Will MPs question the Synod's decision?


The failure of the Church of England Synod to approve women bishops (one of the three houses didn't quite attain the required two-thirds majority) came up at PMQs today, when both Sir Tony Baldry, who speaks in the Commons for the Church Commissioners, and Labour's Ben Bradshaw, expressed their disappointment.

David Cameron declared himself a supporter of women bishops, and agreed - but added that the decision of the Synod had to be respected.

A few moments later Labour's Diana Johnson raised a point of order, requesting a statement from Sir Tony, but was told that only ministers could make a statement.

It's pretty clear that quite a few MPs disagree with the result of the Synod's vote; but can Parliament do anything about it? Perhaps.

Keep an eye on a rather low profile organ of Parliament, the Ecclesiastical Committee, which exists to give the parliamentary stamp of approval to legislation on the established Church. It must be said it's not the most hyperactive committee in Westminster, reporting perhaps once a year on some church-related matter, and at least one of its members was unaware that he was a member.

But all the same, it could be the vehicle for expressing parliamentary disapproval, perhaps by blocking some forthcoming piece of church legislation. In the 1990s controversy over women priests, the Ecclesiastical Committee was firmly in the "no" camp, but insiders tell me the balance of opinion has changed since then.

There are some quite assertive MPs on the committee - Sir Tony, Ben Bradshaw, Helen Goodman and Simon Hughes, among others. If they want to kick off, they have the experience and self-confidence to do it.

UPDATE: Ben Bradshaw has just said on The World At One that Parliament has a right to weigh in because the Church of England was the established church of the state. He's asking for advice from the clerks of the Commons on how Parliament could intervene. Could a recent Ten Minute Rule Bill, that Mr Bradshaw cited, to permit women bishops be revived? Could the Church's exemption from equalities legislation be repealed?

UPDATE 2: Labour's Diana Johnson has put down a Commons urgent question on the women bishops vote. If it's granted, it will be for Sir Tony Baldry, the MP who speaks in the Commons for the Church Commissioners, to answer. Apparently it is in order to direct an urgent question at him - but it's not a done deal that Mr Speaker will allow it. A further UQ to the Equalities Minister, Maria Miller, or to one of her deputies, may follow.

Mark D'Arcy Article written by Mark D'Arcy Mark D'Arcy Parliamentary correspondent

Week ahead

There may well be appearances by exotic species like the Eurasian Beaver, or even defenders of Tony Blair, in the Houses of Parliament this week.

Read full article

More on This Story

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 27.

    As long as the C of E remains 'established' we are all as citizens tainted with their stupidity and disciminatory practices.
    They should be given six months to sort themselves out.
    If they don't - immediate disestablishment.

  • rate this

    Comment number 26.

    If the CoE what to get out of this hole they've dug for themselves, they'll have to amend their constitution. Not by much either, surely it's not too much of a stretch to allow majority voting of the 'houses'. Two out of three had the necessary two-thirds majority, in any reasonable sense that should be enough.

  • rate this

    Comment number 25.

    Should not the Roman Catholic Church,Muslims and other religious bodies also be required to implement equality provisions in their establishments?

  • rate this

    Comment number 24.

    The answer must be disestablishment; removal of the church's exemption from the Equalities legislation and the removal of the Bishops from the House of Lords.
    If the CofE wants to discriminate against women then it should have to realise that these actions have consequences.
    Does the new Archbishop of Canterbury have to get formal agreement from Parliament? If so then block it.

  • rate this

    Comment number 23.

    It doesn't matter what MPs think, unless they are members of the Church of England it is none of their business how that denomination chooses to conduct its affairs.

    Likewise as I am a practising member of a different Christian denomination, it isn't my business either!


Comments 5 of 27



Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.