Is Ed Miliband making a comeback?
17 June 2011 Last updated at 12:14 BST
Andrew Neil asked if Ed Miliband's political obituary was written too early after a week of better headlines for the Labour leader.
But Oona King, who went to school with him and voted for him as leader, warned that consistent good weeks at Prime Minister's Questions do not guarantee a general election win, as the panel also discussed the future of David Miliband.
Their debate followed Andrew Rawnsley's review of the week