John Bercow: Some critical MPs are 'embittered and resentful'

Related Stories

Commons Speaker John Bercow has accused his critics of being "embittered and resentful" and refusing to accept he was elected in the first place.

Mr Bercow, who has held the office since 2009, suggested MPs "briefing" against him were driven by frustrations about their own political careers.

"If people are fair-minded they should not three years on be sulking about who won," he told the BBC's World at One.

He also defended reforms which had brought the Commons "off its knees".

Changes he had introduced - such as granting more urgent questions in the Commons - had given greater power to backbenchers and made ministers more accountable to Parliament, he insisted.

The former Conservative MP was elected to succeed Michael Martin in 2009 after he quit over Parliament's handling of the expenses scandal.

However, many Conservative MPs favoured other candidates at the time and Mr Bercow only secured the post with the backing of Labour members.

'Lingering grievance'

Analysis

When John Bercow says some regard him as puffed up with his own importance, he isn't wrong.

Former Conservative colleagues regard his journey from the right to the left wing of his party before he became Speaker with deep suspicion.

A few criticise him in public. Many more privately complain that he favours Labour.

His backers argue that whether MPs find him charming or not, he does a good job of stopping ministers waffling and giving more members a say.

Talk of plots to oust him have come to nothing.

His predecessor - Michael Martin - was the first holder of the post to be effectively forced from the chair for 300 years.

When Speaker Bercow casts an eye across the Commons chamber he knows there are some on the green benches who would like to see him meet a similar fate.

Since then, there have been grumblings on the Tory benches about his handling of Commons business and the number of times that ministers have been called to answer opposition questions - particularly on controversial issues such as phone hacking.

In an interview with Radio 4's World at One, Mr Bercow defended these changes and suggested some MPs could not disguise their disapproval of him as Speaker.

"People who never wanted me to win in the first place and, in many cases, strove very hard to stop me winning have tended to feel a lingering sense of grievance," he said.

Some of his critics, he suggested, were "perhaps people who have not been able to achieve what they want to achieve in their political career" and feel "their talents have not been recognised".

They, he added, perhaps did not like the fact that a "rather freewheeling, independent, perhaps in their minds disloyal, backbencher" had become Speaker.

He added: "Just as I don't bear a grudge against anyone who did not vote for me, I would argue that if people are fair-minded they should not three years on be sulking about who won.

"They have either vocalised their opinion in public or have constantly briefed against me behind the scenes. I have of course an idea about who some of these people are.

"And I think it is a sadness, a sadness for them that they are so embittered and resentful."

More on This Story

Related Stories

More UK Politics stories

RSS

Features & Analysis

Elsewhere on BBC News

  • Donald TrumpWinning business

    Why trying to become a successful entrepreneur has never been more fashionable

Programmes

  • A Chinese woman drinking red wineTalking Movies Watch

    Tom Brook looks at Red Obsession, a film which charts China's thirst for red wine

BBC © 2013 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.