Rioters need tough love, says David Cameron

David Cameron (15 August 2011) David Cameron says the riots present an opportunity to strengthen our society

Prime Minister David Cameron has said those involved in the riots need "tough love" as he promised to "get to grips" with the country's problem families.

He has vowed to turn around the lives of 120,000 families by 2015.

The PM told the BBC the money to do that would be found, despite spending cuts, and that it would "save the country a fortune" in the long term.

He denied his response to the riots indicated a lurch to the right, calling himself a "common-sense Conservative".

In a wide-ranging interview with BBC Radio 4's Today programme, Mr Cameron said "tough love" - and indeed "both elements of it" - were crucial to dealing with rioters.

"For some of the children who've ended up in this terrible situation there was probably a failure in their background, in their families," he said.

"There probably was a shortage of not just respect and boundaries but also love. But you do need, when they cross the line and break the law, to be very tough.

'Systematic intervention'

"So to me tough love sums it up, that's what we need.


Is David Cameron an old-style, right-wing Tory, praising courts for locking up rioters, or a compassionate Conservative prepared to hug a hoodie? He told the Today programme he's "a common sense Conservative" and summed up his approach as "tough love".

It's a phrase he used shortly after he became Tory leader in 2006. Then he said he did not mean "sentimental, childish love which sees no wrong in anyone" but "love that values people, and therefore demands high standards from them".

The right of his party would prefer him to stick to the "tough" part of the message, but what sorts of things might the PM himself have in mind?

Well, we got some ideas from Education Secretary Michael Gove yesterday, including greater powers for teachers to deal with unruly behaviour and truancy.

Iain Duncan Smith is another key figure in the strategy. His changes to the welfare system are designed to end the cycle of unemployment, deprivation, family breakdown and crime.

David Cameron hopes the riots will vindicate his claim that parts of our society are broken. But it will be a long time before anyone can judge whether tough love works.

"That's what [Work and Pensions Secretary] Iain Duncan Smith and [Home Secretary] Theresa May and others in the government believe and will deliver.

"I think it's an opportunity, we have to use try and use this an opportunity, to do things to strengthen our society, which along with rebuilding a strong economy is going to be this government's priority."

He said the UK must "do better at bringing up our children" and insisted that "much more systematic" intervention in the 120,000 most troubled families was key.

"There's lots of contact with these families, but no-one's actually working on the family, to get into that family and work out what's actually wrong and put it right."

Asked whether he was proposing to do this without spending any more, the PM said: "I'm not saying no extra money... but this will be a great investment to save money for our country.

'Wake-up moment'

"How exactly we find the money, we'll come onto that, but don't worry, this is going to be done - it's a promise I have made."

Mr Cameron reiterated his belief that the riots that erupted in several English cities last month were straightforward criminality - rather than any form of protest - but he said it was not just a criminal underclass who were responsible for them.

"Tragically, we also saw people who were just drawn into it, who passed the broken shop window and popped in and nicked a telly.

"That is a sign of moral collapse, of failing to recognise the difference between right and wrong."

He added: "I think we all need to have a wake-up moment in terms of exercising our responsibilities."

The prime minister was asked about his membership of Oxford University drinking society the Bullingdon Club, some of whose members have been involved in acts of vandalism.

"We all do stupid things when we are young and we should learn the lessons," he said.

But Labour MP John Mann said Mr Cameron had "questions to answer" about his involvement in the Bullingdon Club.

"If we are to get more responsibility throughout our society following the riots then the prime minister should set an example," he said.

'Great mush'

Mr Cameron also criticised the BBC for in his view confusing the issues around the riots with wider problems of inequality and irresponsibility elsewhere in society, such as the banking industry.

He said that "when you listen to the BBC there is a sort of danger" that all the issues were put in a "great mush and make that as an excuse for not acting".

"Some people almost say 'Well, until we deal with the problem of inequality in our society there is nothing you can do to deal with rioting.'"

As presenter Evan Davis attempted to interrupt him, the PM said: "Well that's what it can slip into, Evan, if you are not careful."

A spokesman for the BBC said its coverage of the riots "endeavoured to explore all aspects, as our audiences would expect".

"We also sought to reflect a range of views as to the reasons behind the riots. We are confident we did this in an impartial and balanced manner."

On Twitter, Evan Davis said: "The point of the BC [Bullingdon Club] question was not to point the finger at Cameron for hypocrisy... it was about whether there is a general decline and whether we can forgive youngsters caught up in stupid things."


More on This Story

England riots


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 647.

    I'd like to see some clear targets for what the Government will achieve with the various proposals that Cameron and other Ministers have been setting out. Then when it comes to the next election we can see how many of them have had some msort of effect or how many were just hot air.

  • rate this

    Comment number 643.

    Lets be honest for a moment. How many people thought before the 'riots'
    "If I could commit a crime and get away with it I would?"
    I've heard this many a time from all sorts of people. The only difference this time was people thought they put their money where their mouth was not thinking they would be caught. It wasn't spontaneous criminality certain people have always thought this way.

  • rate this

    Comment number 241.

    I'm tired of hearing low income families being branded in the same 'disadvantaged' category. Lots of young people come from families on low income, however the ones who have been brought up well in a stable family environments were not the ones rioting.

    It is basic family values and the skill of bringing up children correctly- not wealth discrepancy- that needs to be addressed in this country.

  • rate this

    Comment number 40.

    Just a reminder that bankers did not do anything illegal - stupid, selfish, idiotic yes but NOT illegal.

    Cameron is spot on to say we need some effective deterrants and punishments introduced when current justice is frankly meaningless to alot of these young offenders.

    If need be lets have a general election on this - you can be sure the apologists for this behaviour will definitely lose!

  • rate this

    Comment number 21.

    The rioters weren't poor, disadvantaged, under-privileged, excluded or any other pathetic excuse peddled by bleeding-heart, hand-wringing liberals.
    They were anti-social, irresponsible, selfish, criminal scum from all levels of society, even the so-called elites.
    They need discipline, re-education and punishment, not yet more money wasted on them.


Comments 5 of 9


More Politics stories



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.