Cameron stands firm on NHS changes to 'avoid crisis'


David Cameron: "The big killers of the past are becoming the lifelong conditions of the future"

David Cameron has said the NHS in England needs to change to avoid a "future crisis" as he sought to rally support for a controversial shake-up.

Speaking to health staff, the prime minister said the NHS was performing well but faced "enormous financial pressures" as people lived longer.

But he hinted at concessions on plans to give GPs more control over budgets and the private sector a greater role.

Labour said NHS professionals believed the plans were a "complete shambles".


Ministers have promised "substantial" changes to the proposals contained in the Health and Social Care Bill after calling a "pause" to their progress pending the results of a "listening exercise" involving patients, doctors and nurses.

Amid unease in Lib Dem ranks, Deputy Prime Minister Nick Clegg has warned his party will block the proposals unless they are altered.

In a speech at a London hospital, in which he drew on his family's experience of the NHS, Mr Cameron said he "loved the NHS" and it was the "most important" institution in the country for his family.

Start Quote

We save the NHS by changing it”

End Quote David Cameron

But while pledging "never to take risks" with the health service's core principles, he said there were growing problems due to too much waste, inflexibility and top-down control.

"It is because I love the NHS so much that I want to change it," he said. "It needs to change to make it work better today and it needs to change to avoid a crisis tomorrow."

Increased life expectancy, the rising cost of drugs and public health challenges - such as growing levels of obesity - could leave the NHS facing a multi-billion pound funding shortfall unless action was taken, he added, while wide disparities of quality of service and of health outcomes need to be addressed.

Health costs

"Sticking with the status quo and hoping we can get by with a bit more money is simply not a serious option," he said.

"There's only one option we've got and that is to change and modernise the NHS, to make it more efficient and more effective and above all, more focused on prevention, on health, not just sickness. We save the NHS by changing it."

Start Quote

The problem with this bill is that it is expensive, bureaucratic, and it is not properly thought through”

End Quote Ed Miliband Labour leader

Mr Cameron stressed that the plans, drawn up by Health Secretary Andrew Lansley, would not be abandoned and sought to quash opposition claims that they could lead to full privatisation of the NHS, saying there would be "no competition for competition's sake".

But he said the changes needed "to be delivered in the right way" and he wanted doctors and nurses "with, not against" the proposals.

"We are listening and we will make substantive concessions to the reforms based on what we hear," he said, adding that he would be "held accountable" for any amendments to the proposals.

Among these, he promised a role for consultants, nurses and other professionals - not merely GPs - in the commissioning of care and that there were would be no "cherry picking" of services and patients by the private sector.

But BBC Health Correspondent Branwen Jeffreys said there were no further details about limits on the role of the private sector - which unions are demanding.

'Not thought through'

Critics of the proposals say they were not included in the government's coalition agreement and attempting a major re-organisation when the NHS having to find billions in efficiency savings is foolhardy.


It's a sign of how far the government has been forced on to the back foot over the NHS that Mr Cameron is having to go out and make the case for change all over again.

The fear must be that the electorate are quite happy with the health service and don't see why there needs to be sweeping change.

There must also be a concern that despite Mr Cameron's best efforts, voters still don't quite trust the Tories with the health service.

Hence the prime minister will again stress his personal commitment to the health service and restate how three letters still sum up his priorities, N-H-S.

However, as well as trying to win over public opinion, Mr Cameron is also sending out a clear message to critics at Westminster that the "pause" to review the health bill is not the same as a "full stop" - and there will still be major changes.

Ahead of the speech, the chairman of the doctors' union, the British Medical Association, called for major alterations to the government's plans.

"We believe that the bill has to be radically changed and probably so radically that, in essence, it would really be a different bill," Dr Hamish Meldrum told BBC Radio Four's Today programme.

"It would be better to withdraw this bill and produce a new one. Nobody is saying there needs to be no change in the NHS, but the sort of change that is contemplated with the details of this bill are not the right changes."

Labour have have questioned whether the proposed legislation in its original form can continue.

"All the evidence is that the prime minister is going to press ahead with a bill that nobody voted for, is not properly thought through, and which NHS staff have been telling me are a complete shambles," opposition leader Ed Miliband said.

"The problem with this bill is that it is expensive, bureaucratic, and it is not properly thought through."

And shadow health secretary John Healey said the government's proposals needed a "root and branch" rethink.

"He (David Cameron) made the case for change in the NHS but not the changes in his bill."


More on This Story

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 288.

    There is certainly a lot to sort out: for instance, poor access to modern drugs, a service that serves itself rather than its patients, fixation with targets leading to a patient being discharged from hospital one day and brought back the next (personal experience). While much management is poor, however, there is no evidence that GPs will make it better. A bit of common sense would go a long way.

  • rate this

    Comment number 272.

    Some proposals seem fine, like chopping PCTs . But do most medical students start out because they want to run medical businesses? or is it to be doctors? Will they still be able to work as partners, answerable to their patients? Hardly; big companies will surely swallow them up. Competitive market? No thanks; the market's where I buy my vegetables.For my health I'd prefer health professionals.

  • rate this

    Comment number 239.

    I used to work for the NHS. It constantly needs reform, as it always has done. Unfortunately, the reforms that are most required are the ones that involve replacing Victorian buildings, they need some large investments that do not involve a private sector rip-off.

  • rate this

    Comment number 225.

    This debate on the NHS has gone on for far too long now. Why don't the government just put the bill through parliament, let the reforms come into effect and we'll see what effect they've had in a few years time. After all, the NHS can't get much worse than the state it's in at the moment.

  • rate this

    Comment number 165.

    I'm a registered nurse and I work hard looking after other people on a daily basis for less than people seem to assume - not all public sector workers are paid a fortune.

    My concern with the NHS reforms is not the idea of reform, we do need some and it needs looking at properly. But thats the problem this has not been and is being rushed in.


Comments 5 of 10


More Politics stories



Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.