Liam Fox urges government to issue 'quit EU' ultimatum


Dr Fox: ''Britain's destiny is not a debating issue for leaders on the Continent''

Related Stories

Former Defence Secretary Liam Fox has recommended that the UK should leave the European Union unless there is a rebalancing of their relationship.

He said coalition policies were "being curtailed by diktat from Brussels" and urged a referendum on the issue.

The comments will add to pressure on David Cameron who is due to address MPs later on last week's EU summit.

The prime minister has said he is prepared to consider a referendum, but urged campaigners to show "patience".

Mr Cameron's House of Commons statement at 1530 BST follows last week's EU summit in Brussels at which eurozone leaders agreed a bailout deal for their debt-laden banks.

As a non-eurozone leader he was not present during these discussions, but afterwards he insisted he had secured "explicit commitments" to protect the European single market.

'No terror'

Many Eurosceptics fear the UK could lose out in a "two-tier Europe", as eurozone economies integrate further as they work to deal with the debt crisis.

In his speech organised by the Taxpayers' Alliance in London, Mr Fox suggested this could alter the whole set-up of the EU, insisting that "life outside the EU holds no terror".

Start Quote

David Cameron and Liam Fox appear to be contemplating the same sort of referendum - a post renegotiation poll”

End Quote

However, he said holding a referendum now "would be a huge error with enormous tactical risks", and that the UK should first seek to "negotiate a new relationship with the EU based on economic rather than political considerations, and set out in clear and unambiguous language".

If this failed, there would be "no alternative but to recommend rejection and consider departure from the EU".

He added: "We should not wait for EU leaders to recognise the failure of the ill-conceived euro before we set out what we want for the British people. Britain's destiny is not a debating issue for leaders on the Continent."

Mr Fox, who resigned last year after it was found he had breached the ministerial code in his working relationship with friend Adam Werritty, is seen as a leading figure among Conservative Eurosceptics.


He said that, when the referendum on staying in the then European Economic Community had taken place in 1975, voters had been "sold a pup", with intended movement towards ever-greater political union not publicised.

It would be in the UK's national interest to retain the "customs union", but "not other elements I regard as an intrusion into our national life".

Nigel Farage: ''If we are just going to have some sort of fudged referendum... then frankly that isn't good enough''

Mr Fox also said the EU was "not foreign enough", as it did too little to foster trade with growing markets such as China and had become "increasingly uncompetitive" globally by extending rights and benefits.

He described the latest Brussels summit as "Groundhog Day", adding: "What really happened was that fiscally incontinent banks, and nations, sought to avoid their responsibilities and kick the problems, yet again, into the long grass."

Mr Fox was asked about a possible return to government, replying that he would have remained in office for "about 25 minutes" had he made his comments while in office.

He said: "There are some freedoms on the back benches... there are not a huge number of benefits, but there are some and this is one of them."

His comments come amid growing backbench demands for a public vote on the UK's relationship with Brussels.

Last week Conservative MP John Baron said almost 100 colleagues had signed a letter calling on the prime minister to prepare legislation committing the UK to an EU referendum after the next election.


The prime minister responded that he "completely" understood concerns, but after the EU summit ended on Friday he rejected the idea of an in/out referendum and stressed the need to "shape a relationship with Europe that benefits the United Kingdom".

Mr Cameron clarified his views in the Sunday Telegraph, writing that he was "not against referendums on Europe" but that he did not agree with those who wanted "the earliest possible in/out referendum".

He acknowledged the need to ensure the UK's position within the European Union had "the full-hearted support of the British people" but they needed to show "tactical and strategic patience".

Europe is seen as a divisive issue within the coalition government, with the Conservatives broadly less in favour of the EU than their Liberal Democrat partners.

Deputy Prime Minister Nick Clegg, and Lib Dem leader, said that "the ink is barely dry" on legislation that would trigger a referendum if more powers were transferred to Brussels.

He added: "David and I spoke about it. He is entirely entitled to talk as leader of his own party. This is a coalition. You have two people at the top with two different instincts on this."

He added: "It is clearly not a priority now to have an abstract debate about a referendum on a question which is not yet specified on a date which is not yet specified on a set of circumstances which is not yet specified."

UK Independence Party leader Nigel Farage said leaving the EU should be among the choices presented to voters, arguing: "If we are just going to have a fudged referendum on 'do we stay in or go further?' then that's not good enough."

Shadow chief secretary to the Treasury Rachel Reeves refused to rule out the possibility of a future Labour government holding a referendum once the new shape of Europe became clearer, but called the prime minister's stance on Europe "a shambles".

Lib Dem Member of the European Parliament Sir Graham Watson described Dr Fox's speech as "a desperate move by a discredited Tory to bang the populist drum to try to revitalise an ailing political career".


More on This Story

Related Stories


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 622.

    The problem with leaving the EU is we will be cut adrift and you will find the Japanese would pull their car plant out of the UK, if people remember back when they were looking for a place in Europe, they fist wanted a place in the center of Europe like Poland, the only reason they were persuaded to come to the UK was that we were in the EU.
    Not long to move a factory these days.

  • rate this

    Comment number 519.

    As a manufacturing exporter, and one who has been a confirmed Europhile for most of his adult life, it is clear to me that we would be hugely better off by getting out of the EU but staying as members of the EFTA.
    Trade balance is EU to UK, so they need us.
    We would be much more attractive to foreign investors in manufacturing if we weren't subject to so much of Brussels' over-regulation.

  • rate this

    Comment number 424.

    Switzerland is often cited as a model for the UK. Apart from the fact that Switzerland is a small country with specialised, high value economy and a very large immigrant workforce, Switzerland implements the vast majority of EU rules (it has to to be able to trade) and has no say in setting them. It is also a member of Schengen. The UK is not. It also apys the EU for the privilege.

  • rate this

    Comment number 364.

    I do believe that its now time for a grown up debate about the UK in Europe. I think we are now moving into the beginning of the end for the euro as we know it. quite where this leaves us remains to be seen. I do think the debate and our options are a little more complex than 'in or out'.

  • rate this

    Comment number 263.

    For all who say we did not vote for this in 1975 only trade
    sorry yes you did taken from 1975 referendum pamphlet
    The aims of the Common Market are
    To bring together the peoples of Europe
    To raise living standards and improve working conditions
    To promote growth and boost world trade.
    To help the poorest regions of Europe and the rest of the world.
    To help maintain peace and freedom.


Comments 5 of 11


More Politics stories



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.