Get a grip on Olympics, MPs urge government

David Cameron: ''Contracts that are not fulfilled will have... pretty tough financial consequences''

Related Stories

MPs have urged ministers to "get a grip" on G4S to ensure a smooth Games.

The Commons Public Accounts Committee says the security firm, whose staff shortages have seen an extra 3,500 soldiers drafted in, should be fined.

Chairman Margaret Hodge said shortages were "predictable". The government says it is on track for a great Games.

Labour leader Ed Miliband, meanwhile, is urging a government re-think on outsourcing more police services to private firms in light of the "fiasco".

In a speech, he argued that police budget cuts of 20% in England and Wales by 2015 meant forces were "under pressure to outsource on a scale and at a speed never before seen".

And he said G4S' "ability to deliver" should be reviewed before it is awarded any new policing contracts.

The government says spending reductions will not mean worse services.

In other developments as the UK prepares for the start of the Olympics on Friday 27 July:

  • The Ministry of Defence denies "ridiculous" suggestions that servicemen and women are being forced to sleep on office chairs following Olympics security shifts after photos emerge on social media sites
  • Olympic medallist Steve Backley and artist Tracey Emin are among those carrying the Olympic torch as it travels from Deal to Maidstone, in Kent.
  • Great Britain's women's basketball team are beaten 88-63 by USA despite a spirited performance in a Games preparation match in Manchester
  • PM David Cameron says a planned strike by thousands of Home Office workers - including airport immigration workers - which could disrupt the Games would not be "right or justified".
  • Drivers on East Midlands Trains will strike from 6-8 August, union Aslef says, threatening disruption to spectators travelling to the Games

Last week, it emerged the armed forces were on standby to provide an extra 3,500 troops to help with security at the London Games, amid fears that private contractor G4S would not be able to provide enough trained staff in time.

On Tuesday, the firm's chief executive, Nick Buckles, agreed when questioned by the Commons Home Affairs Select Committee that the debacle was a "humiliating shambles for the company".

The company may lose £50m from the £284m contract because it cannot supply enough security guards.

Meanwhile, Metropolitan Police Commissioner Bernard Hogan-Howe has told radio station LBC that people should be "reassured that the policing is in place, the military have come in to fill that gap that G4S have left".


Unveiling her own committee's report, Ms Hodge criticised G4S and the London Organising Committee of the Olympic and Paralympic Games (Locog).

Margaret Hodge MP says she wants 'true transparency' from G4S

She said: "The chaos which has emerged over the security contract was predictable and undermines confidence in those responsible for managing the Games.

"There is now a last-minute scramble to make sure there will be enough security personnel on the ground."

"In evidence to us before Christmas, all those concerned gave assurances that the contract could be met despite more than doubling the number of guards before the ink was dry on the original contract."

She added: "Now troops are having to be drafted in. The Home Office needs to get a grip on Locog and G4S urgently.

"We still don't know just how many security guards will actually be delivered or whether G4S will face any penalty. We will carry out a post-mortem in September," she said.

She later told BBC News: "The more you get private providers providing public services, the more important transparency becomes because it's your and my money - it's the taxpayers' money - that's being used."

She said there had been a 12-fold hike in management costs, from £10m to £125m, and that G4S had still failed to deliver.

"That seemed to us completely unjustifiable - we want to look at it in detail to make sure that the taxpayer is not being ripped off," she added.

'Safe and secure'

The report states that G4S should not only pay for all additional costs but face financial penalties for the "failure to deliver".

Start Quote

If a company doesn't fulfil its contract, then that company should be got after for that money”

End Quote PM David Cameron

It adds that there has been no overall figure about how much the Games are costing the taxpayer.

There is a public-sector funding package of £9.3bn, but other Games-related expenditure, such as funding of elite athletes, will also come from the public purse.

Prime Minister David Cameron, meanwhile, said G4S could be forced to give back some of the money it has been paid.

"If a company doesn't fulfil its contract, then that company should be got after for that money," he told BBC News during a visit to Afghanistan.

"That's exactly what's going to happen in the case of G4S."

Culture Secretary Jeremy Hunt said the government was "on track to deliver a great Games on time and under-budget".

He said he disagreed that his department had lacked transparency.

Jeremy Hunt: "Now is not the time for a blame game."

"London 2012 has arguably been more transparent than any other public sector project."

Mr Hunt said the government had worked closely with Locog and G4S on security arrangements and had "moved quickly to activate our contingency plans".

He later told BBC One's Breakfast that overall, with eight days to go until the start of the Games, there had been "a very encouraging start".

"This week, the athletes arrived in the village, people were worried about immigration and queues at Heathrow, that went smoothly, people were worried about the transport network in London and that went pretty well," he added.

Meanwhile, it has been revealed that the organisers of London 2012 encouraged G4S to keep wages for security staff as low as possible.

Security guards have been offered £8.50 an hour to work at the Olympic venues - below the market rate of about £10 an hour.

G4S was "incentivised" in the contract - renegotiated and enhanced in December - to keep a lid on labour costs, meaning higher profits if it paid less.

A spokesman for Locog said: "The combined pay and retention rate starts at over £9 per hour.

"The more senior [the] role, the higher the rate."

G4S was unavailable to comment.

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More Politics stories


Politics Live

    09:00: Paper review The Guardian

    Mohammed Emwazi had earlier been able to flee Britain despite being a member of a London-based terror cell that had links to the failed 21/7 attacks on the capital in 2005, according to the Observer. Associates of a 12-strong group spent time at a terror camp in Cumbria a year before the bid, the paper says. And it also reports that Labour is on course for an "absolute majority" in the House of Commons, according to a new poll commissioned by the paper.

    The Observer
    08:57: 'Bizarre' response to minimum funding guarantee
    Stephen Crabb Stephen Crabb said Welsh ministers were being offered 'exactly' what they had asked for

    Welsh Secretary Stephen Crabb has described Welsh ministers' response to a promise on minimum funding as "bizarre". On Friday, the UK government proposed a funding "floor" - guaranteeing a minimum Welsh government income. The Conservatives now want Labour Welsh ministers to call a referendum on devolving part-control of income tax. First Minister Carwyn Jones - a Labour politician - denounced the funding offer as a "vague promise", but Mr Crabb said it was a response to specific Welsh government demands.

    08:49: Paper review Sunday Times

    Inside the Sunday Times, a group of the paper's reporters looks at the "bewildering transformation" of Mohammed Emwazi from a "socially-inept computer programmer" to infamous murderer. The paper leads on an alleged row in the coalition between the Conservatives and the Lib Dems: "New rules drawn up by Downing Street to force universities to ban all 'extremist' speakers from their campuses are being blocked by Vince Cable, the business secretary." And it also carries a story about a plan by some senior Tories to "Save Dave" in the event the prime minister wins more votes but fewer seats than Ed Miliband's Labour in May.

    Sunday Times front page
    08:45: Paper review

    The Mail on Sunday leads with further details of the background of British-born Mohammed Emwazi, a.k.a. 'jihadi John'. The paper's security editor describes how as far back as 2010 Emwazi was convinced the security services were tailing him. Looking elsewhere, the paper's Ian Birrell writes about the recently-assassinated Boris Nemtsov, an opponent of Vladimir Putin's in Russia.

    Mail on Sunday front page
    08:21: BBC One, 11:00 GMT Sunday Politics

    Today's political coverage on the BBC starts, of course, with Andrew Marr - but by no means finishes there. Join Andrew Neil on the Sunday Politics sofa at 11:00 GMT on BBC One, where he'll be joined by: Labour's Liam Byrne, the shadow universities minister; UKIP leader Nigel Farage; the Conservative former Defence Secretary Liam Fox; and the journalists Isabel Oakeshott, Nicholas Watt, and Janan Ganesh.

    Sunday Politics guests
    08:20: BBC One, 09:00 GMT The Andrew Marr Show
    Yvette Cooper

    It's been a frantic week in the political world, with election fever spreading to more and more people. UKIP kicked off its spring conference; Labour announced it would reduce tuition fees by a third; and new immigration statistics proved embarrassing for the Conservative Party. But it wasn't a week spent entirely slinging mud - the coalition outlined a new devolved settlement for Wales, in a news conference that saw a show of unity and good humour between David Cameron and Nick Clegg. Join Andrew Marr at 09:00 GMT on BBC One to review the past week and look ahead to the next. His guests today include Shadow Home Secretary Yvette Cooper; Cardinal Vincent Nichols, Archbishop of Westminster; and the actress Kristen Scott-Thomas.

    08:04: Good morning Alex Hunt Politics editor, BBC News Online

    Hello and welcome to a fresh Sunday's political coverage - there are only nine more before the election takes place. Sam Francis and Adam Donald will bring you all the main news and comment from the papers, and all the key moments from the morning's programmes such as The Andrew Marr Show, Pienaar's Politics and Sunday Politics. Don't forget you can get in touch by emailing or via social media @bbcpolitics



Try our new site and tell us what you think. Learn more
Take me there

Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.