Council rubbish bin collection fines to be scrapped

Rubbish collection Residents can receive a fixed-penalty notice if they repeatedly break the rules on rubbish collections

Related Stories

Fines for residents who break the rules on rubbish collections in England are to be scrapped.

Environment Secretary Caroline Spelman is expected to announce next month that the charges will be outlawed in all but the most serious cases of fly-tipping.

Meanwhile, ministers have warned councils against "charging by the back-door" for refuse services.

This includes forcing residents to buy "official" rubbish sacks from the council rather than other suppliers.

'Small minority'

At the moment, people can be fined with a fixed-penalty notice if they repeatedly break the rules covering rubbish collections, such as recycling incorrectly or leaving waste out on the wrong day.

The government will now remove most of those powers from English town halls, following a promise last year to scrap them.

The environmental campaign group Friends of the Earth argued fines should be retained for some persistent offenders.

Friends of the Earth campaigner Dr Michael Warhurst said councils should assist people so they are not fined through a lack of knowledge.

But he added: "If someone isn't recycling properly they can send someone round to help, and then if you go through and you find that someone is really deliberately not doing anything, that's when you start looking at fines."

Shadow environment secretary Mary Creagh said the government was "all over the place" on waste and recycling.

She said it announced a waste review last summer that still had not been published and added the Conservatives had abandoned any hope of achieving a "zero waste" Britain.

"They have nothing positive to say about working with local authorities to improve recycling and cut the amount of rubbish going to landfill," she said.

Meanwhile, Local Government Minister Bob Neill and Environment Minister Lord Henley have written to councils in England after concerns that a "small minority" were going beyond their legal powers to charge for refuse collections.

Their letter reminds local authorities they can charge for collecting bulky or garden waste but not regular rubbish.

Councils are also not allowed to impose a call-out fee if rubbish collectors arrive at a property but are unable for some reason to pick up the waste at that time.

Charging by 'backdoor'

The ministers said councils must not force residents to buy "official" rubbish sacks from the town hall in places where people had to purchase their own bags, warning that authorities should not create a monopoly.

They wrote: "In short, councils cannot introduce 'backdoor' bin charging for mainstream waste collections or waste disposal.

"Such stealth taxes are not legal and are contrary to the policy direction of the new government."

Ministers are currently passing legislation to get rid of the previous Labour government's policy of offering councils the chance to take part in pilot "pay-as-you-throw" schemes which charge households which create the most rubbish.

Lord Henley and Mr Neill said the government believed such initiatives would encourage fly-tipping and burning in gardens, and impose added costs to families which were already struggling financially.

In another development, councils appear to be rejecting government calls to change back from fortnightly to weekly bin collections.

In January Mr Neill said he wanted to "reverse the legacy of Labour's savage cutbacks to weekly rubbish collections".

But a survey of UK councils by the Press Association shows 69 of the 117 which responded had fortnightly pick ups, and of those none planned to increase the frequency of collections.

Many authorities warned their costs would dramatically increase, affecting efforts to raise their recycling rates.


More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 82.

    If this is the case, why is Oxford City Council just about to bring in a £35 / year charge for Garden Waste collection? Surely this will no longer be legal. Personally I'm not going to pay £35 for something that should be covered by my council tax - it's surely better to burn the garden waste instead and then put the ashes in the normal rubbish collection which is free!

  • rate this

    Comment number 77.

    Glad to see some common sense. However I am still concerned with the lack of enforcement to make supermarkets provide all their packaging in recyclable material. I try to do as best as I can but when it comes to I can't recycle this type of plastic or this type of cardboard. It's beyond belief.

    And I am also amazed that there is no standard in what recyclables councils will take.

  • rate this

    Comment number 20.

    Why do we have agist remarks on sites like this. As an elderly pensioner I have no difficulty in disinguishing between the various receptacles that I am asked to use for the different types of waste. In fact the evidence from what my neighbours put out it is the young couples without children who just can't be bothered to recycle.

  • rate this

    Comment number 13.

    If people persistently leave their bins in the street on the wrong day, or are persistently too lazy to sort their recycling, even after advice, information and warnings, I can't imagine what the objection is to fining them. Why should the rest of us put up with their selfishness - obstructions on the pavements and extra Council Tax for someone else to do the sorting?

  • rate this

    Comment number 7.

    Rubbish and recycling collections on an alternate fortnightly basis have worked just fine in our area for several years. Changing back to weekly collections must cost a lot more surely.


Comments 5 of 6


More Politics stories



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.