incomes aren't going up faster than people in work."

The prime minister also insisted the government was going "full steam ahead" with a packed agenda in the second half of its term.

In the wide-ranging interview, Mr Cameron made a number of major points, including:

  • He promised British voters they would be offered a "real choice" on Europe at the next election
  • On the economy, he said it was vital for a country to be able to pay its debts - maintaining "a low rate of interest" so it could borrow money cheaply
  • He said he was "absolutely determined" to overhaul the deportation system so the radical cleric Abu Qatada and others could be deported from the UK before they appeal
  • The prime minister also said he was "absolutely clear" Britain would defend the Falkland Islands in the face of mounting pressure from Argentina
  • He also confirmed he wanted to remain prime minister until 2020
'No pleasure'

Writing in the Mail on Sunday, Chancellor George Osborne said he took "no great pleasure" in reducing people's benefits but that it was needed to ensure a "brighter future".

Labour's Ed Balls says that the government should tax the richest people

Conservative Party chairman Grant Shapps told the BBC's World at One: "I have three children I've filled in the form. I totally understand and get how frustrating these things are."

Mr Balls, Labour's shadow chancellor, told Sky News the changes to child benefits were "perverse".

"It's a complete shambles," he said.

"We're going to have many many hundreds of thousands of people who will end end up filing in tax returns because they didn't realise they were supposed to apply by today not to get the child benefit.

"I've always supported a principled approach to the welfare state which we would call progressive universalism."


More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 880.

    Cameron and Osborne
    Economics Lesson no 1: You don't get out of a recession by making 99% of the population poorer and giving tax cuts to millionaires who offshore their wealth.

    What you achieve out of this is economic failure, poverty, public disorder,increased property crime and (and this is the only thing this lot really care about) crucified at the next General Election.

  • rate this

    Comment number 879.

    #834 removed for telling the TRUTH which has been proven over and over again. BBC moderators in someones pocket. Why won't the BBC investigative reporters check the facts

  • rate this

    Comment number 878.

    People forget that child benefit was brought in to help families repopulate the country after a devastating war. "

    Indeed; it was called Family Allowance and, as so many forget or didn't know, it was NOT payable for the first child, only second and subsequent ones.

    An overhaul is long overdue, although the way this is being done now is not exactly fair or reasonable.

  • rate this

    Comment number 877.

    I so feel sorry for all those on £50k+ a year & losing child benefit


    One thing, UK Tax regime is attrocious. It is pointless & waste of money to tax low paid into poverty & then employ hords of workers to pay back money via Tax credits & housing benefit.

  • rate this

    Comment number 876.

    It's a crazy world we live in where the government takes money from it's own people whilst sending money abroad to other countries.

  • rate this

    Comment number 875.

    If nothing else this just goes to show that if any gov puts up or down a tax or changes a benefit in any way then it will be highly criticised by some. Maybe running a country is not as easy as some posters would like to think.

  • rate this

    Comment number 874.

    Here is a point to ponder, whether you are pro or anti. Finnish child benefit is universal, irrespective of income, and generally, the more children you have, the more is paid in allowances, at a rate rather higher than that of the UK, from 104€ a month for the first to 189€ for the fifth or succeeding. Single parents get extra. How is it that the UK cannot afford what a small country can?

  • rate this

    Comment number 873.

    I don't approve of childbirth as a profession who does?
    So, what to do? I mean in a practical sense, not Daily Wail rhetoric.
    Seems to me that the lowly qualified girl from the sink estate has limited options.
    1. £5 ph at Tesco - so tax payers can subsidise their profits.
    2. Have kids as a means of securing accommodation that she'll never earn enough to afford
    Ideas on a postcard...?

  • rate this

    Comment number 872.

    The policy is right but the implementation poor.
    Now it is time to move on to restricting child benefit and tax credits to two children only. On an overcrowded island on an overpopulated planet subsidising more is madness.

  • rate this

    Comment number 871.

    Issue is misdirected; no one should get state cash benefits unless they are in need. And then, only for as long as their need lasts. Paying child benefit, tax credits, housing, disability or unemployment benefit has been a wrong turn and no more or less than simple vote buying. WONGA takes milliseconds to determine whether you qualify or not, government means testing could be just as simple.

  • rate this

    Comment number 870.

    I just e-mailed my MP thanking him for this change as it was the final straw that pushed us to emigrate. As soon as the house is sold we're off to Canada, and probably 50% of my friends have made the same decision. The UK may not be bothered about losing professional workers but plenty of other countries are welcoming skilled immigrants with open arms. Don't whinge, go elsewhere!

  • rate this

    Comment number 869.

    846 cantsilenceme
    looks as if they can!!

  • rate this

    Comment number 868.

    This is just a tax to pay for the immigration baby boom. Birth rates in this country have rocketed from 600,000 per year to 800,000 over the last decade as a direct result of immigration. As well as the massive increase in child benefit claims an additional £40billion is needed to provide additional school places. If the goverment is serious about making saving it should tackle the prime cause.

  • rate this

    Comment number 867.

    Child benefit !

    The tories are back in town eh ?

    Anyone know how much the so called 'Civil list' will be cut this year and the following ten ?

    Anyone still like to justify nuclear weapons ?

    Anyone care to explain where the oil and gas money went ?

    Child benefit ?

    You make me sick.

  • rate this

    Comment number 866.

    None of us like change which adversely impacts ourselves do we. It's unfair. And we can always find examples to highlight. How to resolve this? - stop ALL benefits. No benefits traps then.

    p.s. not advocating this as anything other than a starting point to think about reforming our out of control welfare system

  • rate this

    Comment number 865.

    I truly don't understand why people feel that the government should subsidize their life style choices. You should only choose to have children if you're economically stable enough to support them, if not it's your own fault. Birth control isn't expensive.

    Many families raise children on HOUSE-HOLD incomes half of the amount proposed here. People need to stop feeling entitled.

  • rate this

    Comment number 864.

    untill people in power stop treating people who have never paid into the NHS and social security but never seem to be on the radar for one should be able to claim if they have not paid in.Britian is full of scroungers taking and not giving anything in return.the country cannot keep the caring society going as things stand .give to people who help create wealth !!!!!!

  • rate this

    Comment number 863.

    I can see from the ratings on the "Editors Picks" that this facist Tory government has brought out all the selfish, egotistical haters that love to look down upon anyone who needs assistance. These self appreciating pious frauds that come out of the woodwork to give their rightious stance on whom they think should have or have not. Dictating how many children a fellow human can have? Shameless

  • rate this

    Comment number 862.

    "..we pay our way"

    The continuous whining for welfare payments for making personal chioces like having children, puts that into doubt. People who really 'pay their way' aren't continualy asking other people to subsidise them

  • rate this

    Comment number 861.

    Ahhhh, the millionaires keeping the serfs in line.
    I've given up our CB. I earn just over the £50k, by the time you allow for overtime and bonuses. I pay an extortionate amount of tax, my neighbours on the other hand, buy and sell cars, cannot work as they have 'bad backs', cycle some 60 - 70 miles a day, and no one cares.

    At least I know my £20 is fair though Dave


Page 32 of 75


More Politics stories


Politics Live

    08:31: Churchill's place in history BBC Radio 4

    Historians Simon Heffer and Andrew Roberts have been discussing Sir Winston Churchill's place in history on Today and considering how he would have adapted to contemporary politics. They agree it is "completely impossible" to compare him with today's leaders as they face lesser challenges and "you need the crisis to create the statesman". Simon Heffer says Churchill would have struggled with modern media scrutiny given his fondness for whisky first thing in the morning and his "dictatorial" style. But Andrew Roberts says Churchill never over-ruled his generals and the "granite" he showed in 1940 and 1941 undisputedly make him the greatest occupant of No 10.

    08:15: NHS row BBC Radio 5 live

    Labour's shadow health minister Liz Kendall tells BBC 5 live Breakfast that former Labour health minister Lord Darzi is "wrong" for thinking that using the private sector is the way to make "the big changes we need" to public services like the NHS. "I just don't think that that's the case," she says. It comes after Lord Darzi told the BBC the NHS should prefer providers who deliver the highest quality care - whether they are "public, private or not-for-profit".

    08:02: 'Million-strong crowd' BBC Breakfast

    The BBC's Duncan Kennedy, outside St. Paul's Cathedral in central London, tells BBC Breakfast a million-strong crowd gathered between the cathedral and Westminster Abbey for Sir Winston Churchill's funeral 50 years ago. "In many places it was 20-people deep as many regarded him as the greatest Englishman who ever lived... he's one of those rare leaders that is remembered in life and in death, however history ultimately judges him," he says.

    07:51: Churchill's funeral BBC Radio 4

    Broadcaster Jonathan Dimbleby tells Today he will be watching the replay of Sir Winston Churchill's funeral on BBC Parliament this morning. It will be poignant for him, he says, since his father Richard - whose commentary on the event has lived so long in the memory - also died 50 years ago.

    @BBCBenThompson 07:41: Housing shortage

    BBC business correspondent Ben Thompson tweets: 150,000 new homes built across UK last year but is it enough if demand still outstripping supply? @CountrysideProp boss - 0750 @BBCBreakfast

    07:37: Behind the scenes at Westminster

    Parliament is not sitting today due to events marking the 50th anniversary of Sir Winston Churchill's funeral. But those wanting a different insight into how the famous institution works might like to read about a new BBC documentary - Inside the Commons - to be broadcast next week. Michael Cockerell and his team have been behind the scenes at Westminster and not all MPs have been happy about it.

    Documentary-maker Michael Cockerell
    @BBCr4today 07:28: Medical training BBC Radio 4

    tweets: Plan to reduce length of medical training will lead to "lower standard of expertise" @thomasdolphin, @TheBMA #r4today

    07:20: 'Dirtiest campaign' The Independent

    Ukip leader Nigel Farage says this general election could be the "dirtiest" campaign in British history. Writing in the Independent, he accused the Conservatives and Labour of employing "attack-campaign" election strategists and "hurling hundreds of thousands of pounds at Facebook and twitter".

    07:07: Funeral film BBC Radio 4

    The TV pictures of Sir Winston Churchill's funeral remain "compelling viewing" 50 years on, James Rowland from BBC Archive says. There was a "little bit of damage" on the original film and dirt that had to be cleaned off, he tells Radio 4's Today, prior to its rebroadcast on BBC Parliament today. He reflects on the fairly rudimentary camerawork used in 1965, compared to today's standards, remarking that the pictures seem "slightly twitchy".

    07:06: Churchill event timings

    Here are some of the 50th anniversary timings if you want to plan your day:

    • The Houses of Parliament will host a remembrance service and wreath-laying ceremony at 09:00 GMT
    • BBC Parliament is re-broadcasting the state funeral, which runs for a little over four hours, at 09:15 GMT.
    • Tower Bridge will be raised at 12:45 GMT as the Havengore repeats its 1965 journey from the Tower of London to Westminster
    • Westminster Abbey will host a ceremony from 18:00 GMT, with flowers laid at the green marble stone placed there in memorial to Churchill.
    06:58: Churchill anniversary
    The Havengore carrying Sir Winston Churchill's coffiin along the Thames

    A bit more about what's happening in London later to mark the 50th anniversary of the state funeral of Sir Winston Churchill. The Houses of Parliament and Westminster Abbey will both host remembrance services, and there'll be a ceremony recreating the flotilla which carried Churchill's coffin along the Thames from the Tower of London to Westminster Pier. Members of Churchill's family will travel along the Thames on the Havengore, which carried his coffin 50 years ago.

    06:51: 'Three parent baby law'
    Daily Telegraph

    And the Daily Telegraph's lead is on concern from the Church of England that legislation is being rushed through to allow children to be born with three genetic "parents". The technique - mitrochondrial DNA transfer - is being promoted as a way to combat a series of inherited medical conditions.

    06:45: 'Religious slaughter of animals'
    The Times

    Meanwhile, the Times leads on a big rise in the number of food animals slaughtered without stunning. The British Veterinary Association - which wants the practice banned from Britain - says the number of animals killed in this way has risen by 60%. The paper says this is because of campaigning by Muslims for traditional slaughter methods.

    06:41: 'Migrant voting power'
    The i

    Migration is the focus of the i newspaper. It says immigrants could decide the result in 70 marginal seats, and Conservatives fear "migrant voting power" could cost them the election.

    06:36: 'Gas bill rip-off'
    Daily Express

    It's a "gas bill rip-off" for the Daily Express, which says figures show the big six energy suppliers are enjoying bumper profits, as temperatures plummet. The paper says the big firms will pocket an extra £114 per household in the coming year.

    06:34: The newspapers
    The Guardian

    A quick look at what's making the headlines in the newspapers. Energy prices take a prominent place in a few, with the Guardian saying real take-home pay is less now than it was in 2001, according to research by the Institute for Fiscal Studies. Men and young workers have noticed the greatest fall in spending power, the paper adds.

    06:28: Missed Newsnight and This Week?

    Don't worry if you weren't glued to your telly seven hours ago - you can catch up with the full editions of Question Time and This Week by clicking on the 'Live Coverage' tab on this page.

    06:24: Cameron tribute to Churchill
    Winston Churchill statue outside parliament

    Last night Downing Street released the text of the message on the wreath David Cameron will lay at the statue of Winston Churchill, which stands just outside the Commons chamber. The PM has written: "Britain was so incredibly fortunate that in our hour of greatest need there came forward one of our greatest ever statesmen. 50 years on the light has not dimmed. David Cameron."

    06:22: Churchill anniversary
    Richard Dimbleby Richard Dimbleby commentating on Sir Winston Churchill's state funeral for the BBC

    Fifty years to the day, BBC Parliament is re-broadcasting the state funeral of the UK's wartime leader Sir Winston Churchill. Introduced by Sir Winston's grandson, Sir Nicholas Soames, the historic broadcast runs for a little over four hours. Fourteen reels of film, complete with impeccable commentary by Richard Dimbleby, have been restored, joined and re-mastered. The showing starts at 09:15 GMT.

    06:20: Good morning Alex Hunt Politics editor, BBC News Online

    Hello and welcome to a fresh day's coverage of political developments ahead of the 7 May General Election - yes there's just 97 days to go now. You'll be able to listen or watch all the BBC's political output today on this page and we'll be bringing you all the best clips, quotes, analysis, reaction and breaking political news throughout the day. If you want to see what to expect, here's yesterday's campaign countdown.



Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.