Labour vote against more IMF funding raises questions


Amidst all the sound and fury around the hacking scandal, another rather very interesting event passed almost unnoticed in the Commons yesterday.

Up on the Committee corridor MPs approved a Statutory Instrument authorising the near doubling of the UK's subscription to the International Monetary Fund from £10.7 billion to £20.15 billion.* The interesting point? Labour voted against.

Shadow Treasury Minister Chris Leslie argued the UK should balance its commitment to supporting the world economy with its domestic woes - and added that he was worried about the risk being taken with taxpayers' money.

Why does this matter? Because this is unlikely to be the last bailout vote in the Commons - indeed this very SI will have to be voted on in the Commons, probably next week. And if Labour start voting against such orders, the Government may have difficulty getting them through.

There's a growing network of eurosceptic Conservative MPs, including many from the 2010 intake, who're mobilising against a further British contribution to euro-zone bailouts, whether routed through EU mechanisms or through the IMF - they have already shown that they can mobilise enough backbenchers to give them at least the theoretical capability to overturn the Coalition's majority.

And, interestingly, Labour eurosceptics, once a rather atomised band of mavericks, are also networking in a way not seen before.

The worries articulated by Chris Leslie sound pretty similar to those you can hear from some Conservative MPs - about the problems of explaining to voters why big loans (and plenty of MPs think these potential liabilities will rapidly become the real thing) are made to foreigners when money is not available to support the British economy, (he cited the cancelled loan to Sheffield Forgemasters) and the exposure of British taxpayers if loans routed through the IMF are not repaid.

So it is not impossible to imagine the Government being defeated, for the first time, in a Commons vote on a Euro-issue. And even if the key decisions on - say - a second bailout package for Portugal happened to fall during the Summer break, I'm told Tory backbenchers will be organised and ready to communicate their displeasure to the leadership. Certainly the whips could have their work cut out containing the increasing backbench euro-dissent.

* Nerd Note: this is not an up-front financing commitment of £9.5 billion for the UK, but simply increases the potential amount of financing from the UK that the IMF can call on.

Mark D'Arcy Article written by Mark D'Arcy Mark D'Arcy Parliamentary correspondent

The next Parliament: Coalition 2.0 or confidence and supply?

It is beginning to dawn on MPs and peers quite how difficult it is likely to be to govern after the next election.

Read full article


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 16.

    Why is it that when, according to Osborne and cohorts, we're in the worst financial straits since WWII yet the government sees fit to make even more money available to the IMF to give away to more profligate economies?
    I'm tired of the political chicanery and sleight of hand this shower pass off. Can't we get rid of them at all?

  • rate this

    Comment number 15.

    quote: "passed almost unnoticed in the Commons yesterday." unquote

    It's not surprising it passed "almost unnoticed" I've been searching for information across the main stream media (inc the BBC) all evening & there has been nothing. An apparent complete blackout. The run up to approval - WITHOUT DEBATE - for £9bn & not worthy of a mention in the media until after the deed is done? V. odd indeed.

  • rate this

    Comment number 14.

    As usual we are conned by Politicians of all parties. Are there any honest MP's ?? Every day we get fed more lies and excuse. I for one am sick of the way governments (no capitas on purpose) ignore the feelings and opinions of the people who put them where they are. Once in power they consider themselves above the law and the people they are elected to SERVE

  • rate this

    Comment number 13.

    We're still one of the biggest economies in the world... if this money is used and lent to a country that does (can?) pay it's bills then the UK makes a tidy profit as we currently are with the loan to Ireland. If they go bust it's a different matter,...

  • rate this

    Comment number 12.

    Interersting assumption by Ian C that Labour actually have a strategy!

    I hear lots of complaints about Govt expenditure cuts but no complaints about the fact the amount of money saved by the cuts is considerably less that the amount lost to EU budget increases partly negotiated/agreed by Blair & Darling & when commitments to EU bailout funds & IMF are added in ...... strewth!


Comments 5 of 16



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.