Eurozone deal: Greek default could still happen
A Greek default has been averted but Andrew Neil is not sure about its future
So, after 13 hours of talks into the wee small hours of this morning (unlucky for them!), eurozone finance ministers finally reached an agreement in principle on a second Greek bailout, this one worth 130bn euro plus a 50%+ write-down of private lenders holdings of Greek sovereign debt.
Since it's less than two years since Bailout 1 of 110bn euro and things in Greece have gone from bad to worse, you might wonder why this second one will do any better. And you'd not be the only one doing the wondering.
A "strictly confidential" report prepared for eurozone ministers' eyes only but helpfully leaked in this morning' s Financial Times shows that Brussels fears Bailout 3 could be necessary. It warns that Greece is now in a recession so deep that reducing its debt might prove impossible.
“Start Quote
End Quote Andrew Neil Daily Politics and Sunday Politics presenterI expect the eurozone will finally refuse to write that third cheque”
At the moment, its cumulative sovereign debt is almost 170% of GDP. Under Bailout 2 it's meant to fall to 120% by 2020 (though nobody seriously expects that to happen). But the leaked brief says it could still be 160% in eight years' time.
The brief also says that forcing private lenders to take a bigger than expected haircut on their loans to Greece (in reality they could end up losing 75% of their loans) is likely to destroy confidence among private investors, making it impossible for Athens to borrow from the financial markets for the foreseeable future.
So it could be on the eurozone drip feed indefinitely.
Two other points that could undermine Bailout 2: it assumes a return to strong growth from 2014 onwards, which might not happen; and the massive privatisation programme that was meant to generate 50bn euro in revenues has been downgraded to 30bn euro - and won't start for five years.
No alternativeGiven eurozone ministers knew all this before they met last night you might wonder why they agreed to Bailout 2.
I suspect it was because, despite all the tough words in the run up to the summit, they didn't want to risk a messy default and thought there was no alternative.
At most Bailout 2 buys some time (like Bail Out 1).
But nobody knows what the eurozone will do with that time (the time Bailout 1 bought has been largely wasted). On present likely projections, even the Brussels bureaucrats think there's every chance there will need to be a Bailout 3.
But if it comes to that I expect the eurozone will finally refuse to write that third cheque. A Greek default has been averted for now. But it could still happen.
~RS~q~RS~~RS~z~RS~29~RS~)



Charting Europe's economic woes
World Bank predicts 'difficult' 2013
Hollande signs gay marriage bill
Sick art
Tweets of the week
Clocking out
Most wanted
Story of the S-Class
Fast Track
Comment number 1.
arch5esdaddy21st February 2012 - 14:04
Q: Who will pay for all this? A: Not the 'Greek in the Street'. Greece will default after it has its new money and will leave the Euro. Greek 'democracy' is now effectively in stasis - elected Greek politicians won't govern the national economy for years. Germany will rule a humiliated Greece with Brussels its cat-paw and the only way out will be to quit the Euro. Who profits? Germany and France
Link to this (Comment number 1)
Comment number 2.
Ohdrat21st February 2012 - 14:12
The Euro and EU are simply proving how undemocratic they actually are and how ineffective the EU institutions were and are. The result is a large swathe of Southern Europe in a currency that is harming their domestic economies and societies. It is time the EU and Greece got intot the NOW rather than fire fighting and planned for a Greek exit.
Link to this (Comment number 2)
Comment number 3.
fluteplayer21st February 2012 - 14:29
This deal isn't sustainable long term, it isn't a deal to help Greece but help Germany and France. It condemns Greek people to severe austerity, Greece will go into depression and how long before civil war breaks out?
Link to this (Comment number 3)
Comment number 4.
alex_penyfai21st February 2012 - 14:48
I'd like to know how the wholesale privatisation of State Assets will help the Greek people - or their government, come to that?
Link to this (Comment number 4)
Comment number 5.
AshleyB921st February 2012 - 14:55
Another Bail Out is virtually inevitable, if they last long enough not to hold up their hands in defeat and default! Greece have been spending far too much, for far too long, and as such to be able to reverese that quickly is a non-starter. As for writing off 50% of their debt, well I wish my mortgage company would do that! Rewards for Recklessness = Ridiculous.
Link to this (Comment number 5)
Comments 5 of 55